A substantial portion of seafood is mislabeled, causing significant impacts to human health, the environment, the economy, and society. Despite the large scientific literature documenting seafood mislabeling the public’s awareness of seafood mislabeling is unknown. We conducted an online survey to assess the public’s awareness and perceptions of seafood mislabeling. Of the 1,216 respondents, 38% had never heard of seafood mislabeling and 49% were only ‘vaguely familiar’ with it. After being provided the definition of seafood mislabeling 95% had some degree of concern. Respondents were the most concerned about environmental impacts caused by seafood mislabeling and the least concerned about the social justice implications. Respondents who were also more concerned and familiar with seafood mislabeling stated that they would be more likely to purchase seafood from a vendor where the labeling was independently verified.
In the United States, shark meat is sold in grocery stores, seafood markets, and online. The meat is often mislabeled as another species or generically labeled as “shark”. The ambiguity of these generic labels makes it challenging to assess the conservation implications of this practice and for consumers to avoid high trophic-level species that often have high mercury concentrations in their tissues. We purchased and DNA barcoded 29 shark products in the United States to determine their species identity. Our samples consisted of 19 filets sold in grocery stores, seafood markets, and Asian specialty markets (mostly in North Carolina) and 10 ordered online as “jerky”. Ninety three percent of samples (27 of 29) were ambiguously labeled as shark or mako shark but not as a specific species. Of the two samples that were labeled to species, one was mislabeled (e.g., shortfin mako shark labeled as blacktip shark) and the other was correctly labeled. Barcoding indicated that the 29 samples included 11 different species of shark, including three species listed by the IUCN as Critically Endangered: great hammerhead, scalloped hammerhead, and tope. Previous studies have found that the first two species contain very high levels of mercury, illustrating the implications of seafood mislabeling for human health. The availability of shark meat in U.S. grocery stores is surprising given the dramatic decline of shark populations globally. Moreover, the fact that nearly all shark meat is labeled ambiguously or incorrectly amplifies the problem. Accurate, verified product labels for shark meat would benefit consumers and shark conservation efforts, and should be a priority for the seafood industry.
Metabarcoding fecal matter is increasingly common in dietary studies across a variety of taxa. This approach assumes that enough prey DNA remains detectable in the fecal DNA (fDNA) as the prey DNA becomes degraded while passing through the digestive tract. However, as prey DNA is degraded during digestion, diet reconstruction based on metabarcoding of fDNA could become incomplete, i.e., species for which DNA was highly degraded would not be detected. The purpose of this study was to test the use of cloacal swabs and metabarcoding fDNA for shark diet reconstruction. To do this, both stomach contents and cloacal swabs were collected from the same individual sharks and metabarcoded using two previously published primer sets targeting teleost fishes and crustaceans. Samples were collected from four coastal species of sharks in a temperate estuary: bonnethead ( Sphyrna tiburo
; n
= 10), blacknose ( Carcharhinus acronotus
; n
= 4), blacktip ( C. limbatus
; n
= 4), and Atlantic sharpnose ( Rhizoprionodon terraenovae
; n
= 5). We determined how well the fDNA represented the corresponding prey DNA from the stomach contents (stDNA) and found no statistical difference in taxonomic richness or diversity when comparing the two sample types. Our results indicate that the less invasive, non‐lethal method of DNA metabarcoding cloacal swabs provided higher taxonomic resolution than more common methods for studying trophic ecology (i.e., morphological stomach contents identification and trophic biomarkers such as stable isotope analysis) with no statistical difference in overall diet description between the two sample types.
