Julia Manek

Mrs. Julia Manek

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
8 August 2022 in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JMJulia Manek
Julia Manek
AGAndrea Galán-Santamarina
Andrea Galán-Santamarina
PPPau Pérez-Sales
Pau Pérez-Sales
Mexico’s role in the US-Central American migration regime is threefold: not only is it a country of origin, and a transit country, but also increasingly becoming a receiving country for migrants who flee from violence, insecurity and poverty. The Mexican state responds with detention enforcement. Clinical research usually puts emphasise on the negative impact of detention enforcement on the detainees‘ mental health. Yet, it often disregards the spatial configurations of detention centres and their socio-political context. This study aims to fill this gap by analysing how such factors create harmful environments that affect both the detainees‘ mental health and their social life in Mexico’s migration detention centres. The study’s mixed method approach builds on semi-structured interviews with a sample ofN = 56 migrants of diverse nationalities and varying socioeconomic status of whom 22 were still detained while 34 had been released. The interviews include the Torturing Environment Scale (TES), a novel instrument for the analysis of detention environments, as well as clinical psychological measures of emotional distress. Additionaln = 10 in-depth interviews with human rights advocates to explore the interconnections between the detention environments, their impact on mental health, and Mexican migration politics. Facultative counter-mappings of the detention centres complement the interviews. Without exception, all interviews of detainees underline that the manipulation of detention conditions creates torturing environments that cause harm to basic physiological and psychological needs. A comparison between detained vs. released interviewees revealed lasting feelings of fear and shame. The study emphasises that immigration detention immobilises migrants in a necropolitical limbo, which destroys hope as much as human integrity. It indicates that detention is part of deterrence politics, which perpetuates harm and inequality through detention and deportation. Highlighting structural human rights violations, the findings stress the need to review current migration policies.
1

27 November 2024 in Antipode
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JMJulia Manek
Julia Manek
In a crisis‐shaken globalised world, migration‐related sites of detention emerge as a harmful figure of attempts to contain human mobility. The new Closed Controlled Access Centre (CCAC) on Samos is a blueprint for the EU's future border practices. While openly dehumanising conditions contributed to the previous “old camp” amounting to a torturing environment, the new remote and securitised CCAC promised safety and humanitarian care. Psycho‐geographical counter‐mappings by people living in the camps and of human rights defenders allow the reading of the hotspot camps as a built environment and social space. They expose how the violent neglect of the old camp transforms into the surveilled and weaponised space of yet another torturing environment. This time, it operates a necropolitical space of uncare that distributes harm differentially. The findings emphasise the abolitionist argument that camps cannot be turned into “better” places.

9 January 2023
Verified
Book Chapter
Open access
PPPau Perez-Sales
Pau Perez-Sales
AGAndrea Galán-Santamarina
Andrea Galán-Santamarina
JMJulia Manek
Julia Manek
The concept of Torturing Environments allows a better understanding of migration detention spaces and the impacts they have on people on the move. This chapter analyses the conditions and impacts derived from them, in spaces located in different border areas: Mexico (N=57), Greece (N=160) and Spain (N=110). The results indicate that the spaces analysed could be considered as torturing environments which generate tear and wear on people on the move. These spaces do not represent isolated cases but are examples of how migration policies use detention as part of a deterrence policy.

10 November 2023 in Methods in Psychology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JMJulia Manek
Julia Manek
ANAmy Nethery
Amy Nethery
FEFrancesca Esposito
Francesca Esposito
PPPau Pérez-Sales
Pau Pérez-Sales
HHHolger Horz
Holger Horz

3 March 2025 in International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JMJulia Manek
Julia Manek
SPSophia Popp
Sophia Popp
ABAmanda Oiza Bucknor
Amanda Oiza Bucknor
The European Union (EU) hotspot system bases itself on securitisation strategies, surrounded by discursive humanitarian promises. In September 2021, the EU opened its first Closed Controlled Access Centre (CCAC) on the Aegean hotspot island of Samos. The EU pledged that the vast securitisation infrastructure, including a police station, would provide safety to asylum seekers. Based on psycho-geographical counter-mappings of forced camp residents (n = 26) and semi-structured interviews with human rights defenders (n = 5), this article investigates the relations between policing, security, safety and vulnerability on different geographical scales. These scales include the border regime, the hotspot island and the camp. The counter-mappings show how the CCAC renders asylum-seeking people more vulnerable, with their safety being played off against border security. Testimonies of police violence and racism indicate that the intentionality of harm reaches a necropolitical dimension beyond the safety–security nexus. Therefore, we call for reflection on the colonial legacy of border policing and its decolonisation.

26 November 2025
Verified
Thesis
Closed access
JMJulia Manek
Julia Manek
Background. Migration detention is a growing global phenomenon related to multiple harms for those who are confined in the ever-increasing number of carceral sites. The detrimental psychological effects can be so devastating that human rights legal cases have classified the conditions in particular migration-related detention sites as tantamount to torture. This dissertation connects research on psychological factors with human geographical perspectives on the detention space, following the assumption that detention sites might form torturing environments. Four contributions examine this torturing environment hypothesis (TEH) from a transdisciplinary perspective. The torturing environment analysis and reflection (TEAR) assesses detention sites as possible torturing environments and successively develops a novel psycho-geographical counter-mapping approach, which integrates mixed methods (MM) and grounded theory (GT). Paper A. Including 26 studies, paper A is a scoping review of the existing scholarship on migration detention, torture, and mental health. It pinpoints the negative relationship between immigrants' mental health and torture experienced not only before detention but also highlights how detainees experience environments as torturous during detention. Paper B. Based on a sample of N = 56 (formerly or permanently) detained people in Mexican migration detention, paper B is an MM research with an embedded design (QUAN(qual)) that asks whether the Mexican estaciones migratorias qualify as torturing environments. It emphasizes how contextual manipulations, fear-producing, and pain-producing actions constitute spaces that affect individual detainees and detainee populations. The estaciones migratorias are an example of openly dehumanizing environments that might amount to torture. Paper C. In the rapidly changing landscape of the EU ‘hotspot’ island Samos, paper C deepens the human geographical understanding of migration detention and harm. From the openly dehumanizing 'Reception and Identification Centre' (RIC), which was closed in 2021 and deemed torturous by the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) two years after its shutdown, the 'Closed Controlled Access Centre' (CCAC), which opened in 2021, promised dignified accommodation. Paper C builds on an embedded MM design (QUAL(quan)) based on GT with psycho-geographical counter-mappings of N = 26 camp residents. Although the CCAC supposedly meets international standards, its securitized de-facto detention is associated with severe psychological and social harm. Meeting the criteria of torturing environments, the weaponization of time and space creates a necropolitical space of uncare that discloses the harmful governing principles of the European border regime. Paper D. Papers B and C encountered the following challenges, which required a methodological and ethical reflection: the fluidity of migration-related detention sites in appearance and function, a high degree of opacity, the creation of vulnerability, and decisive power asymmetries. Recognizing these challenges, paper D uses the metaphor of an architectural arch to develop a novel transdisciplinary MM approach based on GT toward an ideal model that can be applied to research across carceral settings. Conclusion. The four writings made a significant contribution to the exploration of migration-related detention from a perspective of psychological torture. The implications of the TEH emphasize the multiple violations associated with migration detention. Ultimately, whether a case of a torturing environment amounts to torture will be decided in court. However, psychological research begins before the legal case, including the documentation of torture and knowledge production on its transformation. The TEAR framework argues for the political use of psychological research findings and emphasizes the crucial consolidation of transdisciplinary research in times of expanding forced migration and deterrence measures.