This paper concerns about a failure analysis of an electric all aluminum alloy conductor (AAAC) damaged and broken for fretting fatigue phenomena induced by aeolian vibrations. Life of electric conductors is often reduced by various degradation mechanisms such as repeated bending, fluctuating tension, distortion, fatigue, wear and corrosion phenomena. However the main limiting factor of the electrical conductors is related to aeolian vibrations in the high frequency range (between 5 to 50 Hz). Conductor oscillations may lead to fretting fatigue problems (otherwise called fretting wear) caused by wind excitation, mainly in the suspension clamp regions, spacers or other fittings. The induced aluminium wire fracture imply a drastic reduction in the transmission line service. Vibration dampers are considered the most effective method to extend service life of electric conductors, as they are the means to reduce fretting damage of aluminium wires. The aim of the present work is to investigate the failure of an AAAC conductor of a 400kV overhead transmission line (twin conductors) located in Touggourt Biskra (Algeria); the damaged and broken conductors were operated in-service only for six months without spacers or dampers. Three different types of conductors have been taken as experimental samples: the in-service broken conductor, another in-service damaged conductor and a new conductor from warehouse as terms of comparison. Samples have been analysed to identify the root cause of the failure and to verify the conformity of the conductor elements to the international standards. The investigation has outlined the morphology of the fretting damage: in all cases the fractured wires have shown typical static deformation marks and dynamic fretting wear tangential marks associated with intense presence of Al2O3 debris.
1 December 2006 in Surface and Coatings Technology
A deep comprehension of the damage mechanisms involved in contact fatigue is basic to optimize materials and heat treatments for specific applications. In this work, rolling disc-on-disc contact fatigue tests have been performed on three different materials: a hardened and tempered UNI EN 42CrMo4, a nitrided UNI EN 42CrMo4 steel, and a carburized UNI EN 18NiCrMo5 steel. The test method adopted was optimized to better realize such conditions able to develop micropitting on different materials. The main aim of this test campaign was to investigate and compare damage on surface, in terms of initiating and propagating mechanisms. Extensive microfractographic analyses were performed on the damaged samples by the use of a scanning electronic microscope (SEM). For hardened and tempered steel, failure mode was micropitting, started from surface, but evolved into pitting because of crack path extending more deeply beneath the surface. Pits always originated on top surface and propagated as like a common fatigue crack. In the case of carburized steel, micropitting initiated at oxides at most surface grain boundaries, i.e., those sites characterized by greatest brittleness. Superficial cracks initiated and propagated inside the white layer for the nitrided steel. Once initiated, micropits may develop. Damaging rate can significantly increase by coalescence of small closest pits into a larger crater so much that micropitting phenomena do not arrest, but it can degenerate into destructive pitting and spalling. Significant differences, however, exist for ductile surface or hardened one.