Background: Informed consent of the patient prior to surgical procedures is obligatory. A good and informative communication improves patients’ understanding and confidence, thus may strengthen the patient-doctor relationship. The aim of our study was to investigate the usefulness of additional stereoscopic visualization of patient-specific imaging during informed consent conversation. Methods: Patients scheduled for a brain tumor surgery were screened for this study prospectively. The primary exclusion criteria were cognitive or visual impairments. The participants were randomized into two groups. The first group underwent a conventional surgical informed consent performed by a neurosurgeon including a demonstration of the individual MRI on a 2D computer screen. The second group received an additional stereoscopic visualization of the same imaging to explain the pathology more in-depth. The patients were then asked to fill in a questionnaire after each part. This questionnaire was designed to assess the potential information gained from the patients with details on the anatomical location of the tumor as well as the surgical procedure and possible complications. Patients’ subjective impression about the informed consent was assessed using a 5-point Likert scale. Results: A total of 27 patients were included in this study. After additional stereoscopic visualization, no significant increase in patient understanding was found for either objective criteria or subjective assessment. Participants’ anxiety was not increased by stereoscopic visualization. Overall, patients perceived stereoscopic imaging as helpful from a subjective perspective. Confidence in the department was high in both groups. Conclusion: Stereoscopic visualization of MRI images within informed consent conversation did not improve the objective understanding of the patients in our series. Although no objective anatomical knowledge gain was noted in this series, patients felt that the addition of stereoscopic visualization improved their overall understanding. It therefore potentially increases patient confidence in treatment decisions.
Stereoscopic imaging has increasingly been used in anatomical teaching and neurosurgery. The aim of our study was to analyze the potential utility of stereoscopic imaging as a tool for memorizing neurosurgical patient cases compared to conventional monoscopic visualization. A total of 16 residents and 6 consultants from the Department of Neurosurgery at Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin were recruited for the study. They were divided into two equally experienced groups. A comparative analysis of both imaging modalities was conducted in which four different cases were assessed by the participants. Following the image assessment, two questionnaires, one analyzing the subjective judgment using the 5-point Likert Scale and the other assessing the memorization and anatomical accuracy, were completed by all participants. Both groups had the same median year of experience (5) and stereoacuity (≤ 75 s of arc). The analysis of the first questionnaire demonstrated significant subjective superiority of the monoscopic imaging in evaluation of the pathology (median: monoscopic: 4; stereoscopic: 3; p = 0.020) and in handling of the system (median: monoscopic: 5; stereoscopic: 2; p < 0.001). The second questionnaire showed that the anatomical characterization of the pathologies was comparable between both visualization methods. Most participants rated the stereoscopic visualization as worse compared to the monoscopic visualization, probably due to a lack of familiarity with the newer technique. Stereoscopic imaging, however, was not objectively inferior to traditional monoscopic imaging for anatomical comprehension. Further methodological developments and incorporation in routine clinical workflows will most likely enhance the usability and acceptance of stereoscopic visualization.
Background/Objectives: Audio and audiovisual distraction can be effective additive tools to reduce anxiety and pain in patients receiving outpatient procedures (OP). Audiovisual distraction tools already showed positive effects on pain perception in some urological procedures. To identify the effects of audio and audiovisual distraction on pain and anxiety in patients receiving perineal prostate biopsy (PPB), we performed a prospective randomized controlled study. Methods: We recruited 168 male patients undergoing PPB which were randomized into three groups: a control group (CG), an audio distraction group (ADG) and an audiovisual distraction group (AVDG). The CG received no intervention, while the ADG received audio distraction and the AVDG received audiovisual distraction while PPB was performed. The primary endpoint was pain perception, measured in the Numeric Rating Scale (NRS) and Visual Analogue Scale (VAS). Secondary endpoints were subjective and objective procedure time (SPT/OPT), heart rate, blood pressure, cortisol blood levels and scores in the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) questionnaire. Results: Demographics of each group were similar (CG = mean age (a) = 69.5; ADG a = 67 years; AVDG a = 67). We did not find any significant difference regarding our primary endpoint, pain perception (p = 0.384). In contrast, we examined a highly significant difference between SPT and OPT, comparing AVDG to CG (p < 0.001) and AVDG to ADG (p < 0.001), but not for ADG to CG (p = 0.348). There was no significant difference in the secondary endpoints, heart rate, blood pressure, STAI scores and willingness to repeat the procedure. Conclusions: Our study shows that audiovisual distraction can significantly shorten SPT for patients receiving PPB, which may represent their comfort throughout the procedure. To accelerate the wider implementation of audiovisual distraction as a cost-efficient tool in outpatient urological procedures, further studies should examine its effect on different OPs with a more heterogeneous patient group.