The effects of the German Fertilizer Application Ordinance (GFO) on crop yield, nitrogen use efficiency and economical performance are highly controversial in science and practice in Germany. This study presents the results of a multi-year field experiment conducted at an experimental farm in southern Germany, in which the effects of different fertilizer systems on crop yield, protein concentration and nitrogen balance were analyzed.
Satellite and sensor-based systems of site-specific fertilization have been developed almost exclusively in conventional farming. Agronomic and ecological advantages can also be expected from these digital methods in organic farming. However, it has not yet been investigated whether the algorithms and models are also applicable under organic farming conditions. In this study, the digital data and systems tested in the years 2021 and 2022 in southern Germany were (a) reflectance measurements with a tractor-mounted multispectral sensor, calculation of the vegetation index REIP, and application of algorithms; (b) satellite data in combination with the plant growth model PROMET; and (c) determination of the vegetation index NDVI based on satellite data. They were used to determine plant parameters (crop yield, biomass potential) and to calculate nitrogen balances at a high spatial resolution (10 × 10 m). The digital systems were tested at two sites with different organic farming systems (arable farming and dairy farming). Validation of the digital methods was carried out with ground-truth data from manual biomass sampling and combine harvester yield measurement. The nitrate leaching risk from the crop rotations of the farms was analyzed via site-specific N balancing using multi-year satellite data. The N balances were validated by measuring nitrate concentrations in leakage water. Additionally, soil properties, such as soil organic carbon (SOC) and total nitrogen (TN), were measured at the sub-field level. Using geostatistics, plant data, soil properties, and nitrate measurements were transferred into grids of the same resolution to enable correlation analyses. The correlations between yield determined with digital systems and the validation data were up to r = 0.77. Site-specific N balancing showed moderately positive correlations with nitrate concentrations in leakage water (r = 0.50–0.66). The strongly positive influence of the soil properties SOC and TN on crop yields underlines the importance of soil organic matter on soil fertility and site-specific yield potentials. The results show that digital methods allow the spatially high-resolution determination of yields and nitrogen balances in organic farming. This can be the basis for new management strategies in organic farming, e.g., the targeted use of limited nutrients to increase yields. Further validations under differentiated soil, climate, and management conditions are required to develop remote and proximal sensing applications in organic farming.
This study investigates the effects of sensor-based, variable-rate mineral nitrogen (N) application (VRA) in winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) on the spatial variability of grain yield, protein content, N uptake, N balance, and N efficiency compared with uniform N application (UA). To analyze the effects of VRA and UA on yield and N balance parameters, on-farm strip trials were conducted on heterogeneous arable fields covering an area of 49 hectares. The trials were carried out over a four-year period, from 2020 to 2023, with crops under both application methods placed in strips side-by-side. The N fertilizer requirements for growth stages (GSs) 32 and 39 were determined using an online map-overlay VRA method. This method integrated the site-specific yield potential and current plant development derived from spectral reflectance measurements using a tractor-mounted sensor system. The results show that the application of N fertilizer can be reduced by up to 38 kg ha−1 yr−1. The N efficiency can be increased by 15% and a significant reduction in variability of N balances can be achieved. However, the effects on yield and N efficiency are highly dependent on the specific application conditions (weather conditions, disease occurrence, and crop development). Not every field trial showed advantages of VRA over UA fertilization. Overall, the VRA system demonstrated encouraging potential, functioning as intended. However, further adjustment and optimization are required to ensure that the VRA fertilization system works robustly and reliably under on-farm conditions.
In this study, three digital, site-specific, yield-mapping methods for winter wheat were examined, and their precision was evaluated. The crop yields of heterogeneous fields at three locations were determined on a site-specific basis using a yield-recording system composed of a combine harvester and algorithms based on reflection measurements made via satellites, as well as a tractor-mounted sensor. As a reference, the yield was determined with a plot harvester (ground truth data). The precision of the three methods was evaluated via statistical indicators (mean, median, minimum, maximum, and standard deviation) and correlation analyses between the yield of the ground truth data and the respective method. The results show a yield variation of 4.5–10.9 t ha−1 in the trial fields. The yield of the plot harvester was strongly correlated with the yield estimate from the sensor data (R2 = 0.71–0.75), it was moderately correlated with the yield estimate from the satellite data (R2 = 0.53–0.68), and it ranged from strongly to weakly correlated with the yield map of the combine harvester (R2 = 0.30–0.72). The absolute yield can be estimated using sensor data. Slight deviations (<10%) in the absolute yield are observed with the combine harvester, and there are clear deviations (±48%) when using the satellite data. The study shows differences in the precision and accuracy of the investigated methods. Further research and optimization are urgently needed to determine the exactness of the individual methods.
Sensor- and satellite-based determination of nitrogen uptake provides critical data in site-specific fertilization algorithms. Therefore, two basic noncontact measurement methods (sensor and satellite) were investigated in winter wheat, and their precision was evaluated in this study. Nitrogen uptake at four characteristic growth stages (BBCH 31, BBCH 39, BBCH 55, and BBCH 65) was determined using algorithms based on sensor and satellite data. As a reference, nitrogen uptake was determined using biomass samples in the laboratory (ground truth data). The precision of the tested methods was evaluated using statistical indicators (mean, median, minimum, maximum, and standard deviation) and correlation analyses between the nitrogen uptake of the ground truth data and that of the respective method. The results showed moderate to strong correlations with the nitrogen uptake of the ground truth data for both methods (R2 = 0.57–0.83). Both sensor and satellite data best represented nitrogen uptake in BBCH 39 and 55 (R2 = 0.63–0.83). In sum, there were only slight deviations in the absolute amount of nitrogen uptake (≤±15%). Clear deviations can be explained by external influences during measurement. Overall, the investigations showed that the nitrogen uptake could be appropriately determined as a data basis for site-specific fertilization systems using sensor and satellite data.
Various fertilization systems have been developed to optimize nitrogen (N) application, yet their effectiveness remains a topic of debate in both science and practice. This study evaluates the effects of 28 N fertilization treatments on yield, quality, nitrogen use efficiency (NUE), N surplus, and economic optima in two winter barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) varieties—a multi-row and a two-row type—across a three-year field trial (2021–2023). Specifically, it compares the performance of fertilizer requirement calculations based on the German Fertilizer Application Ordinance (GFO), multispectral sensor-based fertilization systems, and fixed N input treatments. Under the trial conditions (highly productive fields without organic fertilization for decades), the GFO system consistently achieved high yields (>10 t ha−1) and NUE (up to 88%) for both barley varieties, often near economically optimal N rates and with minimal N surpluses. Sensor-based systems demonstrated promising potential for yield optimization and reducing N input; however, they did not result in significantly higher yields. Further research is needed to assess the performance of these fertilization systems under different conditions, such as sandy soils in regions with early-summer droughts or in systems involving organic fertilization.