Ground-level ozone (O3) pollution is a persistent environmental concern, even in regions that have made efforts to reduce emissions. This study focuses on the state of Arizona, which has experienced elevated O3 concentrations over past decades and contains two non-attainment areas as designated by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Using the Weather Research and Forecasting with Chemistry (WRF-Chem) model, we examine O3 levels in the semi-arid and arid regions of Arizona. Our analysis focuses on the month of June between 2017 and 2021, a period characterized by high O3 levels before the onset of the North American Monsoon (NAM). Our evaluation of the WRF-Chem model against surface Air Quality System (AQS) observations reveals that the model adeptly captures the diurnal variation of hourly O3 levels and the episodes of O3 exceedance through the maximum daily 8 h average (MDA8) O3 concentrations. However, the model tends to overestimate surface NO2 concentrations, particularly during nighttime hours. Among the three cities studied, Phoenix (PHX) and Tucson (TUS) exhibit a negative bias in both hourly and MDA8 O3 levels, while Yuma demonstrates a relatively large positive bias. The simulated mean hourly and MDA8 O3 concentrations in Phoenix are 44.6 and 64.7 parts per billion (ppb), respectively, compared to observed values of 47.5 and 65.7 ppb, resulting in mean negative biases of −2.9 and −1.0 ppb, respectively. Furthermore, the analysis of the simulated ratio of formaldehyde (HCHO) to NO2 ( ; FNR), reveals interesting insights of the sensitivity of O3 to its precursors. In Phoenix, the FNR varies from a VOC (volatile organic compound)-limited regime in the most populated areas to a transition between VOC-limited and NOx-limited regimes throughout the metro area, with an average FNR of 1.15. In conclusion, this study sheds light on the persistent challenge of ground-level O3 pollution in semi-arid and arid regions, using the state of Arizona as a case study.
1 May 2024 in Environmental Research Communications
Arid urban areas are pivotal in the global landscape, and their air quality issues are highlighted by the complexities of tropospheric ozone production. Here, we use recent satellite observations from TROPOMI and a longer record of data from OMI to investigate the levels of ozone precursors (NO2 and CH2O) in 12 major cities in arid regions. Using a space-based CH2O/NO2 indicator, we identified the dominant chemical regime influencing ozone formation, revealing a clear temporal trend that aligns with previously reported economic trajectories as well as variation in emission control strategies implemented in these cities. Our results show that, NO2 concentrations decreased in cities with proactive regulatory policies, such as Madrid and Los Angeles in semi-arid and arid regions. A contrasting increase was observed in rapidly developing cities within arid and hyper-arid regions, such as Tehran and Cairo, where emission controls are less strict. An increase in CH2O levels was also apparent, requiring more attention to VOCs control. Furthermore, our analysis clearly shows that the interactions between ozone production and climatic factors such as temperature exhibit a nonlinear relationship, especially in arid climates. These findings highlight the importance of emission reduction strategies that consider the meteorological and chemical drivers of dry regions, particularly in light of the rising global aridity.
An oxidizing and harmful pollutant gas, tropospheric ozone is a product of a complex set of photochemical reactions that can make it difficult to enact effective control measures. A better understanding of its precursors including volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and nitrogen oxides (NOx) and their spatial distribution can enable policymakers to focus their control efforts. In this study we used low-cost sensors (LCSs) to increase the spatial resolution of an existing NO2 monitoring network in addition to VOC sampling to better understand summer ozone formation in Maricopa County, Arizona, and observed that afternoon O3 values at the downwind sites were significantly correlated, ~0.27, to the morning NO2 × rate values at the urban sites. Additionally, we looked at the impact of wildfire smoke on ozone exceedances and compared non-smoke days to smoke days. The average O3 on smoke days was approximately 20% higher than on non-smoke days, however, the average NO2 concentration multiplied by estimated photolysis rate (NO2 × rate) values were only 2% higher on smoke days. Finally, we evaluated the ozone sensitivity of the region by calculating HCHO/NO2 ratios using three different datasets: ground, satellite, and model. Although the satellite dataset produced higher HCHO/NO2 ratios than the other datasets, when the proper regime thresholds are applied the three datasets consistently show transition and VOC-limited O3 production regimes over the Phoenix metro area. This suggests a need to implement more VOC emission controls in order to reach O3 attainment in the county.
7 October 2024 in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
In this study, we demonstrate the utility of available correlative measurements of carbon species to identify regional and local air mass characteristics as well as their associated source types. In particular, we combine different regression techniques and enhancement ratio algorithms with carbon monoxide (CO), carbon dioxide (CO2), and methane (CH4) total column abundance from 11 sites of the Total Carbon Column Observing Network (TCCON) to infer relative contributions of regional and local sources to each of these sites. The enhancement ratios provide a viable alternative to univariate measures of relationships between the trace gases that are insufficient in capturing source-type and transport signatures. Regional enhancements are estimated from the difference between bivariate regressions across a specific time window of observed total abundance of these species (BERr for bulk enhancement regression ratio) and inferred anomalies (AERr for anomaly enhancement regression ratio) associated with a site-specific background. Since BERr and AERr represent the bulk and local species enhancement ratio, respectively, its difference simply represents the site-specific regional component of these ratios. We can then compare these enhancements for CO2 and CH4 with CO to differentiate between combustion and non-combustion air masses. Our results show that while the regional and local influences in enhancements vary across sites, dominant characteristics are found to be consistent with previous studies over these sites and with bottom-up anthropogenic and fire emission inventories. The site in Pasadena shows a dominant local influence (> 60 %) across all species enhancement ratios, which appear to come from a mixture of biospheric and combustion activities. In contrast, Anmyeondo shows more regionally influenced (> 60 %) air masses associated with high-temperature and/or biofuel combustion activities. Ascension Island appears to only show a large regional influence (> 80 %) on CO CO2 and CO CH4, which is indicative of transported and combustion-related CO from the nearby African region, consistent with a sharp rise in column CO (3.51 ± 0.43 % ppb yr−1) at this site. These methods have important applications to source analysis using spaceborne column retrievals of these species.
This study quantifies wildfire contributions to O3 pollution in Arizona, relative to local and regional emissions. Using WRF-Chem with O3 and CO tags, we analyzed emissions during June 2021, a period of drought, extreme heat, and wildfires. Our results show that background O3 accounted for ∼50 % of total O3, while local anthropogenic emissions contributed 24 %–40 %, consistent with recent estimates for Phoenix. During peak smoke conditions, fire-related O3 ranged from 5 to 23 ppb (5 %–21 % of total O3), averaging 15 ppb (15 %). These estimates were compared with model sensitivity tests excluding fire emissions, which confirmed the spatiotemporal pattern of fire-driven O3, though the model underestimated the magnitude by a factor of 1.4. The results further demonstrate that wildfires exacerbate O3 exceedances over urban areas. Our analysis reveals key differences in O3 sources: Phoenix's O3 was mainly driven by local emissions, while Yuma's was heavily influenced by transboundary transport from California and Mexico. Wildfires not only boosted O3 formation but also altered winds and atmospheric chemistry in Phoenix and downwind areas. O3 increases along the smoke plume resulted from NOX and volatile organic compound (VOC) interactions, with fire-driven O3 forming in NOX-limited zones near the urban interface. Downwind, O3 chemistry shifted, shaped by higher NOX in central Phoenix and more VOCs in suburban and rural areas. Winds weakened and turned westerly near fire-affected areas. This study highlights the value of high-resolution modeling with tagging to disentangle wildfire and regional O3 sources, particularly in arid regions, where extreme heat intensifies O3 pollution, making accurate source attribution essential.