(1) Methods for checking the condition of monumental masonry structures can still be considered understudied. Among the different approaches available in the literature, the graphical ones have a special role, due to their simplicity and effectiveness. (2) In this work, a 2D method (Thrust Line Analysis (TLA)), the Modified Thrust Line Method (MTLM), and the 3D Membrane Equilibrium Analysis (MEA) method are compared. All methods have the same starting concept: no tensile strength, no sliding between the stone blocks, infinite compressive strength. (3) The methods are compared in terms of stress distribution (for the same—or similar—thrust line), and in terms of the Geometrical Safety Factor ensured. (4) The work shows that these theories, if properly conveyed in a scientific methodology (as many authors are doing currently and have done in the past) demonstrate the effectiveness and the advantages of graphical methods for simple structures.
The behaviour of axisymmetric masonry shells can be simulated by a system of forces constituted by meridian forces acting in the vertical planes, and by hoop forces acting circumferentially. A crucial component for the assessment of these structures using the Modified Thrust Line Method (MTLM) is the determination of hoop forces, whose computation is strenuous, limiting the practical application of MTLM. Working around this limitation, the current research introduces a strategy to manipulate the hoop forces by graphically implementing a function describing their distribution. The adaptiveness of this distribution function not only allows the application of MTLM for the analysis of a range of geometries, but also enables the simulation of membrane behaviour, arch behaviour and their combination, for considering partially cracked structures. Taking this into account, the approach is applied in the case studies illustrated within the current research.
The building sector has a significant impact on the environment due to its unproductive and technologically outdated practices. Although digital tools have emerged as potential solutions, current building practices often lack automation and efficiency. Throughout history, several self-supporting techniques, i.e., construction methods dedicated to the building of shells that do not need support during the construction works, have been developed. These techniques allow for reducing waste and minimizing construction costs. Combining self-supporting techniques and digital tools could aid the development of contemporary, highly sustainable, and efficient building practices that permit the use of alternative and sustainable materials. Building on this, the research conducted defines an approach for evaluating the balanced state of masonry structures during construction works and built using robotic technologies. The approach considers the factors that govern the stability under construction derived through studying self-supporting building techniques. The proposed approach assesses the structural state under construction, evaluating the need for temporary supports. An example of a masonry arch is provided to emphasize the importance of construction factors in sustainable building practices. Then the method is applied to a real case study. Overall, integrating self-supporting techniques with digital tools has the potential to revolutionize the building sector, and create highly sustainable and efficient practices.
1 September 2025 in International Journal of Space Structures
The interaction of geometry, structure and construction design in the I Live with Nature shell is the focus of the paper. The demonstrator consists of a masonry shell with a corrugated single-leaf cross-section composed of modular units. The installation was built within a 16-day timeframe for the 2024 Shenzhen Flower Show. Structural and construction parameters were embedded into the early design process, aiming to eliminate the need for scaffolding and temporary guidework. Global and construction-phase structural analyses, based on the Discrete Element Method (DEM), accounted for time-dependent mortar behaviour to evaluate stability during construction. Augmented Reality (AR) technology was utilised for digital tracing, enabling scaffold-free assembly without the need for physical drawings. The combination of structural and construction design, numerical analyses and innovative technology enables the construction of complex geometries, ensuring accuracy and boosting construction productivity. The I Live with Nature shell was completed for the Greater Bay Area Shenzhen Flower Show 2024, an international event that has taken place annually in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area (China) since 2019. The shell is conceived as a landscape installation that embodies the integration of urban life and nature, celebrating the aesthetic and ecological benefits of incorporating natural elements into the built environment.
This contribution is the first step of a multi-disciplinary research project, aimed at studying the roof of the tholos of Athena Pronaia in Delphi, dating back to the first decades of the 4th century BC. The starting point of this research is the fascination exerted by the tectonic quality of the temple, comprising some complex fragments of marble tiles belonging to the roof of the tholos. Despite the number of studies on this sanctuary, the poor state of preservation and lack of original material did not allow archaeologists to perform concluding research on its original configuration, in particular with reference to the reconstruction of the roof. Aware of the complexity of this topic, this contribution aims at exploring two possibilities, namely, on the one hand, that the fragments of tiles constitute elements supported by a wooden structure, and on the other hand, that they are structural elements of a stone system subjected to compressive stresses. Our contribution intends to serve as food for thought on the need for archaeological studies to be accompanied not only by advanced surveys in the field, aimed at the precise definition of the geometry of the finds, but also by architectural and structural investigations which make it possible to verify the feasibility of the hypothetical reconstructions of the architectural elements aware of the construction techniques used in the past.