In architectural design, a well-structured and adaptable approach is fundamental to creating functional and cohesive spaces, providing a foundational framework for spatial organization. As design requirements grow increasingly complex, traditional methods often fall short of addressing multifaceted design needs, such as user preferences, environmental considerations, and geometric constraints. Computational design techniques offer advanced methods to automate and refine architectural space planning. Despite significant advancements in computational software and data processing capabilities, challenges remain in practically embedding diverse design criteria. This study systematically reviews computational methods for architectural spatial design from 2013 to 2023, analyzing methodologies, typological applications, user preferences, and advancements in environmental data integration. The findings highlight a shift from rule-based to data-driven approaches, emphasizing the development of scalable and intuitive tools. This research identifies pathways for adopting computational design in architectural practice and education, underlining the critical role of user-centered adaptability and environmental responsiveness in shaping future tools.
This study aimed to compare and investigate the efficacy of the real-world experiences, immersive virtual reality (IVR) experiences, and video walkthrough representations on layout-learning in a complex building. A quasi-experimental, intervention, and delayed post-test research design was used among three groups: real-world, IVR, and video walkthrough representation. A total of 41 first-year design students from architecture, and game design departments were attended the study. Design students were selected as they already know how to communicate graphically the layout of a building on paper. IVR and video walkthrough groups experienced the representations of the building by themselves, but real-world group experienced the building within a group as imitating a design education field trip. After 10 days, a total of 26 participants out of 41 tested for spatial recall performance. Recall performances were measured as an indicator of layout learning by analysing the plan sketches drawn by the participants. Results showed IVR group recalled significantly more spatial memories compared with the real-world and video walkthrough representation groups. Real-world group performed the worst among three groups. This result was interpreted to three conclusions. First, the layout learning tends to be overly sensitive to distractions and lower levels of distraction may lead to better levels of layout learning. Second, for the domain of layout knowledge learning, a remarkably simple IVR model is enough. Third, although real-world experiences give direct and richer sensory information about the spaces, layout knowledge acquisition from the surrounding environment requires psychologically active wayfinding decisions.
28 December 2023 in ICONARP International Journal of Architecture and Planning
The study develops the 'Ostrakinda' toolkit for teaching morphologies of ancient Mediterranean cities. The methodology consists of a triple structure involving design, play, and analysis phases. In the design phase, the level of interest and actual demands of students regarding game-based learning (GBL) and ancient cities were explored through pre-experiments. The play phase involved experimental studies conducted in courses and workshops, where both physical and digital toolkits were tested by a total of 331 students. The analysis phase aimed to evaluate the impact of the game by systematically addressing five research questions. The results of the paired t-test confirm a significant difference in scores before and after playing the game, thus validating the effectiveness of the proposed strategy. Additionally, Chi-square (X2) tests revealed significant relationships between the form of play and the level of abstraction in the game outputs. Individual and group experiences during gameplay were associated with various interactions, and group experiences particularly fostered competitive and collaborative learning. The extensive analysis using the GBL Design Scale, comprising ten critical factors (GBL-Fn), showed that the challenge factor (F8) had the weakest values, while fantasy (F5) and narrative (F6) had the highest values in the correlation matrix. Overall, the study contributes methodologically and contextually to the existing literature, offering valuable findings for the future development of similar strategies in architectural education. However, it is important to acknowledge the limitations of this interdisciplinary study, particularly with regards to technical, cognitive, and archaeological aspects. Nevertheless, the clear and effective structure of the game holds promise as a valuable tool for learning.
In the current Architecture, Engineering, Construction, and Operations (AECO) sector, the demand for a skilled workforce capable of responding to rapidly changing needs is increasing. However, academic programs are struggling to keep up with this transformation. The integration of Building Information Modeling (BIM) tools into design studios and the objective evaluation of the pedagogical outcomes of this process are not yet fully clear. This study develops a pedagogical evaluation framework to integrate professional BIM competencies into architectural design studio curricula. This framework aims to measure student competency development and guide the restructuring of academic programs for BIM-supported education. A mixed methodology was adopted in the research; utilizing a combination of purposive and convenience sampling techniques, the studio performances, submission processes, and survey data of 409 students studying in architecture and interior architecture departments over a four-year period were analyzed longitudinally using the developed measurement-evaluation model. The proposed framework serves to pedagogically grade students’ in-studio performance and to measure acquired competencies with structured criteria. The qualitative data obtained from the surveys were analyzed through thematic and content analysis. The research revealed that students possessed limited technical skills in BIM projects and experienced deficiencies in collaboration and data management. Furthermore, it determined that instructors’ lack of knowledge regarding integrating BIM into the curriculum negatively impacted students’ learning processes. This study recommended enhancing teacher training for BIM-supported education, improving collaboration and coordination skills, and aligning the curriculum with professional requirements. The findings provide a framework that not only better prepares students for professional life but also helps bridge the gap between education and industry. Through this framework, students’ competencies can be measured at the pedagogical level.