High-intensity therapeutic ultrasound (HITU) is a minimally invasive and non-ionizing medical procedure used to combat cancers. Faithful characterization of HITU fields is fundamental to ensure patient safety and clinical efficiency. However, standardized quality assurance protocols have not yet been established for HITU, which is a prerequisite for the wide acceptance of HITU as a therapeutic modality. This review discusses the challenges in the acoustic output characterization of HITU and the solutions that have been proposed to overcome this issue. The purpose of this review is to discuss the state of art of the metrological techniques, and invoke new ideas to prompt further development of HITU usage and characterization techniques, to ensure the safe and effective usage of therapeutic ultrasound.
The heterodyne interferometer has been used to realize the sound pressure unit directly and absolutely for underwater acoustics and ultrasound, which is considered as the primary standard of the hydrophone calibration instead of the reciprocity method. The widely used demodulation methods are the zero-crossing method and the arctangent method. Recent studies show that the frequency response of the utilized photodetector (PD) in the heterodyne interferometer also significantly influences the results of the sound pressure realization using the two demodulation methods, especially for the high-intensity focused ultrasound application, which is investigated in this paper. Simulations are performed to obtain general conclusions using different types of low-pass filters to simulate the nonideal frequency responses of the PD. Also, experimental results of the frequency response of the utilized PD are then used to analyze the induced relative error of the demodulated acoustic particle velocity so as to evaluate the related measurement uncertainty of the sound pressure realization. The simulation method is useful to choose the required PDs and evaluate the related measurement uncertainty induced by their frequency responses for the optical sound pressure standards and other optical measurement applications.
As a high-end medical technology, high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) is widely used in cancer treatment and ultrasonic lithotripsy technology. The acoustic output level and safety of ultrasound treatments are closely related to the accuracy of sound pressure measurements. Heterodyne laser interferometry is applied to the measurement of ultrasonic pressure owing to its characteristics of non-contact, high precision, and traceability. However, the upper limit of sound pressure measurement is limited by the bandwidth of the interferometer. In this paper, a high-bandwidth heterodyne laser interferometer for the measurement of high-intensity focused ultrasound pressure is developed and tested. The optical carrier with a frequency shift of 358 MHz is realized by means of an acousto-optic modulator. The selected electrical devices ensure that the electrical bandwidth can reach 1.5 GHz. The laser source adopts an iodine frequency-stabilized semiconductor laser with high-frequency spectral purity, which can reduce the influence of spectral purity on the bandwidth to a negligible level. The interference light path is integrated and encapsulated to improve the stability in use. An HIFU sound pressure measurement experiment is carried out, and the upper limit of the sound pressure measurement is obviously improved.
Laser heterodyne interferometry plays a crucial role in measuring the velocity of water particles during the calibration of hydrophones with the optical method. The velocity of water particles acts as an indicator of acoustic-pressure variations and can be used to evaluate the stability of the acoustic field. The calibration of hydrophones requires a stable acoustic field environment; currently, though, the assessment of acoustic field stability is largely subjective. This study introduces the Normalized Dynamic Time-Warping (NDTW) algorithm, which objectively evaluates acoustic field stability. Sine-fitting is applied to the region of interest in the measured signal to obtain a reference signal. Subsequently, the NDTW algorithm is used to calculate the difference between the measured and reference signals, enabling the assessment of acoustic field stability. The NDTW algorithm effectively identifies subtle differences between signals and addresses the accumulation errors arising from varying signal lengths. The calibration results showed that for signals of high quality within the identified frequency band, the calibration outcomes obtained using the NDTW algorithm deviated from the reciprocity method by no more than 0.7 dB. For frequency bands with poor signal quality identified by the NDTW algorithm, the deviation between the calibration results and the reciprocity method exceeded 0.7 dB.