European member states have high emission reduction potential. They send a strong signal to the rest of the world with their action or inaction on climate change. Yet, within the EU, national-level climate policies (NLCP) lag behind the EU Commission’s overall climate goals. Transparency of and accountability for climate action requires an integrative perspective. Here, insights from diverse research disciplines address the following questions: How are climate impacts, public attitudes, and climate policies changing over time, and what are the interlinkages? Using three databases (Germanwatch (CCPI), European Extreme Events Climate Index (E3CI), and Eurobarometer Public Opinion Survey, 27 European countries were compared for NLCP (mitigation), climate change impacts (heat/drought), and public attitudes towards climate change (cognition/affect/conation). Differences among groups before and after the Paris Agreement were evaluated with ANOVA tests; trends and geographical differences were analysed with linear models. NLCP did not improve after the Paris Agreement, even displaying some deterioration in the eastern macro-region. Conversely, public awareness towards climate change is improving, with concern being higher in northern compared with southern countries. Heat stress is significantly related to NLCP, with increases in heat stress corresponding to improved climate policy in the northern region while worsening it in the southern region. Under worsening climate impacts, public attitudes increasingly favour climate action. However, overall policy responses are inadequate, although differences occur at the macro-regional level. The results provide granular insights into a persistent knowledge–action gap.
Verifying greenhouse gas (GHG) mitigation efforts of governments using atmospheric observations is a task which is rapidly gaining scientific interest and attention. The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) requires the compilation of National Inventory Reports and recommends augmenting them with observational data. The joint project ITMS (Integriertes Treibhausgas-Monitoringsystem für Deutschland) is Germany's national contribution to the World Meteorological Organization’s Integrated Global Greenhouse Gas Information System (IG3IS). It will establish the scientific basis and methodology for integrating GHG observations into the national emissions inventories. Our focus within the ITMS joint project is to optimize observation strategies for monitoring fossil CO2 emissions in German urban and metropolitan areas using synthetic studies. Focusing on cities is especially relevant as cities are substantial contributors to total anthropogenic CO2 emissions. Our study uses the Weather Research and Forecasting model (WRF v4.3.3) with ECMWF-ERA5 as meteorological input and boundary conditions. As a first step, we have optimized model transport such that our results are representative of real-world conditions as much as possible. Within comprehensive sensitivity studies, we have analyzed the optimal model settings for German urban areas. Our sensitivity studies focus on the Rhine-Neckar region and compare 16 different physics configurations of WRF for 4 months of 2020, representative of the four seasons. Modeled meteorological variables were compared against 19 meteorological observation stations operated by the German Weather Service and 2 radiosonde stations. We found the setup using Mellor-Yamada-Janjic boundary layer, Noah MP land surface, Monin-Obukhov surface layer and BEP urban parametrization scheme has the overall best performance for our use case. Using the optimal setup for urban areas in WRF, we have generated a year-long, 1km resolved dataset of German metropolitan areas. This dataset contains meteorological and sector specific CO2 enhancement data for the year 2018. These metropolitan areas include the Rhine-Neckar, Berlin, Rhine-Ruhr, Nuremberg and Munich metropolitan areas. We showcase the usefulness of the dataset by comparison to actual observations in cities.
3 June 2026 in Elementa: Science of the Anthropocene
Accurate knowledge about urban carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions is essential to support effective climate change mitigation. Yet large discrepancies among emission inventories within cities highlight the need for well-designed atmospheric CO2 sensor networks that can deliver independent CO2 emission estimates. Most cities still lack observation systems capable of meeting this challenge. We conducted Observing System Simulation Experiments (OSSEs) for 2 German cities, Berlin and Munich, to assess how the number, quality, and placement of in situ CO2 sensors affect the ability to quantify city-wide emissions under various error conditions. The experiments included random errors from transport and limited precision of the sensors, as well as systematic biases arising from background concentration errors and limited sensor accuracy. Networks were evaluated by their ability to recover assumed true emissions from incorrect prior assumptions using simulated measurements in a Bayesian inversion framework. The results show that thoroughly investigating network designs using OSSEs prior to physical deployment enables identification of optimal sensor locations that substantially improve emission estimates compared to random placement. Across all tested error cases, we found mid- and high-cost sensors to provide reliable constraints on total city emissions, but mid-cost sensors can introduce biases on sub-urban scales. Sensors with accuracies of 5 ppm or worse produced considerably smaller improvements or even degraded prior emission estimates. Spatially uniform background errors could generally be corrected through an appropriate choice of state vector, whereas spatially varying biases propagated into the inferred emission patterns. These findings were consistent across both cities, suggesting their applicability to similar urban areas. This study thereby provides practical guidance for designing cost-effective urban emission monitoring networks and highlights the importance of assessing diverse error contributions within a network’s planning phase.
High-resolution monitoring is the basis for CO2 emissions tracking and attribution in urban areas. This work is an important step towards an integrated urban CO2 emissions monitoring system. Three middle-cost nondispersive infrared (NDIR) sensors of 500€ to 3000€ are characterised. Furthermore, CO2 emissions of large, regional point sources are simulated to analyse their effect on these sensors’ signals.The three sensors are Vaisala GMP343, Senseair HPP3 and SmartGas FlowEvo CO2. Their analysis and characterisation is achieved by co-locating them with a Picarro G2401 cavity ringdown spectrometer for 40 days. Co-locating different middle-cost sensors is novel and enables a direct performance comparison. While the HPP3 is the only one to reach a 1 min mean standard deviation under 1 ppm, the GMP343 is the most linear and stable with a drift of 0.03(2) × 10−1 ppm per day and the SmartGas sensor provides the best price-to-performance ratio. For all sensors, precisions (the 1 min mean error’s lower bound) of under 0.8 ppm are determined. In general, temperature stabilisation turns out to be one of the most promising avenues of performance improvement for all sensors.The sensors’ in-situ measurements are combined with meso-scale meteorological simulations for the Rhine-Neckar region using the Weather Research and Forecasting model (WRF). In two case-studies, simulated excess CO2 due to large, regional point sources and measured CO2 concentration are compared. Both simulations show qualitative agreement with the measurements. The differences between measurements and simulation, however, highlight aspects to be refined. These include increasing the horizontal and vertical resolution of the simulation domain as well improving as the parametrisation of the planetary and urban boundary layer.
Quantifying sources and sinks, as well as chemical activity of trace gases in the lower troposphere, requires accurate measurements of the concentrations of the species of interest. While there exist in-situ measurement techniques, which are highly accurate, point-like measurements are only sufficiently representative in the spatial domain for a small area. This holds true in particular in high-gradient environments, e.g., urban settings. Hence, measuring those concentrations averaged on the length scale of a few kilometers is desirable. Furthermore, quantifying emissions requires combining concentration measurements with regional transport models, which cover a comparable spatial resolution.We present a long open-path setup that measures average concentrations on the kilometer-scale in the urban boundary layer. Our setup, which is operational since March 2022, is based on a Bruker IFS 125 HR Fourier transform spectrometer, a commercially available spectrometer, which offers high resolution and throughput. The instrument choice provides flexible and explorative experimental setups such as variable and high spectral resolution and the extension of spectral coverage from the shortwave-infrared to the near ultra-violet spectral range. Here, we present the results on CO2 and CH4 from our 2022 measurement campaign as well as analysis of the diurnal variability in comparison to the prediction of local and regional transport models.