Wastewater from mining and other industries usually contains arsenic and cyanide, two highly toxic pollutants, thereby creating the need to develop bioremediation strategies. Here, molecular mechanisms triggered by the simultaneous presence of cyanide and arsenite were analyzed by quantitative proteomics, complemented with qRT-PCR analysis and determination of analytes in the cyanide-assimilating bacterium Pseudomonas pseudoalcaligenes CECT 5344. Several proteins encoded by two ars gene clusters and other Ars-related proteins were up-regulated by arsenite, even during cyanide assimilation. Although some proteins encoded by the cio gene cluster responsible for cyanide-insensitive respiration decreased in the presence of arsenite, the nitrilase NitC required for cyanide assimilation was unaffected, thus allowing bacterial growth with cyanide and arsenic. Two complementary As-resistance mechanisms were developed in this bacterium, the extrusion of As(III) and its extracellular sequestration in biofilm, whose synthesis increased in the presence of arsenite, and the formation of organoarsenicals such as arseno-phosphoglycerate and methyl-As. Tetrahydrofolate metabolism was also stimulated by arsenite. In addition, the ArsH2 protein increased in the presence of arsenite or cyanide, suggesting its role in the protection from oxidative stress caused by both toxics. These results could be useful for the development of bioremediation strategies for industrial wastes co-contaminated with cyanide and arsenic.
Quantitative proteomics relies on robust statistical methods for differential expression, critically impacting downstream functional enrichment. This meta-analysis systematically investigated how statistical hypothesis testing approaches and criteria for defining biological relevance influence functional enrichment concordance. We reanalyzed five independent label-free quantitative proteomics datasets using diverse frequentist (t-test, Limma, DEqMS, MSstats) and Bayesian (rstanarm) approaches. Concordance of Gene Ontology (GO) and KEGG pathways was assessed using Jaccard indices and correlation metrics, grouping comparisons by statistical test and biological relevance consistency. The results demonstrated highly significant differences in similarity distributions among the comparison groups. Comparisons varying only hypothesis testing methods (with constant relevance criteria, FC or Bayesian) showed the highest consistency. Conversely, comparisons with differing biological relevance criteria (or varied methodological choices) yielded significantly lower consistency, highlighting this definition’s critical impact on GO term overlaps. KEGG pathways displayed more uniform, method-insensitive concordance. Sensitivity analysis confirmed the findings’ robustness, underscoring that methodological choices profoundly influence functional enrichment outcomes. This work emphasizes the critical need for transparency and careful consideration of analytical decisions in proteomics research to ensure reproducible and biologically sound interpretations.
Quantitative proteomics analyses rely on robust statistical methods for differential expression, impacting downstream pathway and functional enrichment. This meta-analysis investigated the influence of Hypothesis Testing Methods (HTMs) and Criteria for Biological Relevance (CBRs) on functional enrichment concordance. Five independent label-free quantitative proteomics datasets were reanalyzed using diverse frequentist (t-test, Limma, DEqMS, MSstats) and a Bayesian (rstanarm) approach. Concordance of enriched terms was assessed using Jaccard indices, categorized by four comparison types: Intra-HTM_FC_CBR, Intra-HTM_Bayes_CBR, Intra-CBR_Fixed_HTM, and Inter-HTM_Inter_CBR. Results showed highly significant differences in Jaccard similarity distributions among comparison types (Kruskal-Wallis p = 5e-04). “Intra-HTM_FC_CBR” exhibited the highest consistency, indicating minor HTM influence when using FC-based CBR. “Intra-CBR_Fixed_HTM” also maintained high concordance, suggesting robust agreement between FC and Bayesian CBRs when HTM is fixed. Conversely, “Intra-HTM_Bayes_CBR” and “Inter-HTM_Inter-CBR” showed the lowest consistency, highlighting the critical impact of Bayesian method choice and mixed comparisons on functional overlaps, particularly for Gene Ontology terms. KEGG pathways displayed more uniform, method-insensitive concordance. Sensitivity analysis confirmed the robustness of these findings. This study underscores that analytical choices profoundly influence functional enrichment outcomes, emphasizing the need for transparency and careful consideration in proteomics research to ensure reproducibility.