Muhammet Ali Heyik

Dr. Muhammet Ali Heyik

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
2 April 2025 in Sustainability
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
EKEmre Karataş
Emre Karataş
AOAysun Ozkose
Aysun Ozkose
MHMuhammet Ali Heyik
Muhammet Ali Heyik
Urban mass tourism and rural depopulation increasingly threaten heritage sites worldwide, leading to socio-economic and environmental challenges. This study adopts a holistic approach to sustainable tourism planning by examining 84 cultural and natural heritage sites in and around Safranbolu and Amasra, two cities in Türkiye that are listed on the UNESCO World Heritage List and the Tentative List. Inspired by historical travelers’ itineraries, it proposes an eco-cultural tourism route to create a resilient heritage network. A participatory methodology integrates charettes within Erasmus+ workshops, crowdsourcing, various analysis methods while engaging stakeholders, and AI-powered clustering for route determination. The study follows a four-stage framework: (1) data collection via collaborative GIS, (2) eco-cultural route development, (3) stakeholder participation for inclusivity and viability, and (4) assessments and recommendations. Results highlight the strong potential of heritage assets for sustainable tourism while identifying key conservation risks. Interviews and site analysis underscore critical challenges, including the absence of integrated site management strategies, insufficient capacity-building initiatives, and ineffective participatory mechanisms. Moreover, integrating GIS-based crowdsourcing, machine learning clustering, and multi-criteria decision-making can be an effective planning support system. In conclusion, this study enhances the sustainability of heritage and tourism by strengthening participatory eco-cultural development and mitigating mass tourism and abandonment’s negative impacts on the heritage sites.

16 March 2024 in Urban Governance
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MHMuhammet Ali Heyik
Muhammet Ali Heyik
MCMaria Camila Castellanos-Escobar
Maria Camila Castellanos-Escobar
JRJosé María Romero-Martínez
José María Romero-Martínez
ZÇZühal Çalışkan
Zühal Çalışkan
Participation is often employed by authorities as a unilateral tool for gathering data from citizens, informing them about processes, and obtaining legitimacy and accountability, rather than truly empowering or collaborating with citizens. However, many scholars emphasize the vital role of civic consciousness and collective intelligence (CI) in addressing chronic issues and global crises related to shared interests and values. To achieve this with effective participatory design and planning (PD&P) processes, it's essential to understand citizens' perspectives rather than imposing ‘one-size-fits-all’ approaches. We explored how citizens evaluate existing PD&P mechanisms in three capital cities: Ankara, Bogota, and Madrid, representing developed, developing, and least-developed countries. Through collective experiments using conjoint analysis, we conducted citizen interviews based on the CI genome consisting of key dimensions and attributes of PD&P for public spaces. Crowdsourcing applications were integrated to enhance field studies. Additionally, chord diagrams and scatter charts visually depict interrelations among the grouped and ranked genome attributes. Our analysis explores variations and commonalities across cities and includes reflections from students. The results show that PD&P is perceived as significantly important, while top-down political decisions are perceived as dissatisfactory by most respondents. Notably, Madrid stands out positively in certain dimensions, including the willingness for active participation, multi-functionality as a capital, and diversity of initiatives. In addition, the political culture, respondents' education, age, and attachment to the city have significant influences on preferred methods, prioritized issues, and attitudes. Despite its limitations, conjoint analysis holds promise as a method to understand citizens' demands and design robust PD&P settings for deeper and broader involvement.

