As transportation activities affect a region’s environmental quality, knowing why individuals prefer certain modes can help a region make judicious transportation investments. Using a nested logit model, this paper studies the behavior of commuters to downtown Pittsburgh who use auto, bus, light rail, walking, and biking. Although statistical measures influence the selection of a nesting structure, another criterion for model selection is the policy questions such models inform. Hence this paper demonstrates how an alternative model structure allows planners to consider new policy questions. For example, how might a change in parking fee affect greenhouse gas emission (GHGs)? The proposed model showed that a 5%, 10% and 15% increase in parking cost reduces GHGs by 7.3%, 9% and 13.2%, respectively, through increasing carpoolers’ mode share. Because the proposed model forecasts mode choices of certain groups of travelers with higher accuracy (compared to an older model that did not consider the model selection criteria presented here), the proposed model strengthens policymakers’ ability to consider environmental impacts of interest to the region (in this case, GHGs). The paper does not suggest that one nesting structure is always preferable; rather the nesting structure must be chosen with the policy considerations in mind.
1 September 2009 in Socio-Economic Planning Sciences
This study developed measures of effectiveness (MOEs) to quantify the influence of recommendations from a long-range transportation plan (LRTP) on the implementation of projects in a statewide transportation program. MOEs included percentage of LRTP projects in the implementation program, percentage of projects placed in the program before appearing in the LRTP, and percentage of projects started before the LRTP was superseded by an updated LRTP. These MOEs were computed by comparing LRTPs with the Virginia Department of Transportation’s Six Year Improvement Programs (SYIP) over a period for the Hampton Roads region. The results suggest how regional long-range transportation planning influences the projects selected for implementation. For example, only 6% of the implemented projects appeared in the program prior to the LRTP. The number of LRTP projects implemented are relatively low, but about two thirds of the projects are initiated while the LRTP is current. Accordingly, the LRTP is evolving from its intended long-range visioning function to serve as a shorter-term programming document, where a small proportion of projects are selected for immediate implementation. The utility of these metrics is that they represent a feasible approach for quantifying the implementation aspect of long-range transportation planning.
Traffic volume forecasts are fundamental to policymaking; yet, the impacts of forecast errors are rarely considered. Accordingly, traffic forecasts in 39 studies were compared to observed volumes after the forecast year had elapsed, yielding a mean error of 40%. To evaluate the effect of forecast accuracy, five case studies examined how forecast error affected investment decisions. Because errors of 11%, 12%, 20%, 33%, and 34% can alter investment decisions, the respective observed errors of 20%, 38%, 64%, 6%, and 52% meant the forecast error was potentially large enough to alter the investment decision based on each study’s stated criterion. Although striving for more accurate forecasts is laudable, the results from the 39 studies showed that only a quarter of the variation in study accuracy is not attributable to random variation. Accordingly, until highly accurate forecasts become the norm, an interim recommendation for planners is to use empirical decision intervals, as shown herein, indicating the magnitude of error can alter investment decisions.
24 February 2010 in Public Works Management & Policy
Scoping is a process that develops the budget, schedule, and explicit rationale for a transportation infrastructure project. Detailed interviews with Virginia scoping professionals provide a unique occasion to investigate challenges and potential improvements in this field. Problems include lack of a clear purpose statement from the planning process; incongruence between planning cost estimates and scoping estimates; scoping of projects not having full construction funding; insufficient participation from outside agencies; and insufficient documentation of follow-up commitments fulfilled after the scope is established. Solutions focused on process rather than technology and include distinguishing the prescoping meeting (where questions are raised) from the scoping meeting (where questions are answered), providing an accounting mechanism allowing some scoping to be performed prior to programming, and strengthening the link between scoping and planning. This article further suggests that scoping substantially influences a project’s achievement of desired transportation outcomes.