This paper describes Vulcan version 4.0, a dataset representing annual United States carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from the combustion of fossil fuel and cement production at high spatial resolution for the 2010-2022 time period. It updates the Vulcan version 3.0 data product previously reported in the literature. While the "native" spatial resolution of Vulcan is at the point, line, and US Census block spatial scale, we report here on the results placed into a 1 km × 1 km spatial grid at an annual time resolution. The approach uses multiple federal, state, and local data sources to estimate the CO2 emission magnitude and distribute those emissions in space and time. Given the increased interest in greenhouse gas mitigation at sub-national scales, this data offers a better understanding of the emitting landscape enabling more targeted, efficient policy instruments. The Vulcan output offers the scientific community CO2 emissions applicable to a wide range of study fields, including carbon cycle science, climate science, environmental policy, urban planning, and socioeconomic research.
Quantitative assessment of greenhouse gas emissions is an essential step to plan, track, and verify emission reductions. Multiple approaches have been taken to quantify U.S. CO2 emissions from fossil fuel combustion (FFCO2), the primary driver of global climate change. A 2020 study analyzing atmospheric 14CO2 observations (a key check on bottom-up estimates) and multiple inventories found significant differences in the U.S. total FFCO2 emissions. The specific reasons for the differences were left for future work. Here, we take up this task and explore the differences between two widely used U.S. FFCO2 inventories, the Vulcan FFCO2 emissions data product and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) GHG inventory, developed using mostly independent data sources. Where possible, we isolate definitions and data sources to quantify/understand discrepancies. We find that the initial 2011 emissions difference (104 MtC yr−1; RD = 10.7%) can be reduced by aligning the two estimates to account for differing definitions of emission categories or system boundaries. Out of the remaining 90.6 MtC yr−1 gap (RD = 6.2%), we find that differences can be largely explained by data completeness, emission factors, and fuel heating values. The remaining difference, 45.4 MtC yr−1 (3.2%), is difficult to isolate due to limited EPA documentation and disaggregation of emissions by sector/fuel categories. Furthermore, the final net difference obscures countervailing gross differences (∼40 MtC yr−1) within individual sectors. Nevertheless, this comparison suggests the potential for a national estimation approach that can simultaneously satisfy reporting at the national/global scale and the local scale, maintaining internal consistency throughout and offering detailed decision support to a much wider array of stakeholders.
Accurate estimation of planetary greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions at the scale of individual emitting activities is a critical need for both scientific and policy applications. Powerplants represent the single largest and most concentrated form of global GHG emissions. Climate Trace, co-founded and promoted by former U.S. Vice President Al Gore, is a new effort using, in part, artificial intelligence (AI) approaches to estimate asset-scale GHG emissions. Climate Trace recently released a database of global powerplant CO2 emissions at the facility-scale that uses both AI and non-AI estimation approaches. However, no independent peer-reviewed assessment has been made of this important global emissions database. Here, we compare the Climate Trace powerplant CO2 emissions to an atmospherically calibrated, multi-constraint estimate of powerplant CO2 emissions in the United States. The 3.7% (65) of compared facilities that used an AI-based approach show a mean relative difference (MRD) of −1.1% (SD: 46.4%) in the year 2019. The 96.3% (1726) of the facilities that used a non-AI-based approach show a MRD of −50.0% (SD: 117.7%). Of the non-AI estimated facilities, 151 (8.7%) facilities agree to within ±20%. The large differences between Climate Trace and Vulcan-power emission estimates for these facilities is primarily caused by Climate Trace’ use of a national-mean power plant capacity factor (CF) which is a poor representation of the reported power plant CFs of individual US facilities and leads to very large errors at those same 1726 facilities.
Accurate fossil fuel CO 2 (FFCO 2 ) emission estimates are crucial for tracking mitigation and constraining atmospheric‐based emissions estimation. Global gridded emissions often downscale national total emissions using spatial proxies. Here, we examine such downscaling by comparing a recently released global gridded FFCO 2 inventory (GRACED) to a bottom‐up, high‐resolution estimate (Vulcan) in the U.S. which has demonstrated consistency with independent atmospheric‐based emission estimates. While sector‐specific national totals are similar, large differences are found at the gridcell scale (e.g., total FFCO 2 median gridcell‐scale relative difference is 128.7%). Examination of the downscaling approaches suggests that gridcell‐scale residential/commercial differences are driven by GRACED use of a population spatial proxy, missing the spatial influence of other driving factors such as surface air temperature or building size. Population is also a poor choice for industrial building emissions as they better correlate with transportation infrastructure such as rail and marine shipping hubs. The use of population and road length as an onroad FFCO 2 emissions spatial proxy does not reflect differences in urban versus rural driving behavior. Finally, the use of the CARMA powerplant data set as a spatial proxy is ill‐advised due to its inconsistency with measured powerplant CO 2 emissions. Similar implications were found in a previous study comparing GRACED to a European high‐resolution inventory (CAMS‐REG) suggesting some universality to biases in the GRACED emission estimates at fine scales. Aggregation to larger urban area aggregates ameliorates the large gridcell scale differences between GRACED and Vulcan, suggesting a more viable scale at which global downscaling proxies can be used.
The share of global GHG emissions in urban areas, home to the majority of global population, is a central metric in establishing the importance and prioritization of cities for global GHG emissions mitigation efforts. However, the urban share of global GHG emissions remains poorly quantified due to a paucity of accurate and comprehensive urban GHG emissions data and lack of clarity on both geographical and system boundaries. Here, we use a new machine learning-based global fossil fuel CO2 (FFCO2) emissions dataset (Vulcan-UrbanML) to estimate the global urban share of territorial FFCO2 emissions. We quantify the urban share for multiple geographic boundaries, system boundaries, and IPCC regional domains over the 2010 to 2022 time period. We find a 2022 global territorial FFCO2 emissions urban share range of 63.6-69.9%, depending upon the urban boundary considered. The consumption-based global urban share is estimated as 65.3%-79.3%. Per capita urban emissions are significantly lower than their rural counterparts in the Developed Countries, the Middle East, and Eastern Europe and West-Central Asia regions. The global territorial FFCO2 emissions urban share increased 1.4% over the 13 year time period examined here.