Introduction: Sustainability reporting has become increasingly important to stakeholders, and therefore, there is a growing need for a global set of standards for sustainability reporting. The International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) has recently published new sustainability standards under the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) Foundation. The consolidation of integrated reporting into the IFRS Foundation creates the problem of whether there is still a need for principles in the future of sustainability reporting and how these principles will be applied in the standard setting of the ISSB in future. This study provides insights into the similarities and differences between the Framework and the ISSB's draft IFRS S1 standard and clarifies the role that could play in the future of sustainability reporting within the context of the newly issued IFRS S1 standard.Methods: The study uses thematic content analysis on the two frameworks and comment letters submitted to the ISSB as part of the standard-setting process to understand the relevance of integrated reporting in sustainability reporting and to identify important principles contained within that can contribute to the ISSB standard-setting process in future.Results: The study identified that there is a largely positive sentiment toward in developing sustainability standards within the IFRS Foundation. The study also identified important aspects where can play a significant role in standard development, such as the connectivity of information, integrated thinking, and the six capitals that can assist organizations in understanding the significant sustainability-related risks and opportunities.Conclusion: The research points out pertinent sustainability principles that could be useful for the ISSB in future standard settings. Furthermore, the research adds to the existing literature on and can act as an impetus for further research on the use of principles in the standard-setting processes of the ISSB.
24 February 2020 in Journal of Economic and Financial Sciences
The Journal of Economic and Financial Sciences promotes research in auditing, corporate finance, corporate governance, economics, econometrics, financial accounting, financial management, financial planning, investment management, management accounting and taxation in the emerging market field.
Integrated thinking and connectivity have recently attracted particular attention in sustainability reporting. A firm’s reporting on its Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) practices should be connected to the other business functions to optimize the ESG information provided through integrated reports. Academic research on the connectivity between ESG information and other business functions is limited. Hence, the main aim of this study is to analyze and characterize the reporting connectivity between the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and other business functions of South African retail banks. This is done using a thematic content analysis of the integrated reports of each bank in the sample from 2016 to 2023. The sample consists of the top five retail banks in South Africa that are listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE). Specifically, the researchers determine the number of occurrences where the SDGs are linked to other business functions through an iterative process. Furthermore, several Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) models are implemented to identify which content elements have the strongest connectivity to the SDGs as well as to identify which elements have the strongest linkage to the various content elements. The results show that SDGs are primarily linked to stakeholders, the business model, and performance. Furthermore, it was found that this sample of South African banks most prominently links these business functions to SDG 8, which aligns with the banks’ purpose of furthering economic development.
Due to tough economic conditions, more retailers are relying on lay-by agreements to maintain revenue. Lay-by agreements are thus part of their business models and are included in their forecasting and budgeting strategies. As part of financial planning, decisions need to be made based on financial information to achieve organisational goals. A recent South African income tax amendment regarding lay-by agreements resulted in three possible income tax interpretations. This study analysed and evaluated the implications of these amendments for South African deferred tax. The study utilised a doctrinal approach in an interpretive paradigm. The results show that the amendment in the South African Income Tax Act relating to lay-by agreements has an impact on deferred tax calculations, depending on the tax interpretation used. The resulting ambiguity and diversion in the practice of the deferred tax treatment may potentially lead to less useful financial information, contrary to the objectives of the International Accounting Standards Board for effective decision making. This study recommends that the National Treasury should clarify this ambiguity, through either legislative amendments or an interpretation note. This will create the necessary certainty for organisations to plan their finances.