This study presents a comparative analysis of the accuracy of different methodologies for the design and performance evaluation of thermoelectric generators (TEGs), using analytical, computational numerical, and experimental approaches. TEGs are promising devices for capturing waste energy in industrial processes, converting waste heat into electrical energy and contributing to energy sustainability. However, the efficiency of TEGs is a significant challenge due to their low conversion rates. To address this challenge, three different methodologies were developed and systematically compared. Analytical Model: Developed for the electrical design of thermoelectric micro generators, using theoretical performance data and industrial temperature gradients. This method offers a robust theoretical view but may not capture all practical variables. Computational model in Simulink/MATLAB: Created and validated to consider the variation of the Seebeck coefficient and the internal resistance of thermoelectric modules with temperature. This model provides an accurate simulation of operating conditions but depends on the accuracy of the input parameters. Experimental Multi-string Electrical Arrangement Prototype: This involved the design and construction of a prototype followed by experimental tests to validate its performance. This method provides valuable empirical data but can be limited by the complexity and cost of the experiments. The results show that each methodology has specific advantages and limitations, offering valuable insights for the development of more efficient TEG systems. The comparison of analytical, numerical, and experimental methods revealed differences in accuracy and efficiency, highlighting the importance of an integrated approach to TEG design. This study lays a solid foundation for future research and practical applications in the field of industrial residual energy harvesting.
Thermoelectric systems configured in multistring arrays of thermoelectric generators (TEGs) represent a promising solution for energy harvesting in environments with non-uniform thermal gradients. However, the presence of multiple maximum power points (MPPs) in such configurations poses significant challenges to energy extraction efficiency. This study presents a comprehensive performance evaluation of four maximum power point tracking (MPPT) algorithms, Perturb and Observe (P&O), Incremental Conductance (InC), Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO), and Genetic Algorithm (GA), applied to multistring thermoelectric generator (TEG) arrays under multiple and asymmetric thermal gradients. The simulated systems, modeled in MATLAB/Simulink, replicate real-world thermoelectric configurations by employing series-parallel topologies and eleven distinct thermal scenarios, including uniform, localized, and sinusoidal temperature distributions. The key contribution of this work lies in demonstrating the superior capability of metaheuristic algorithms (PSO and GA) to locate the global maximum power point (GMPP) in complex thermal environments, outperforming classical methods (P&O and InC), which consistently converged to local maxima under multi-peak conditions. Notably, PSO achieved the best average convergence time (0.23 s), while the GA recorded the fastest response (0.05 s) in the most challenging multi-peak scenarios. Both maintained high tracking accuracy (error ≈ 0.01%) and minimized power ripple, resulting in conversion efficiencies exceeding 97%. The study emphasizes the crucial role of algorithm selection in maximizing energy harvesting performance in practical TEG applications such as embedded systems, waste heat recovery, and autonomous sensor networks. Future directions include physical validation through prototypes, incorporation of dynamic thermal modeling, and development of hybrid or AI-enhanced MPPT strategies.