23 September 2025 in Urban Governance
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
MHMuhammet Ali Heyik
Muhammet Ali Heyik
MEMeral Erdoğan
Meral Erdoğan
JRJosé María Romero-Martínez
José María Romero-Martínez
The ecosocial transition advocates for an approach that is ecocentric, transdisciplinary, resource-efficient, socially inclusive, equitable, and democratic. Over the past decade, digital participatory platforms (DPPs) have gained prominence in supporting ecosocial transitions by addressing chronic and wicked problems affecting both specific territories and the planet as a whole. However, fragmented overviews and biases in socio-spatial and socio-technical contexts have left a notable knowledge gap between technological advancements and research on their affordances in urban planning and design ecosystems. This study examines how DPPs are introduced and conceptualized in literature. It explores distinguishing characteristics, emerging trends, and key success factors of geospatial DPPs through the lens of the collective intelligence (CI) framework. Following the PRISMA protocol, a systematic review was conducted across Scopus, Google Scholar, and public repositories, identifying 312 platforms worldwide. The coded descriptions of platforms were analyzed using content analysis, network mapping, and AI-powered clustering to reveal underlying patterns and relationships. Our findings reveal a diverse spectrum of technological features, human-computer interactions, and engagement levels across DPPs. However, geographical distribution and effective institutional adoption remain limited. Nearly half of the examined geospatial platforms rely on one-way information flow focused on data aggregation, while co-creation platforms increasingly adopt advanced technologies such as gamified urban simulators, extended realities, and networked sentient technologies to foster interaction and co-design capabilities. The insights from this comprehensive review contribute to a better understanding of DPPs for ecosocial transition, emphasizing key design aspects such as accessibility, transparency, transferability, user-friendliness, follow-up mechanisms, and continuous feedback. Given the complexity of urban governance and the challenges commonly highlighted in the literature regarding participatory approaches, DPPs are predominantly deployed to complement—rather than replace—existing top-down and technocratic planning frameworks. Strengthening the concept of participants as co-researchers within action research remains essential for fostering long-term systemic impact and stakeholder empowerment.

28 December 2023 in ICONARP International Journal of Architecture and Planning
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MHMuhammet Ali Heyik
Muhammet Ali Heyik
MEMeral Erdoğan
Meral Erdoğan
TTTOGAN TONG
TOGAN TONG
The study develops the 'Ostrakinda' toolkit for teaching morphologies of ancient Mediterranean cities. The methodology consists of a triple structure involving design, play, and analysis phases. In the design phase, the level of interest and actual demands of students regarding game-based learning (GBL) and ancient cities were explored through pre-experiments. The play phase involved experimental studies conducted in courses and workshops, where both physical and digital toolkits were tested by a total of 331 students. The analysis phase aimed to evaluate the impact of the game by systematically addressing five research questions. The results of the paired t-test confirm a significant difference in scores before and after playing the game, thus validating the effectiveness of the proposed strategy. Additionally, Chi-square (X2) tests revealed significant relationships between the form of play and the level of abstraction in the game outputs. Individual and group experiences during gameplay were associated with various interactions, and group experiences particularly fostered competitive and collaborative learning. The extensive analysis using the GBL Design Scale, comprising ten critical factors (GBL-Fn), showed that the challenge factor (F8) had the weakest values, while fantasy (F5) and narrative (F6) had the highest values in the correlation matrix. Overall, the study contributes methodologically and contextually to the existing literature, offering valuable findings for the future development of similar strategies in architectural education. However, it is important to acknowledge the limitations of this interdisciplinary study, particularly with regards to technical, cognitive, and archaeological aspects. Nevertheless, the clear and effective structure of the game holds promise as a valuable tool for learning.

2 January 2024 in International Journal of Architectural Computing
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
MHMuhammet Ali Heyik
Muhammet Ali Heyik
DODerya Gulec Ozer
Derya Gulec Ozer
FAFrancisco Javier Abarca-Alvarez
Francisco Javier Abarca-Alvarez
JRJosé María Romero-Martínez
José María Romero-Martínez
This study introduces a collective cartography strategy for analyzing complex urban spaces. It was applied during a 7-day Erasmus + workshop with 46 participants from universities in Spain, Turkey, Portugal, and Poland, representing various backgrounds such as urban planning, architecture, heritage, information technologies, and tourism. The workshop's objective was to identify critical urban issues and generate sustainable and multisensory urban space concepts. The impact of this strategy, from co-sensing to co-ideation, was evaluated by its influence on collaboration and the development of self-generated tactics during the process. Within this context, we explored various group tactics, including multisensor data collection, multi-criteria-based analysis, crowdsourcing for site diagnosis, and distributed collaboration to enhance diverse perspectives and narratives. The findings, outputs, and reflections from participants indicate highly interactive, productive, and inclusive co-creation settings. These were facilitated through a web-based virtual collective space (Doyoucity) and a crowdsourcing mobile app for on-site data collection and analysis (Fulcrum).

25 October 2024 in ITU Press, Press of the Istanbul Technical University
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
MHMuhammet Ali Heyik
Muhammet Ali Heyik
JMJosé María Romero Martínez
José María Romero Martínez
MEMeral Erdoğan
Meral Erdoğan