Objectives: To evaluate the effectiveness of a virtual reality (VR) temporal bone simulator in training cochlear implant surgery. Methods: We compared the performance of 12 otolaryngology registrars conducting simulated cochlear implant surgery before (pre-test) and after (post-tests) receiving training on a VR temporal bone surgery simulator with automated performance feedback. The post-test tasks were two temporal bones, one that was a mirror image of the temporal bone used as a pre-test and the other, a novel temporal bone. Participant performances were assessed by an otologist with a validated cochlear implant competency assessment tool. Structural damage was derived from an automatically generated simulator metric and compared between time points. Results: Wilcoxon signed-rank test showed that there was a significant improvement with a large effect size in the total performance scores between the pre-test (PT) and both the first and second post-tests (PT1, PT2) (PT-PT1: P = 0.007, r = 0.78, PT-PT2: P = 0.005, r = 0.82). Conclusion: The results of the study indicate that VR simulation with automated guidance can effectively be used to train surgeons in training complex temporal bone surgeries such as cochlear implantation.
14 December 2020 in BMJ Simulation and Technology Enhanced Learning
Objective To investigate the effectiveness of a virtual reality (VR), three-dimensional (3D) clinically orientated temporal bone anatomy module, including an assessment of different display technologies. Methods A clinically orientated, procedural and interactive anatomy module was generated from a micro-CT of a cadaveric temporal bone. The module was given in three different display technologies; 2D, 3D with monoscopic vision, and 3D with stereoscopic vision. A randomised control trial assessed the knowledge acquisition and attitudes of 47 medical students though a pretutorial and post-tutorial questionnaire. The questionnaire included questions identifying anatomic structures as well as understanding structural relations and clinical relevance. Furthermore, a five-point Likert scale assessed the students’ attitudes to the module and alternative learning outcomes, such as interest in otology and preparedness for clinical rotations. Results As a whole cohort, the total test score improved significantly, with a large effect size (p≤0.005, Cohen’s d=1.41). The 23 students who returned the retention questionnaire had a significant improvement in total test score compared with their pretutorial score, with a large effect size (p≤0.005, Cohen’s d=0.83). Display technology did not influence the majority of learning outcomes, with the exception of 3D technologies, showing a significantly improvement in understanding of clinical relevance and structural relations (p=0.034). Students preferred 3D technologies for ease of use, perceived effectiveness and willingness to use again. Conclusions The developed VR temporal bone anatomy tutor was an effective self-directed education tool. 3D technology remains valuable in facilitating spatial learning and superior user satisfaction.
5 February 2021 in European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology
Purpose: The position and orientation of the head is maintained to be relatively similar during the CT / MR imaging process. However, the position / orientation dissimilarities present in the resulting images between patients, or between different scans of the same patient, do not allow for direct comparison of the images themselves or features / metrics extracted from them. This paper introduces a method of defining a coordinate system which is consistent between patients and modalities (CT and MR) for images of the temporal bone, using easily identifiable landmarks within the semicircular canals. Methods: Cone Beam CT and high resolution MRI (T2) images of the temporal bone from 20 patients with no cochlear or temporal bone pathology in either modality were obtained. Four landmarks within the semicircular canals were defined that can be identified in both modalities. A coordinate system was defined using these landmarks. Reproducibility of landmark selection was assessed using intra- and inter-rater reliability (for three expert raters and two repeats of the landmark selection). Accuracy of the coordinate system was determined by comparing the coordinates of two additional landmarks in CT and MR images after their conversion to the proposed coordinate system. Results: Intraclass Correlation Coefficients at a 95% level of confidence showed significant agreement within and between raters as well as between modalities. The differences between selections, raters, and modalities (as measured using mean, standard deviation, and maximum) were low and acceptable for clinical applications. Conclusion: The proposed coordinate system is suited for use in images of the temporal bone and inner ear. Its multi-modal nature enables the coordinate system to be used in tasks such as image co-registration.