Metabarcoding fecal matter is increasingly common in dietary studies across a variety of taxa. This approach assumes that enough prey DNA remains detectable in the fecal DNA (fDNA) as the prey DNA becomes degraded while passing through the digestive tract. However, as prey DNA is degraded during digestion, diet reconstruction based on metabarcoding of fDNA could become incomplete, i.e., species for which DNA was highly degraded would not be detected. The purpose of this study was to test the use of cloacal swabs and metabarcoding fDNA for shark diet reconstruction. To do this, both stomach contents and cloacal swabs were collected from the same individual sharks and metabarcoded using two previously published primer sets targeting teleost fishes and crustaceans. Samples were collected from four coastal species of sharks in a temperate estuary: bonnethead ( Sphyrna tiburo
; n
= 10), blacknose ( Carcharhinus acronotus
; n
= 4), blacktip ( C. limbatus
; n
= 4), and Atlantic sharpnose ( Rhizoprionodon terraenovae
; n
= 5). We determined how well the fDNA represented the corresponding prey DNA from the stomach contents (stDNA) and found no statistical difference in taxonomic richness or diversity when comparing the two sample types. Our results indicate that the less invasive, non‐lethal method of DNA metabarcoding cloacal swabs provided higher taxonomic resolution than more common methods for studying trophic ecology (i.e., morphological stomach contents identification and trophic biomarkers such as stable isotope analysis) with no statistical difference in overall diet description between the two sample types.
Abiotic environmental stress is a fundamental driver of population and community dynamics across diverse ecosystems (Menge and Sutherland 1987). In this context, specialist species persisting at great altitudes or depths, in near-boiling or subfreezing temperatures, through droughts or monsoons, and over prolonged bouts of resource deprivation highlight the adaptability of life on Earth.
Feeding patterns of sheepshead, Archosargus probatocephalus, in the northwest Gulf of Mexico were examined from samples collected at two locations in Texas, USA; Galveston and Port Aransas. A total of 53 sheepshead stomachs (Galveston, n = 35; Port Aransas, n = 18) had their contents analyzed along with tissue samples from the muscle and liver for a stable isotope analysis (δ13C, δ15N, and δ34S) because they provide a contrast between short-term (liver) and long-term (muscle) measurements. Multiple species of amphipods made up the majority of the prey items in sheepshead from Galveston (%IRI = 61.79), whereas barnacles were the primary diet item for sheepshead collected in Port Aransas (%IRI = 39.53). We observed diet shifts prior to and during the spawning season. MANOVA revealed significant differences in δ13C, δ15N, and δ34S stable isotope values from the muscle and liver tissue of sheepshead based on the location. In both muscle and liver samples, δ13C values were lower in Galveston than Port Aransas, but δ15N and δ34S values were higher in Galveston than Port Aransas. Niche size and overlap also differed between sheepshead from both locations and tissue types. Sheepshead collected in Galveston had a larger niche size in the muscle and liver samples ((mean ± SD) 479.3 ± 131.2, muscle; 433.3 ± 120.3, liver) than Port Aransas (178.8 ± 54.3, muscle; 270.0 ± 80.9, liver). The trophic niche of sheepshead from Galveston overlapped Port Aransas in muscle samples by 16.47% and 18.56% in liver samples. The trophic niche overlap of sheepshead from Port Aransas measured in muscle samples overlapped with sheepshead from Galveston by 18.49% and by 39.17% in liver samples. This study shows that there are subtle but significant differences between the diets of sheepshead along the Texas coast, with the majority of the differences potentially attributable to differences in the prey field along the natural salinity gradient of the Texas coast. This work provides an insight into the widely generalist grazing behavior of sheepshead, which potentially changes during the springtime spawning season.