Nowadays, the possibility that medium-large earthquakes could produce some electromagnetic ionospheric disturbances during their preparatory phase is controversial in the scientific community. Some previous works using satellite data from DEMETER, Swarm and, recently, CSES provided several pieces of evidence supporting the existence of such precursory phenomena in terms of single case studies and statical analyses. In this work, we applied a Worldwide Statistical Correlation approach to M5.5+ shallow earthquakes using the first 8 years of Swarm (i.e., from November 2013 to November 2021) magnetic field and electron density signals in order to improve the significance of previous statistical studies and provide some new results on how earthquake features could influence ionospheric electromagnetic disturbances. We implemented new methodologies based on the hypothesis that the anticipation time of anomalies of larger earthquakes is usually longer than that of anomalies of smaller magnitude. We also considered the signal’s frequency to introduce a new identification criterion for the anomalies. We find that taking into account the frequency can improve the statistical significance (up to 25% for magnetic data and up to 100% for electron density). Furthermore, we noted that the frequency of the Swarm magnetic field signal of possible precursor anomalies seems to slightly increase as the earthquake is approaching. Finally, we checked a possible relationship between the frequency of the detected anomalies and earthquake features. The earthquake focal mechanism seems to have a low or null influence on the frequency of the detected anomalies, while the epicenter location appears to play an important role. In fact, land earthquakes are more likely to be preceded by slower (lower frequency) magnetic field signals, whereas sea seismic events show a higher probability of being preceded by faster (higher frequency) magnetic field signals.
Since the appearance and evolution of earthquake ionospheric precursors are expected to show a nonlinear and complex behaviour, the use of nonlinear predictor models seems more appropriate. This paper proposes a new approach based on deep learning as a powerful tool for extracting the nonlinear patterns from a time series of ionospheric precursors. A Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) network as a type of Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) was used to investigate 52 six-month time series, deduced from the three Swarm satellite (Alpha (A), Bravo (B) and Charlie (C)) measurements, including electron density (Ne), electron temperature (Te), magnetic scalar and vector (X, Y, Z) components, Slant and Vertical Total Electron Content (STEC and VTEC), for day and night periods around the time and location of a seismic event. This new approach was tested on a strong Mw = 7.1 earthquake in Japan on 13 February 2021, at 14:07:50 UTC by comparing the results with two implemented methods, i.e., Median and LSTM methods. Furthermore, clear anomalies are seen by a voting classification method 1, 6, 8, 13, 31 and 32 days before the earthquake. A comparison with atmospheric data investigation is further provided, supporting the lithosphere–atmosphere–ionosphere coupling (LAIC) mechanism as a suitable theory to explain the alteration of upper geolayers in the earthquake preparation phase. In other words, using multi-method and multi-precursor analysis applied to 52 time series and also to the orbit-by-orbit investigation, the observed anomalies on the previous day and up to 32 days before the event in normal solar and quiet geomagnetic conditions could be considered as a striking hint of the forthcoming Japan earthquake.
Several possible lithosphere–atmosphere–ionosphere coupling mechanisms before earthquake occurrence are presented in the literature. They are described by several models with different interaction channels (e.g., electromagnetic, mechanics, chemical, thermal), sometimes in conflict with each other. In this paper, we search for anomalies six months before the Lushan (China) 2013 earthquake in the three geo-layers looking for a possible view of the couplings and testing if one or another is more reliable to describe the observations. The Lushan earthquake occurred in China’s Sichuan province on 20 April 2013, with a magnitude of Mw = 6.7. Despite the moderate magnitude of the event, it caused concern because its source was localized on the southwest side of the same fault that produced the catastrophic Wenchuan event in 2008. This paper applies a geophysical multi-layer approach to search for possible pre-earthquake anomalies in the lithosphere, atmosphere, and ionosphere. In detail, six main increases in the accumulated seismic stress were depicted. Anomalous geomagnetic pulsations were recorded in the Chengdu observatory, sometimes following the increased stress. Atmosphere status and composition were found to be anomalous in several periods before the earthquake, and, spatially, the anomalies seem to appear firstly far from the upcoming earthquakes and later approaching the Longmenshan fault where the Lushan earthquakes nucleated. The Formosat-3 data identified interesting anomalies in the altitude or electron content of the ionospheric F2 peak in correspondence with seismic and atmospheric anomalies 130 days before the earthquake. In addition, the total electron content showed high anomalous values from 12 to 6 days before the earthquake. We compared the anomalies and tried to explain their correspondences in different geo-layers by the lithosphere–atmosphere–ionosphere coupling models. In particular, we identified three possible couplings with different mechanisms: a first, about 130 days before the earthquake, with a fast (order of one day) propagation delay; a second, about 40 days before the earthquake occurrence, with a propagation delay of few days and a third from 2.5 weeks until one week before the event. Such evidence suggests that the geo-layers could interact with different channels (pure electromagnetic or a chain of physical-chemical processes) with specific propagation delays. Such results support the understanding of the preparation for medium and large earthquakes globally, which is necessary (although not sufficient) knowledge in order to mitigate their impact on human life.