Juvenile blacktip sharks (Carcharhinus limbatus) are highly abundant in the mangrove-fringed bays throughout the Galapagos Archipelago, utilizing these habitats as nursery grounds. Due to spatial variation in factors including temperature and larval connectivity, fish species richness is higher in the eastern portion of the archipelago. Predator diets often reflect regional prey availability, leading us to hypothesize that juvenile blacktip sharks in the eastern Galapagos would have greater prey taxa richness than those in the west. Here, we used DNA metabarcoding of fecal matter collected via non-lethal cloacal swabs to describe and quantify juvenile blacktip shark diets. We collected samples from 107 sharks across 240 km, spanning 14 bays on four islands, and released all sharks alive. The most common prey taxa identified were Thoburn’s mullet (Mugil thoburni; 20.0%, based on percent of occurrence), followed by fishes in the genus Abudefduf (sergeant-majors; 13.4%), Galapagos ringtail damselfish (Stegastes beebei; 12.7%), scalloped hammerhead shark (Sphyrna lewini; 11.7%), and yellowtail damselfish (Stegastes arcifrons; 10.7%). Prey taxa richness was highest among sharks sampled in the bays of San Cristobal, possibly due to geographic variation in prey availability. Additionally, sharks sampled during a La Niña event in 2021 had higher prey taxa richness than those sampled during an El Niño event in 2023, which could be due to El Niño-induced declines in species richness and abundance resulting from shifts in primary productivity and upwelling. A deeper understanding of shark diets can improve our ability to predict how changes in food web dynamics and prey availability affect shark populations. This knowledge is especially vital in the face of overfishing and climate change, helping to inform more effective conservation strategies and support shark survival.
The Atlantic sharpnose (Rhizoprionodon terraenovae), blacknose (Carcharhinus acronotus), blacktip (Carcharhinus limbatus), and bonnethead (Sphyrna tiburo) sharks are commonly encountered large mobile consumers found in the estuaries along the western North Atlantic coast. The bulk of the dietary data for these species has been coarsely recorded at a broad taxonomic level (e.g., “teleost fish”). Here, we used DNA metabarcoding of fecal DNA collected using non-lethal cloacal swabs to identify the species of prey contributing to the diets of these shark species and measure the degree of trophic overlap. Samples were collected from 24 Atlantic sharpnose, 33 blacknose, six blacktip, and 17 bonnethead sharks in the summer of 2020. Based on previous dietary research on these shark species, we targeted teleost fishes and crustaceans using two previously published primer sets. From the 80 sharks sampled off the coast of North Carolina, we identified 38 prey taxa, with 82% classified to the species level and all assigned to at least the genus and family levels. The most common prey taxa found in the diet of the bonnethead was Atlantic blue crab (Callinectes sapidus; 44.75%, based on percent of occurrence) followed by penaeid shrimp (Penaeus spp.; 24.41%), mantis shrimp (Squilla empusa; 20.34%), and spot (Leiostomus xanthurus; 4.75%). Atlantic sharpnose and blacknose sharks had the largest Levin’s niche overlap, with both species relying on the same two most frequently consumed prey taxa: penaeid shrimp (Atlantic sharpnose: 33.33%, percent of occurrence, and blacknose: 34.78%) and spot (Atlantic sharpnose: 32.70% and blacknose: 22.32%). Bonnetheads and blacktips had the least amount of overlap between all shark species, where blacktips primarily consumed menhaden (Brevoortia spp.; 58.62%) and penaeid shrimp (26.44%). Our findings highlight the value of DNA metabarcoding in refining our understanding of predator diets, moving beyond broad taxonomic classifications to identify species-level prey associations and trophic interactions. As coastal habitats undergo increasing alteration due to anthropogenic impacts, such information is crucial for fisheries management, helping to identify key prey dependencies and anticipate potential ecosystem shifts.
Shark meat is widely available in the United States in grocery stores and seafood markets. The meat is often mislabeled or generically labeled as “shark”. The ambiguity of these generic labels makes it challenging to assess the conservation implications of this practice and for consumers to avoid species with high mercury concentrations. For this study we purchased and DNA barcoded 30 shark products purchased in the United States to determine their species identity and conservation status. These samples consisted of 19 filets sold in grocery stores, seafood markets, and Asian specialty markets (mostly in North Carolina) and 11 ordered online as “jerky”. 70% of samples were “soft mislabeled” (i.e., labeled generically as shark but not as a specific species). Of the nine samples labeled to species, eight were mislabeled (e.g., spinner shark labeled as mako shark). Only one sample was correctly labeled. All 30 samples were identified as shark and came from 11 different species, including three species listed by the IUCN as Critically Endangered: great hammerhead, scalloped hammerhead, and tope. The first two species have been found to contain very high levels of mercury, illustrating the implications of seafood mislabeling for human health. The widespread availability of shark meat in U.S. grocery stores is surprising given the dramatic decline of shark populations globally. Moreover, the fact that nearly all shark meat is either mislabeled or not labeled to species amplifies the problem. Accurate, verified product labels for shark meat would benefit consumers and shark conservation efforts, and should be a priority for the seafood industry.