This research evaluated the effect of different levels of extrusion process energy during the production of wheat and sorghum‐based feeds on the growth performance and digestibility of Pacific white shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei). Process energy consisted of mechanical and thermal components, which were both modulated via varying preconditioner steam addition. Diets were formulated to be isonitrogenous (36% protein) and isolipidic (8% fat), with three levels of thermal energy (TE) input during preconditioning (high, medium, and low). All diets showed increased starch gelatinization with increased TE, with the wheat‐based diets undergoing a greater degree of gelatinization than the sorghum‐based diets. There were no significant differences in final biomass, weight gain, feed conversion ratio (FCR), or survival among the different treatments. However, digestibility results showed that wheat‐based diets had significantly higher apparent digestibility coefficients (ADCs) for both protein and energy compared to sorghum‐based diets. Overall, increased starch gelatinization that correlated with greater digestibility was observed, but this effect was reduced in the sorghum‐based diets. These findings suggest that sorghum can be used as a viable alternative to wheat in shrimp feed without negatively impacting their growth performance, while also offering potential cost savings to producers.
This study explored the potential of insect proteins as an alternative to traditional meat and bone meals in nutritionally balanced dry expanded dog food. Four formulations containing black soldier fly larvae meal (BSFL), cricket flour (CF), poultry meal (PM), or fish meal (FM) at 30% inclusion were evaluated using powder rheology, extrusion trials, and analyses of kibble expansion and texture. BSFL and FM had lower specific basic flow energy (14 mJ/kg), leading to better flowability and improved extrusion stability and product consistency. High fat and chitin contents in CF and BSFL, respectively, resulted in higher bulk densities (328–382 g/L) than meat-and-bone-meal-based products (304–306 g/L). The insect-meal-based kibbles also had either a fragile (peak crushing force < 7 kg for BSFL) or very hard texture (force > 13 kg for CF). Results from a second experiment showed that including BSFL meal at lower levels (10%) alongside poultry meal mitigated the negative effects on kibble quality while improving process stability. Overall, the study suggests that defatting and partial, rather than complete, replacement of traditional proteins with insect meal could be more viable strategies for producing consistent, high-quality extruded pet food.
Energy consumption and different methods for determining energy efficiency were evaluated for drying of extruded rainbow trout feed pellets using a pilot-scale, heated air, integrated conveyor dryer and cooler. Impact of drying parameters on product quality, especially final moisture and pellet durability index (PDI), was also studied. From an initial moisture of 21.2 to 22.1% wet basis (wb), the drying–cooling process reduced the pellet moisture to 3.5 to 5.0% wb. Dryer throughput (82–121 kg/h) did not have statistically significant impact on final moisture (p = 0.0965) although the highest throughput corresponded to highest moisture; but increase in drying temperature from 93 to 115 °C led to a significant decrease in final moisture (p = 0.0285). Increase in dryer throughput led to a significant increase in PDI from 82.8 to 88.0% (p = 0.0003), while increase in drying temperature resulted in a slight decrease in PDI from 84.3 to 83.6%, although not statistically significant (p = 0.0811). Sorghum-based aquatic feed had a slightly lower PDI than wheat-based feed (82.8 versus 83.7%, respectively), but the difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.3009). Differences in pellet durability were attributed primarily to structural weakness induced by product shrinkage during drying, which in turn was impacted by drying rates. Specific energy consumption (SEC) during drying decreased from 136.3 to 101.1 MJ/kg-water with increase in throughput and increased from 122.5 to 150.1 MJ/kg-water with increase in drying temperature. An inverse trend was observed for various measures of dryer energy efficiency, with increase in efficiency for higher throughput and decrease for higher temperature. Sorghum-based aquatic feed had a higher drying SEC as compared to wheat-based feed and a lower energy efficiency. Overall, the results highlighted trade-offs between throughput, drying efficiency and pellet quality during drying of aquatic feeds.
This research compared grain sorghum with wheat as an ingredient in extruded, floating tilapia feed, and also studied the impact of pre-extrusion grinding intensity or hammer mill sieve size on extrusion parameters, final product quality and animal performance. With an increase in grind size of the diets from 0.61 to 1.27 mm, higher specific thermal energy was observed; however, specific mechanical energy decreased, leading to lower expansion (pooled bulk density of 405.6 g/L versus 441.5 g/L). Grain source also impacted pellet expansion and quality, with sorghum-based aquatic feed pellets having higher piece density than wheat-based pellets (pooled average of 0.52 g/cm3 versus 0.48 g/cm3) and lower water absorption (pooled average of 255.7% versus 334.4%). Digestibility trends with respect to grain and grind size were not consistent for Nile tilapia fed different extruded diets, but results from a 12-week growth trial showed that tilapia fed the sorghum-based diet had a higher weight gain as compared to wheat-based diets (86.0% versus 81.8%). Grind size or grain did not have a statistically significant impact on feed conversion ratio (FCR), but the sorghum-based feed from medium grind had the lowest FCR of 1.03, while the FCR of other treatments ranged from 1.09 to 1.13. These results indicate that grain sorghum can successfully be incorporated into Nile tilapia diets with positive effects on both physical feed quality as well as the growth of the fish.