The Metropolitan Economic Freedom Index (MEFI) ranks cities based on their support of free market enterprise. In its current state, MEFI purports to measure three constructs (government spending, taxation, and labor market freedom) with three equally weighted variables for each one, assuming perfect substitutability of variables. This study investigates the statistical consistency of MEFI through Confirmatory Factor Analysis. Multiple models investigate current variable selection by providing a potentially better indicator of labor market freedom, aggregation assumptions by removing the requirements for fixed and equal weights, and statistical consistency by evaluating the fit between the data and models. Results indicate that the current MEFI model is not statistically consistent with the data, that weighting of variables should not be equal, that variable selection should be investigated, and that constructs should be re-imagined. The models investigated provide an initial starting point for redefining MEFI.
21 February 2026 in Health Care Management Science
In response to the growing number of hospital bankruptcies across the United States, this study sought to develop a predictive and interpretable model tailored specifically to the healthcare industry. Utilizing a longitudinal dataset of 3,091 short-term acute care hospitals from 2008 to 2021, we evaluated and compared traditional bankruptcy prediction models—Altman's Z'', Ohlson’s O-score, and Zmijewski’s model—against a newly developed hospital-specific logistic regression model (BRKFSST). We incorporated over 30 financial and hospital-level variables, including quality indicators, ownership type, and market characteristics. Unlike prior models, ours lagged all unknowable variables to ensure true out-of-sample prediction. The BRKFSST model achieved strong performance, with an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 81.8%, balanced accuracy of 72.2%, and a mean recall of 60.6% across multiple test/train splits, outperforming all benchmark models. Importantly, the model retained interpretability, allowing for the identification of key predictors such as labor compensation ratio, adjusted patient days, and quality ratings. These findings provide actionable insights for hospital leaders and policymakers to identify at-risk institutions and implement early interventions to prevent financial collapse and preserve access to care.
The Metropolitan Economic Freedom Index (MEFI) ranks cities based on their support of free market enterprise. In its current state, MEFI purports to measure three constructs (government spending, taxation, and labor market freedom) with three equally weighted variables for each one, assuming perfect substitutability of variables. This study investigates the statistical consistency of MEFI through Confirmatory Factor Analysis. Multiple models investigate current variable selection by providing a potentially better indicator of labor market freedom, aggregation assumptions by removing the requirements for fixed and equal weights, and statistical consistency by evaluating the fit between the data and models. Results indicate that the current MEFI model is not statistically consistent with the data, that weighting of variables should not be equal, that variable selection should be investigated, and that constructs should be re-imagined. The models investigated provide an initial starting point for redefining MEFI.
Rankings drive consequential decisions in science, sports, medicine, and business. Yet standard evaluations typically analyze concordance, dispersion, and extremeness in isolation, inviting biased inference when these properties co-move. We introduce the Concordance–Dispersion–Extremity Framework (CDEF), a copula-based, ranking-specific audit that treats dependence as the object of interest. CDEF (i) automatically detects forced vs.\ non-forced regimes; (ii) screens dispersion mechanics via $\chi^2$ (independent multinomial vs.\ without-replacement structure) and, for forced dependent data, compares Mallows structure against appropriate baselines; (iii) estimates upper-tail agreement between raters by fitting pairwise Gumbel copulas to mid-rank pseudo-observations and summarizes tail co-movement alongside Kendall’s $W$ and mutual information; and (iv) reports likelihood-based summaries and decision rules that distinguish \emph{genuine} from \emph{phantom} agreement. Applied to pre-season college football rankings, CDEF reinterprets apparently “high” concordance by revealing heterogeneity in pairwise tail dependence and dispersion patterns that inflate agreement under univariate analyses. Rather than claiming probabilities from a monolithic trivariate model, CDEF provides a transparent, regime-aware diagnosis showing when observed agreement is driven by tail dependence and shared rank usage instead of stable consensus. This dependence-centric view improves reliability assessment, surfaces bias, and supports sound decisions in settings where rankings carry real stakes.
\begin{highlights}\item AMS treats coordinate geometry as an empirical choice, selecting via cross-validated AICc between the only two transformations yielding $y$-invariant coefficient interpretability\item A nested selection framework: inner forward selection recovers sparse polynomials within candidate geometries, while outer cross-validated AICc selects the geometry with strongest held-out evidence\item 99.3\% joint success rate and thresholded sign accuracy across 288 experiments with high structural fidelity (Adaptive Interpretability Index of 0.92)\item Structural fidelity persists under misspecification: 100\% thresholded sign accuracy across six adversarial out-of-class functions\item Decisive coordinate selection across eight real-world benchmarks; AMS overfit gaps near zero against ensemble overfitting gaps reaching 0.597\end{highlights}
Medicare hospital cost reports constitute one of the largest longitudinal administrative datasets describing the financial and operational behavior of U.S.\ hospitals, yet they remain underutilized for proactive oversight and audit prioritization. This study introduces MOSAIC (Multi-Objective Signal Aggregation for Interpretable Classification), a weakly supervised forensic prioritization framework integrating analytical, behavioral, and model-based anomaly signals through multi-objective optimization. Applied to 83,512 hospital facility-years rom the Medicare Hospital Cost Report Information System (HCRIS) dataset (FY2011--2024), MOSAIC learns signal weights on a pre-pandemic Baseline regime (FY2012--2018) and applies them without modification to all other periods and validation data. MOSAIC achieves a Spearman concordance of $\rho_S = 0.5618$ with a financial distress anchor, compared with a maximum benchmark concordance of $\rho_S = 0.1173$. A signal-exclusion robustness analysis yields $\rho_S = 0.5394$, indicating that performance is not driven by anchor-adjacent variables or any single signal family. External validation using independent datasets of hospital bankruptcies and Medicare enforcement actions confirms that MOSAIC risk stratification anticipates real adverse events under a fully prospective design: risk scores constructed from prior-period ($t-1$) data identify high-risk facilities in subsequent periods ($t$), with approximately 53--54\% of events concentrated in the top two risk quintiles versus a 40\% null expectation. These findings demonstrate that distress-aligned anomaly risk in administrative healthcare data is better captured through domain-constrained multi-signal integration than standalone unsupervised or high-capacity reconstruction models, and that MOSAIC provides a scalable and interpretable framework for data-driven audit prioritization.