Deep learning consistently demonstrates high performance in classifying and segmenting medical images like CT, PET, and MRI. However, compared to these kinds of images, whole slide images (WSIs) of stained tissue sections are huge and thus much less efficient to process, especially for deep learning algorithms. To overcome these challenges, we present attention2majority, a weak multiple instance learning model to automatically and efficiently process WSIs for classification. Our method initially assigns exhaustively sampled label-free patches with the label of the respective WSIs and trains a convolutional neural network to perform patch-wise classification. Then, an intelligent sampling method is performed in which patches with high confidence are collected to form weak representations of WSIs. Lastly, we apply a multi-head attention-based multiple instance learning model to do slide-level classification based on high-confidence patches (intelligently sampled patches). Attention2majority was trained and tested on classifying the quality of 127 WSIs (of regenerated kidney sections) into three categories. On average, attention2majority resulted in 97.4%±2.4 AUC for the four-fold cross-validation. We demonstrate that the intelligent sampling module within attention2majority is superior to the current state-of-the-art random sampling method. Furthermore, we show that the replacement of random sampling with intelligent sampling in attention2majority results in its performance boost (from 94.9%±3.1 to 97.4%±2.4 average AUC for the four-fold cross-validation). We also tested a variation of attention2majority on the famous Camelyon16 dataset, which resulted in 89.1%±0.8 AUC¹. When compared to random sampling, the attention2majority demonstrated excellent slide-level interpretability. It also provided an efficient framework to arrive at a multi-class slide-level prediction.

Breast cancer is the most common malignancy in women, with over 40,000 deaths annually in the United States alone. Clinicians often rely on the breast cancer recurrence score, Oncotype DX (ODX), for risk stratification of breast cancer patients, by using ODX as a guide for personalized therapy. However, ODX and similar gene assays are expensive, time-consuming, and tissue destructive. Therefore, developing an AI-based ODX prediction model that identifies patients who will benefit from chemotherapy in the same way that ODX does would give a low-cost alternative to the genomic test. To overcome this problem, we developed a deep learning framework, Breast Cancer Recurrence Network (BCR-Net), which automatically predicts ODX recurrence risk from histopathology slides. Our proposed framework has two steps. First, it intelligently samples discriminative features from whole-slide histopathology images of breast cancer patients. Then, it automatically weights all features through a multiple instance learning model to predict the recurrence score at the slide level. On a dataset of H&E and Ki67 breast cancer resection whole slides images (WSIs) from 99 anonymized patients, the proposed framework achieved an overall AUC of 0.775 (68.9% and 71.1% accuracies for low and high risk) on H&E WSIs and overall AUC of 0.811 (80.8% and 79.2% accuracies for low and high risk) on Ki67 WSIs of breast cancer patients. Our findings provide strong evidence for automatically risk-stratify patients with a high degree of confidence. Our experiments reveal that the BCR-Net outperforms the state-of-the-art WSI classification models. Moreover, BCR-Net is highly efficient with low computational needs, making it practical to deploy in limited computational settings.

Multiple instance learning (MIL) models have achieved remarkable success in analyzing whole slide images (WSIs) for disease classification problems. However, with regard to giga-pixel WSI classification problems, current MIL models are often incapable of differentiating a WSI with extremely small tumor lesions. This minute tumor-to-normal area ratio in a MIL bag inhibits the attention mechanism from properly weighting the areas corresponding to minor tumor lesions. To overcome this challenge, we propose salient instance inference MIL (SiiMIL), a weakly-supervised MIL model for WSI classification. We introduce a novel representation learning for histopathology images to identify representative normal keys. These keys facilitate the selection of salient instances within WSIs, forming bags with high tumor-to-normal ratios. Finally, an attention mechanism is employed for slide-level classification based on formed bags. Our results show that salient instance inference can improve the tumor-to-normal area ratio in the tumor WSIs. As a result, SiiMIL achieves 0.9225 AUC and 0.7551 recall on the Camelyon16 dataset, which outperforms the existing MIL models. In addition, SiiMIL can generate tumor-sensitive attention heatmaps that is more interpretable to pathologists than the widely used attention-based MIL method. Our experiments imply that SiiMIL can accurately identify tumor instances, which could only take up less than 1% of a WSI, so that the ratio of tumor to normal instances within a bag can increase by two to four times.

The early diagnosis of lymph node metastasis in breast cancer is essential for enhancing treatment outcomes and overall prognosis. Unfortunately, pathologists often fail to identify small or subtle metastatic deposits, leading them to rely on cytokeratin stains for improved detection, although this approach is not without its flaws. To address the need for early detection, multiple-instance learning (MIL) has emerged as the preferred deep learning method for automatic tumor detection on whole slide images (WSIs). However, existing methods often fail to identify some small lesions due to insufficient attention to small regions. Attention-based multiple-instance learning (ABMIL)-based methods can be particularly problematic because they may focus too much on normal regions, leaving insufficient attention for small-tumor lesions. In this paper, we propose a new ABMIL-based model called normal representative keyset ABMIL (NRK-ABMIL), which addresseses this issue by adjusting the attention mechanism to give more attention to lesions. To accomplish this, the NRK-ABMIL creates an optimal keyset of normal patch embeddings called the normal representative keyset (NRK). The NRK roughly represents the underlying distribution of all normal patch embeddings and is used to modify the attention mechanism of the ABMIL. We evaluated NRK-ABMIL on the publicly available Camelyon16 and Camelyon17 datasets and found that it outperformed existing state-of-the-art methods in accurately identifying small tumor lesions that may spread over a few patches. Additionally, the NRK-ABMIL also performed exceptionally well in identifying medium/large tumor lesions.

Although multiple instance learning (MIL) methods are widely used for automatic tumor detection on whole slide images (WSI), they suffer from the extreme class imbalance WSIs containing small tumors where the tumor may include only a few isolated cells. For early detection, it is important that MIL algorithms can identify small tumors. Existing studies have attempted to address this issue using attention-based architectures and instance selection-based methodologies but have not produced significant improvements. This paper proposes crossattention-based salient instance inference MIL (CASiiMIL), which involves a novel saliency-informed attention mechanism to identify small tumors (e.g., breast cancer lymph node micro-metastasis) on WSIs without needing any annotations. In addition to this new attention mechanism, we introduce a negative representation learning algorithm to facilitate the learning of saliencyinformed attention weights for improved sensitivity on tumor WSIs. The proposed model outperforms the state-ofthe-art MIL methods on two popular tumor metastasis detection datasets. The proposed approach demonstrates great cross-center generalizability, high accuracy in classifying WSIs with small tumor lesions, and excellent interpretability attributed to the saliency-informed attention weights. We expect that the proposed method will pave the way for training algorithms for early tumor detection on large datasets where acquiring fine-grained annotations is is not practical