Reservoir evaluation is essential in oil and gas exploration, influencing development decisions. Traditional classification methods are often limited by small sample sizes and low accuracy, restricting their effectiveness. To address this, we propose an intelligent classification method, GA-XGBoost, which integrates Genetic Algorithm (GA) optimization with Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) to enhance the classification accuracy in small-sample scenarios. The lithological, physical, and lithofacies characteristics of tight sandstone reservoirs are analyzed, and key evaluation parameters—including the mineral composition, porosity, permeability, oil saturation, and logging data (GR, SP, CAL, DEN, AC, LLS)—are selected. After data normalization, the GA-XGBoost model is developed and compared with SVM, XGBoost, and AdaBoost models. The experimental results demonstrate that GA-XGBoost achieves an 88.8% classification precision, outperforming traditional algorithms in both efficiency and accuracy. This study advances experiments on and the standardization of intelligent reservoir evaluations, providing a more reliable classification approach for tight sandstone reservoirs. Additionally, it contributes to the integration of geological exploration and computational intelligence, offering new insights into the application of machine learning in geosciences.