A variety of hollow microneedle (HMN) designs has emerged for minimally invasive therapies and monitoring systems. In this study, a design change limiting the indentation depth of the (3D) printed custom microneedle assembly (circular array of five conical frusta with and without a stopper, aspect ratio = 1.875) fabricated using stereolithography has been experimentally validated and modeled in silico. The micro-indentation profiles generated in confined compression on 1 mm ± 0.073 mm alginate films enabled the generation of a Prony series, where displacement ranged from 100 to 250 µm. These constants were used as intrinsic properties simulating experimental ramp/release profiles. Puncture occurred on two distinct hydrogel formulations at the design depth of 150 µm and indentation rate of 0.1 mm/s characterized by a peak force of 3.5 N (H = 31 kPa) and 8.3 N (H = 36.5 kPa), respectively. Experimental and theoretical alignments for peak force trends were obtained when the printing resolution was simulated. Higher puncture force and uniformity inferred by the stopper was confirmed via microscopy and profilometry. Meanwhile, poroviscoelasticity characterization is required to distinguish mass loss vs. redistribution post-indentation through pycnometry. Results from this paper highlight the feasibility of insertion-depth control within the epidermis thickness for the first time in solid HMN literature.