This systematic mapping study provides a comprehensive review of current Fintech publications, analyzing the current state, maturity level, and future directions of Fintech research. Reviewing 518 Fintech articles across four academic databases from 2008 to 2021, we find a significant increase in Fintech studies, especially in Quartile 1 and Quartile 2 journals. Fintech and banking, Fintech development, and Fintech adoption are the most popular research areas, and articles in these areas are increasing. We propose a classification scheme for Fintech studies across five dimensions. Our study provides a unique perspective on the subject, enabling researchers and practitioners to re-evaluate the direction and scope of future Fintech research.
Customer intimacy plays a crucial role in shaping customer relationships and guiding organizational strategies. As the digital business environment has grown, the concept of customer intimacy has evolved, leading to significant changes in its dimensions and implications. This systematic literature review and synthesis comprehensively analyzes the current research on customer intimacy, reexamines it within the context of e-commerce and digital marketing, and introduces the concept of “Digital Customer Intimacy”. The paper explores the unique characteristics of digital customer intimacy, how it differs from traditional customer intimacy, and identifies areas for future research. By synthesizing insights from various studies, this review deepens our understanding of customer intimacy in both traditional and digital contexts, offering practical insights for modern marketing and laying the groundwork for future research.
This study examines how user relationships with FinTech platforms evolve beyond initial adoption, focusing on the formation of Digital Customer Intimacy (DCI) in human–machine interactions. Using a quantitative-dominant design combining survey data from 414 users and thematic analysis of open-ended responses, the study develops and tests a staged-based model linking cognitive evaluations, experiential interaction, emotional connection, and Digital Customer Intimacy (DCI). The findings show that while perceived quality and behavioural intention explain early engagement, emotional connection is the most direct driver of digital intimacy. Trust supports engagement but influences intimacy only indirectly through emotional pathways. By introducing and validating DCI as a distinct relational construct, the study extends digital service research beyond behavioural continuance toward an understanding of how emotionally meaningful interactions shape long-term digital relationships.
Structural equation modelling (SEM) is widely used in survey-based business and information systems research to assess latent constructs and theory-driven structural relationships. However, SEM path significance is obtained within a particular model specification and may not show whether findings remain stable under alternative estimation frameworks. This study develops and demonstrates a staged robustness analysis framework that connects SEM, ordinary least squares (OLS) regression, and Double Machine Learning (DML). SEM is first used to refine the measurement structure and estimate the robustness-baseline SEM model, in which the full theory-specified structural path system is retained for downstream robustness analysis before final structural path evaluation. OLS regression is then applied to SEM-derived construct scores as a transparent regression benchmark. Finally, DML-style residualisation is used to examine whether each tested focal relationship remains stable after flexible machine-learning-based adjustment for observed controls. Learner-sensitivity checks compare Random Forest, Gradient Boosting, and Support Vector Machine learners, and selected reverse-direction diagnostics are used to examine directional sensitivity. The framework is demonstrated using a FinTech Digital Customer Intimacy survey model. The findings identify which relationships are stable across SEM, OLS, and DML-style checks, and which require more cautious interpretation. A reproducible Google Colab workbook and generated result files are publicly available, providing a reusable template that researchers and students can adapt to other survey-based latent-construct studies. The paper contributes a practical robustness workflow and interpretation guide for survey-based researchers seeking to complement SEM with conventional and machine-learning-based robustness checks.
This study examines how user relationships with FinTech platforms evolve beyond initial adoption, focusing on the formation of Digital Customer Intimacy (DCI) in human–machine interactions. Using a quantitative-dominant design combining survey data from 414 users and thematic analysis of open-ended responses, the study develops and tests a staged-based model linking cognitive evaluations, experiential interaction, emotional connection, and Digital Customer Intimacy (DCI). The findings show that while perceived quality and behavioural intention explain early engagement, emotional connection is the most direct driver of digital intimacy. Trust supports engagement but influences intimacy only indirectly through emotional pathways. By introducing and validating DCI as a distinct relational construct, the study extends digital service research beyond behavioural continuance toward an understanding of how emotionally meaningful interactions shape long-term digital relationships.