Helicopters are seen by the petroleum industry as the only viable way of transportation between on and offshore platforms. At present, there exists no certification requirement to ensure a high level of survivability in the event of a water impact. Within the literature, there exists a body of information related to the post crash analysis of accident data, which supports the finding that a conventional metallic under floor design performs poorly during a water impact, in relation to the transmission of water pressure and the absorption of energy. In order to characterise this behaviour, this paper concerns the crashworthiness of helicopters on water for an impact speed of 8 m s−1, for a simple box-beam construction that is common to metallic helicopters. A complete section-by-section analysis of a component floor will be presented, which has been compared both quantatively and qualitatively with the results provided by the finite element code, LS-DYNA3D. Comparisons will be made to collapsed frame height, as well as to detailed measurements for skin deflection. The main areas of good and poor agreement are discussed and conclusions drawn on the validity of the simulations, with a view for developing a practical methodology for fluid–structure interactions. This paper discusses the recommendations for design changes that could potential improve the level of crashworthiness currently offered, through the careful redesign of frames and joints, in order to allow for progressive collapse and sustained energy absorption. This paper concludes with a recommendation that a next generation design must incorporate a passive dual role capability that can cater for both hard and soft surface impacts, by being able to degrade its localised strength depending upon the type of surface encountered.
7 December 2021 in International Journal of Crashworthiness
This paper proposes a modelling approach for integral vehicle structures, applied to frontal crash loading, based on the Macro element approach. Addressing the idealisation of complex sub-structures and full vehicle was through identification of critical parameters for conversion of validated FEM into MEM equivalents through sensitivity analyses. Two examples of impact onto rigid barriers are presented; 1). Frontal crash energy management system (consisting crush-can and longitudinal engine rail), impacting at 8.6 m/s and 2). A complete vehicle impact at 56 km/hr (15m/s). Both case studies predict key features of collapse, with force-time histories agreeing within ±10–15% against FEM. Case study 1 required a 3 second solution time versus 1.5 h (8CPUS) mass-scaled FEM (105k element). For Case study 2, MEM required 7.5mins versus 16.5 hrs for a 3 M element FEM vehicle. For all simulations, LS-DYNA R10.0 and Visual Crash Studio R4.0 used. Developing a framework to overcome accuracy/stability problems, together with issues related to robustness and error reduction is discussed. Model complexity was progressive, involving a-priori knowledge of collapse and/or analysing several sub-assemblies to guide idealisation. The level of agreement demonstrates the advantages of MEM as a complementary method to support conceptual vehicle design and offers significant advantages for design exploration, particularly across multiple crash certification cases.
1 July 2018 in International Journal of Impact Engineering
This paper describes a constitutive model for progressive damage in carbon fibre-reinforced composites (CFRPs), developed in the framework of thermodynamics and coupled with a vector equation of state. This made the constitutive model capable of modelling shock wave propagation within orthotropic materials. Damage is incorporated in the model by using reduction in the principal material stiffness based on the effective stress concept and the hypothesis of strain energy equivalence. Damage evolution was defined in terms of a modified Tuler–Bucher criteria. The constitutive model was implemented into Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) DYNA3D nonlinear hydrocode. Simulation results were validated against post-impact experimental data of spherical projectile impact on an aerospace-grade woven CFRP composite panel. Two plate thicknesses were considered and a range of impact velocities above the ballistic limit of the plates, ranging from 194 m/s to 1219 m/s. Other than for the size of the delamination zone in the minor material direction, the discrepancy between the experiments and numerical results for damage and delamination in the CFRP target plates was within 8%.