Mixed-use commercial property on airport premises, defined as Airport City, could deliver significant commercial, social, and environmental success to airports and their communities. Yet, findings on Airport City’s success factors remain fragmented and inconclusive, hence hampering validity. This paper presents the first systematic literature review to identify consistently validated Airport City success factors. Using a mixed-method synthesis design, 53 peer-reviewed studies published between 2007 and 2022 were selected through database keyword searches and two rounds of reference snowballing. Their findings were aggregated through metasummary approach that grouped and abstracted findings into 21 overarching themes comprising 95 distinct success factors, and quantified their frequency effect sizes. Among those, 14 factors with frequency effect size above 10% were distilled: stakeholder coordination, multimodal transport, compact design, regional integration, air connectivity, real estate expertise, airside-landside coordination, aesthetics, shared facilities, solid business case, mixed-use development, sustainability, land for expansion, and public spaces. However, the literature often treats these factors in isolation. To advance knowledge, the authors propose how these factors may reinforce one another through configuring six higher-order constructs: Plane (robust air transportation), Place (urbanisation agglomeration), Purpose (social mission), People (human capital), Platform (multimodal transport), and Planet (sustainability). Together, these constructs form the coherent 6P Conceptual Model of Successful Airport City, where neglecting one may undermine overall success. Practitioners are invited to consider and leverage these interdependencies. Limitations of this review are the high proportion of conceptual studies and case studies. Future research is encouraged to empirically test the proposed relationships of the 6P Model.