Although the construction industry has shown significant improvements in safety performance over the past 30 years, falls are still a leading cause of fatalities and serious injuries. Previous studies have focused on identifying factors affecting the risk of falls, but remained silent on investigating the evidential relationships among these factors to better prevent fall accidents. This research proposes a Bayesian network (BN) based approach to diagnose the accident risk of working at heights. The proposed approach consists of a conceptual and generic model with a protocol for assessing the risk of falls and a computational module. The generic BN model was developed on the basis of an extensive review and evaluation of causal factors leading to falls. The computational module was developed on the basis of Bayes’ rule for inference to customize model input and job site characteristics. The results of the proposed approach provide probabilities associated with different states of safety risk. Addi...
1 February 2018 in Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
The design-build (D-B) project delivery method has been used increasingly by state departments of transportation (DOTs) because of its documented benefits. Many studies have shown the superior performance of D-B projects when compared to traditional design-bid-build (D-B-B) projects. However, these studies often rely on experts’ judgments or small sample sizes based on data collected from surveys, interviews, or case studies. There are few, if any, empirical studies that have compared D-B-B and D-B highway project performance by work types. This research analyzed 139 pairs of D-B-B and D-B highway projects built by the Florida DOT. The 139 pairs of projects were classified into five categories of work types: (1) new construction; (2) reconstruction; (3) resurfacing, restoration, rehabilitation (3R) projects; (4) intelligent transportation systems (ITS)–related projects; and (5) miscellaneous construction such as sidewalks, bike lanes, or landscaping. The study employed both parametric and nonparametric statistical tests to compare cost growth, schedule growth, and construction intensity metrics across the five project work types. The results show that D-B projects statistically perform better than D-B-B in terms of cost growth and schedule growth for miscellaneous construction and 3R project work types, respectively. Design-build projects also statistically provide a higher construction intensity (more work put in place) than D-B-B for new construction and reconstruction work types. No statistically significant differences between D-B-B and D-B projects were found for other project work types. This study contributes to the construction engineering and management body of knowledge by providing empirical comparisons between D-B-B and D-B project performance on the basis of different types of work. The findings from this paper may provide guidance for state DOTs and practitioners to select D-B project delivery for specific work types and benchmarks D-B against D-B-B.
1 May 2018 in Journal of Management in Engineering
The highway industry currently uses three fundamental delivery methods, design-bid-build (D-B-B), design-build (D-B), and construction manager/general contractor (CM/GC), to deliver transportation projects. Selecting an appropriate project delivery method is a complex decision and often fraught with risk and uncertainty. This article presents the results of a two-tiered approach to evaluating the impacts of risks and uncertainties on project delivery selection in highway projects. Tier 1 involved identifying and verifying 31 risk factors related to project delivery based on the responses of experts with an average of 25 years of relevant experience. Tier 2 involved an empirical evaluation of project delivery risks through the analysis of 274 completed highway projects (122 D-B-B, 118 D-B, and 34 CM/GC) collected from 26 transportation agencies. The risk score of each risk factor was determined. The Cronbach’s alpha test and correlation analysis were conducted to verify the internal consistency, interdependency, and reliability of delivery risk factors. The results showed that the following eight risk factors substantially impact the project delivery decision: (1) delays in completing in railroad agreements, (2) project complexity, (3) uncertainty in geotechnical investigation, (4) delays in a right-of-way (ROW) process, (5) unexpected utility encounter, (6) work-zone traffic control, (7) challenges to obtaining environmental documentation, and (8) delays in delivery schedules. These eight risk factors are discussed in detail using the content analysis of Tier 1 and the relevant literature. Highway agencies and other practitioners can use these risk factors to make more effective and defensible decisions on which delivery method is the most suitable for their transportation projects.
1 October 2018 in Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
Best-value (BV) procurement is increasingly used in conventional design-bid-build (DBB) delivery, which raises questions regarding the influence of qualifications-based evaluation criteria when selecting construction contractors. The objectives of this study are to (1) examine BV procurement outcomes that can be expected from DBB projects, (2) determine which evaluation criteria have the greatest dispersion among competing contractors, and (3) identify whether a relationship exists between cost- and qualifications-based proposal submissions. A sample of 162 public institutional BV-procured DBB projects was collected that include evaluation results of 684 contractor proposals. Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used, including coefficient of variation and correlation analysis of evaluation criteria. The results show that BV-selected contractors offer substantial qualifications benefits in comparison with lowest- and average-bidder alternatives. Certain qualifications-based criteria, such as technical proposals, contractor interview scores, and safety proposals were found to have a greater dispersion among competing bidders than cost proposals. Contributions of this study to the body of knowledge include a sizable empirical data set of BV-procured DBB projects in the vertical sector and a unit of measure that considers dispersion among competing contractor proposals. In current construction industry practice, it is recommended that project owners consider BV for complex DBB projects and prioritize certain qualifications-based criteria that are well-suited for differentiating between competing contractor proposals.
Cross-impact analysis (CIA) is a technique that is designed to predict future events by capturing the interactions among variables. It is an appropriate tool to deal with the selection of a project delivery method. Project delivery selection involves the assessment of tradeoffs between numerous risks and uncertainties, complex relationships among variables, and multiple decision alternatives. In fact, the number of variables involved in project delivery decisions creates CIA models that are extremely complex, and few researchers have attempted to apply them. This paper presents a hybrid CIA approach to project delivery decisions in highway design and construction. It provides for the evaluation of project cost with projects in three fundamental delivery methods: design-bid-build (DBB), design-build (DB), and construction manager/general contractor (CMGC). The paper discusses in detail how the cross-impact concepts support the selection of an appropriate delivery method in highway projects. The hyb...
1 March 2018 in Journal of Management in Engineering
Alternative project delivery methods such as design-build (D-B) and construction manager/general contractor (CM/GC) or construction manager at risk (CMR) are typically used in conjunction with best-value or qualification-based procurement and guaranteed maximum price (GMP) or other payment provisions. Recently, a new hybrid contracting strategy called “competitive GMP,” in which an alternative delivery method combines with low-bid procurement and “open book” GMP payment provisions, has been used in the construction industry. The objective of this paper is to advance the understanding of the impact of the competitive GMP contracting strategy on project costs. The exploratory structured interviews were conducted to identify the perception of the owners and contractors on selecting a contracting strategy. Three empirical case studies were then performed to examine the cost implications on the competitive GMP contracts. The first two case study projects were delivered using the competitive GMP, and the third case study project was delivered using the conventional GMP. Each case study was analyzed using a proposed framework that captures the competitive behavior of contractors by evaluating cost and discounts related to direct work, contingency, and construction change orders throughout the project development process. The results showed that the competitive GMP projects generated cost advantages to the owner through various discounts provided during the procurement but did not always attain such saving advantages during the construction. This study contributes to a body of knowledge by examining a new approach to delivering construction projects. The findings from this study also provide guidance for owners and practitioners to better understand the cost implications of competitive GMP projects throughout the project life.