Herein, we investigate the performance and safety of four of the early-stage, commercial Na-ion batteries available in 2024, representing the most popular cathode types across research and commercialization: polyanion (Na-VPF), layered metal oxide (Na-NMF), and a Prussian blue analog (Na-tmCN). The cells deliver a wide range of energy density with Na-tmCN delivering the least (23 Wh/kg) and Na-NMF delivering the most (127 Wh/kg). The Na-VPF cell was in between (47 Wg/kg). Capacity retention under specified cycling conditions and with periodic 0 V excursions was the most robust for the Na-tmCN cells in both cases. Accelerating rate calorimetry (ARC) and nail penetration testing finds that Na-NMF cells do undergo thermal runaway in response to abuse, while the Na-VPF and Na-tmCN exhibit only low self-heating rates (<1 °C/min). During these safety tests, all cells exhibited off-gassing, so we conducted in-line FTIR equipped with a heated gas cell to detect CO, CO2, CH4, toxic acid gases (HCN, HF, NH3), and typical electrolyte components (carbonate ester solvents). Gases similar to those detected during Li-ion failures were found in addition to HCN for the Na-tmCN cell. Our work compares different types of commercial Na-ion batteries for the first time, allowing for a more holistic comparison of the safety and performance tradeoffs for different Na-ion cathode types emerging in 2024.
Removing residual energy from end-of-life batteries prior to transportation requires some method of deactivation. While many methods have been proposed, very few have been implemented due to limitations of cost, safety, and efficacy. In this work, multiple cell and battery types (e.g., lithium-polymer pouch cells, 18650 lithium-ion cell, alkaline batteries, and lithium-ion power-tool batteries) were deactivated using a low-cost and easily applied gel consisting of borax cross-linked polyvinyl alcohol and carbon. The PVA–carbon composite creates an external short-circuit pathway of moderate resistance that enables the complete discharge of batteries. Abusive testing conducted after deactivation demonstrates that hazards are largely eliminated, including a complete avoidance of thermal runaway from lithium-ion cells and a reduction in flammable and toxic gases by several orders of magnitude.
Herein we investigate the performance and safety of four of the early-stage, commercial Na-ion batteries available in 2024, representing the most popular cathode types across research and commercialization: polyanion (Na-VPF), layered metal oxide (Na-NMF), and Prussian blue analog (Na-tmCN). The cells deliver a wide range of energy density with the Na-tmCN delivering the least (23 Wh/kg) and Na-NMF delivering the most (127 Wh/kg). Capacity retention under specified cycling conditions and with periodic 0V excursions was the most robust for the Na-tmCN cells in both cases. Accelerating rate calorimetry (ARC) and nail penetration testing finds that Na-NMF cells do undergo thermal runaway in response to abuse, while the Na-VPF and Na-tmCN exhibit only low self-heating rates (<1 °C/min). During these safety tests, all cells exhibited off-gassing, so we conducted in-line FTIR equipped with a heated gas cell to detect CO, CO2, CH4, toxic acid gases (HCN, HF, NH3), and typical electrolyte components (carbonate ester solvents). Gases similar to those detected during Li-ion failures were found in addition to HCN for the Na-tmCN cell. Our work compares different types of commercial Na-ion batteries for the first time allowing for a more wholistic comparison of the safety and performance tradeoffs for different Na-ion cathode types emerging in 2024.