Recent theoretical studies have predicted that adiabatic compressed air energy storage (ACAES) can be an effective energy storage option in the future. However, major experimental projects and commercial ventures have so far failed to yield any viable prototypes. Here we explore the underlying reasons behind this failure. By developing an analytical idealized model of a typical ACAES design, we derive a design-dependent efficiency limit for a system with hypothetical, perfect components. This previously overlooked limit, equal to 93.6% under continuous cycling for a typical design, arises from irreversibility associated with the transient pressure in the system. Although the exact value is design dependent, the methodology we present for finding the limit is applicable for a wide range of designs. Turning to real systems, the limit alone does not fully explain the failure of practical ACAES research. However, reviewing the available evidence alongside our analytical model, we reason that underestimation of the system complexity, difficulty with the integration of off-the-shelf components, and a number of misleading performance claims are the primary reasons hindering ACAES development.
Adiabatic Compressed Air Energy Storage (ACAES) is regarded as a promising, grid scale, medium-to-long duration energy storage technology. In ACAES, the air storage may be isochoric (constant volume) or isobaric (constant pressure). Isochoric storage, wherein the internal pressure cycles between an upper and lower limit as the system charges and discharges is mechanically simpler, however, it leads to undesirable thermodynamic consequences which are detrimental to the ACAES overall performance. Isobaric storage can be a valuable alternative: the storage volume varies to offset the pressure and temperature changes that would otherwise occur as air mass enters or leaves the high-pressure storage. In this paper we develop a thermodynamic model based on expected ACAES and existing CAES system features to compare the effects of isochoric and isobaric storage. Importantly, off-design compressor performance due to the sliding storage pressure is included by using a second degree polynomial fit for the isentropic compressor efficiency. For our modelled systems, the isobaric system round-trip efficiency (RTE) reaches 61.5%. The isochoric system achieves 57.8% even when no compressor off-design performance decrease is taken into account. This fact is associated to inherent losses due to throttling and mixing of heat stored at different temperatures. In our base-case scenario where the isentropic compressor efficiency varies between and , the isochoric system RTE is approximately 10% lower than the isobaric. These results indicate that isobaric storage for CAES is worth further development. We suggest that subsequent work investigate the exergy flows as well as the scalability challenges with isobaric storage mechanisms.
27 February 2024 in Energy Conversion and Management
A combined heat store and heat exchanger unit (HSX) intended for compressed air energy storage (CAES) is presented. The unit is directly charged by the pressurised air emerging from the compression train, which removes the need for a secondary low‐pressure air circuit. Salt is used as the thermal storage medium due to its good heat capacity, thermal conductivity, and its ability to accommodate the thermal expansion of the stainless‐steel pipes. This paper uses a CAES system (15 MW, 12‐h discharge) driven by an offshore wind turbine as a case study. There are not many commercial CAES systems in operation; however, the levelized cost of the heat storage subsystem of a CAES system (i.e. heat store, set of heat exchangers and ancillary low‐pressure circuit) ranges between 45 and 48 £/MWh. Findings show that the most cost‐effective design for a HSX has a capital cost of ∼£55k. This translates into a levelized cost of storage of ∼31.5 £/MWh. The roundtrip exergy efficiency of this design is 93.7 %. This accounts for heat‐exergy and pressure‐exergy losses; losses to ambient are not considered. A HSX unit can considerably reduce the overall cost of a CAES system.
Adiabatic compressed air energy storage (ACAES) is an energy storage technology that has the potential to play an important role in the transition to a predominantly renewables‐driven net‐zero energy system. However, it has not yet achieved the performance necessary to be widely deployed. This paper undertakes an exergy analysis of isobaric and isochoric ACAES systems, tracking lost work through the components and exploring the influences of different design choices. Three different configurations are modelled: (1) 3 compression and 3 expansion stages; (2) 4 compression and 2 expansion stages; and (3) 2 compression and 4 expansion stages. These results illustrate that isobaric systems are likely to have higher round‐trip efficiency and significantly higher energy density, at the cost of achieving isobaric storage. Exergy analysis reveals that most of the losses arise in the compressors, compressor aftercoolers and expanders. Losses in aftercoolers are exaggerated when compressors operate with high‐pressure ratios, emphasizing that the choice of TES is a key system variable. With pressurised water as the coolant and TES fluid, it seems likely that the best system will have more compression than expansion stages. Increasing the number of compression stages decreases the off‐design penalty when the system is isochoric.