The optimal technique for managing distal femur fixation failure remains inconclusive. The author studied the efficacy of a combined proximal humerus locking compression plate (LCP-PH) and 3.5 mm reconstruction plate (LCP-RP) by finite element (FE) analysis and retrospectively described the clinical outcomes of the present technique in such difficult circumstances. Biomechanical study setting included FE models of the distal femur with remaining holes from previous distal femur LCP (LCP-DF) fixation stabilized with three different constructs i.e., LCP-DF alone, LCP-DF-and-LCP-RP, as well as LCP-PH-and-LCP-RP. All settings were analyzed by using FE under physiological loads. Regarding the clinical series, the outcomes of 8 LCP-DF fixation failures operated on by the present technique were retrospectively reviewed. High Implant stress of 911.2 MPa and elastic strain at fracture site of 200.8 µɛ were found when stabilized with LCP-DF. The constructs of LCP-DF-and-LCP-RP, and LCP-PH-and-LCP-RP presented lower implant stress compared to LCP-DF, 511.5, and 617.5 MPa, respectively. The elastic strain of both dual plating constructs was also 4-5 times lower than LCP-DF and differed from each other by approximately 10 µɛ. Regarding the clinical series, bony consolidation was achieved in all cases with a mean duration of 28.5 weeks (range 24-36). An average ROM of the affected knee was 115° (range 105-140). Regarding the KSS, 1 was determined to be excellent and 7 to be good. By the biomechanical analysis and the clinical results, the construct of LCP-PH-and-LCP-RP could be an effective technique for revision surgery of LCP-DF fixation failure.
22 June 2024 in Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research
Background: Basicervical femoral neck fracture is a rare proximal femur fracture with a high implant failure rate. Biomechanical comparisons between cephalomedullary nails (CMNs) and dynamic hip screws (DHSs) under torsion loading are lacking. This study compared the biomechanical performance of three fixations for basicervical femoral neck fractures under torsion load during early ambulation. Methods: The biomechanical study models used three fixations: a DHS, a DHS with an anti-rotation screw, and a short CMN. Finite element analysis was used to simulate hip rotation with muscle forces related to leg swing applied to the femur. The equivalent von Mises stress (EQV) on fixation, fragment displacement, and strain energy density at the proximal cancellous bone were monitored for fixation stability. Results: The EQV of the short CMN construct (304.63 MPa) was comparable to that of the titanium DHS construct (293.39 MPa) and greater than that of the titanium DHS with an anti-rotation screw construct (200.94 MPa). The proximal fragment displacement in the short CMN construct was approximately 0.13 mm, the greatest among the constructs. The risk of screw cutout for the lag screw in short CMNs was 3.1–5.8 times greater than that for DHSs and DHSs with anti-rotation screw constructs. Conclusions: Titanium DHS combined with an anti-rotation screw provided lower fragment displacement, stress, and strain energy density in the femoral head than the other fixations under torsion load. Basicervical femoral neck fracture treated with CMNs may increase the risk of lag screw cutout. Graphical