Thermal comfort is defined as the user's sensation of thermal well-being. This sensation can be modified by ex-treme environmental conditions changing the body temperature of the user. Different mechanisms, the thermoreg-ulatory system itself or an external textile system, are required to allow the body to return to their state of well-being. A cooling vest is an example of a smart garment that helps to reduce the user's body temperature in situa-tions of heat stress. There are two different standards to evaluate the performance of this type of clothing: the ASTM F2371-16 standard that uses a thermal manikin and the ASTM F2300-10 standard that uses human subjects for the evaluation. There is a need for simple, objective and affordable tests to evaluate the thermal comfort asso-ciated with personal protective equipment use. The aim of this work is to develop a new testing method that com-bines a thermal manikin with a simulation software and allows to study physiological parameters of a human subject in the body of the thermal manikin.
Environmental conditions, job tasks, and clothing choices influence the thermal comfort of workers. While it is impossible to control outdoor environmental conditions, selecting appropriate clothing for workers is feasible. Personal protective equipment often does not completely protect outdoor workers at high air temperatures. In such cases, cooling garments can help dissipate body heat and be worn with standard work clothes or uniforms. Currently, there is a lack of consensus in the literature regarding the characterisation of this type of garment. This study employed an innovative laboratory testing method that integrates a thermal manikin with a computer simulation program to assess the thermal sensation and comfort of various garment types in different activities and environmental conditions. This advanced approach enables a thorough evaluation of cooling garments that considers their physical properties and interactions with the human body. The findings confirm the efficacy of the tested cooling mechanisms, highlighting that the air circulation mechanism was the only one that consistently maintained user comfort across low, medium, and high metabolic activity levels. This study aims to assist users in selecting the most suitable cooling mechanism for the market based on the type of work or activity being performed.
Personal cooling garments are designed to help individuals manage excess heat in high-temperature environments. The thermal effects of these garments are typically evaluated through thermal manikin experiments or human subject tests. However, there remains an insufficient understanding of the correlation between the cooling efficacy of garments tested with thermal manikins and the thermal responses observed in the human body. This study seeks to establish thermal correspondence by integrating a novel thermal manikin-based testing protocol with physiological simulation software and controlled human-subject trials. A phase change material (PCM) cooling vest serves as a representative textile system for comparison. The results indicate that the manikin-based protocol effectively replicates the non-linear skin temperature drop and thermal stabilisation phases evident in humans, demonstrating a maximum deviation of only 0.2 °C in skin temperature (Tsk) across varying metabolic loads. These findings provide specific experimental evidence on the minimal deviation between the manikin’s skin temperature and human trials, demonstrating that the established novel testing protocol is capable of accurately detecting the heat-flux saturation points and latent heat discharge of the textile system. The proposed approach endorses this protocol as a robust, reproducible methodology for assessing thermal comfort and serves as a starting point for future international standardised protocols in personal cooling textiles, especially where human safety cannot be guaranteed.