This study examines how user relationships with FinTech platforms evolve beyond initial adoption, focusing on the formation of Digital Customer Intimacy (DCI) in human–machine interactions. Using a quantitative-dominant design combining survey data from 414 users and thematic analysis of open-ended responses, the study develops and tests a staged-based model linking cognitive evaluations, experiential interaction, emotional connection, and Digital Customer Intimacy (DCI). The findings show that while perceived quality and behavioural intention explain early engagement, emotional connection is the most direct driver of digital intimacy. Trust supports engagement but influences intimacy only indirectly through emotional pathways. By introducing and validating DCI as a distinct relational construct, the study extends digital service research beyond behavioural continuance toward an understanding of how emotionally meaningful interactions shape long-term digital relationships.