On 19 September 2021, La Palma Cumbre Vieja Volcano started an eruption classified as Volcanic Explosive Index (VEI) 3. In this study, at least the six months prior to such an event have been investigated to search for possible lithosphere–atmosphere–ionosphere bottom-up interactions. The lithosphere has been analysed in terms of seismicity getting advantages from the high-density local seismic network. Possible atmospheric alterations related to the volcano emissions or release of gases due to the uplift of the magmatic chamber have been searched in SO2, aerosol, dimethyl sulphide, and CO. The magnetic field on Earth’s surface has been studied by ground geomagnetic observatories. The status of the ionosphere has been investigated with two satellite missions: China Seismo Electromagnetic Satellite (CSES) and European Space Agency Swarm constellation, with Total Electron Content (TEC) retrieved from global maps. We identified a temporal migration of the seismicity from November 2020 at a depth of 40 km that seems associable to magma migration, firstly to a deep chamber at about 15 km depth and in the last 10 days in a shallow magma chamber at less than 5 km depth. The atmospheric composition, ground geomagnetic field, and ionosphere showed anomalies from more than three months before the eruption, suggesting a possible influence from the bottom geo-layers to the upper ones. CSES-01 detected an increase of electron density, confirmed by TEC data, and alterations of vertical magnetic field on ground Guimar observatory that are temporal compatible with some volcanic low seismic activity (very likely due to the magma uplift), suggesting an eventual electromagnetic disturbance from the lithosphere to the ionosphere. A final increase of carbon monoxide 1.5 months before the eruption with unusually high values of TEC suggests the last uplifting of the magma before the eruption, confirmed by a very high shallow seismicity that preceded the eruption by ten days. This work underlines the importance of integrating several observation platforms from ground and overall space to understand geophysics better, and, in particular, the natural hazard affecting our planet.
4 August 2022 in IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing
A nonnegative tensor decomposition (NTD) approach has been developed to analyze the ionospheric magnetic field data of the Swarm Alpha and Charlie satellites for the Mw7.8 2015 Nepal earthquake. All available satellite data were analyzed regardless of geomagnetic activity. We used the amplitude time–frequency spectra of the two-satellite data to build third-order tensors and decomposed them into three components. One of these components seems to be more affected by seismicity. In particular, the cumulative number of anomalous tracks of this component displays accelerated growth that conforms to a sigmoid fit from 60 to 40 days before the mainshock. Subsequently, until ten days before the earthquake, it shows a weak accelerating trend that obeys a power-law behavior and then resumes linear growth after the mainshock. Moreover, the cumulative anomaly was indicated not to be caused by geomagnetic activity, solar activity, or other nonseismic factors. An investigation of the foreshocks around the epicenter reveals that the cumulative Benioff strain also exhibited two accelerated growths before the mainshock, which is consistent with the cumulative result of ionospheric anomalies. In the first acceleration stage, seismicity appeared in the region surrounding the epicenter, and most of the ionospheric anomalies were offset away from the epicenter. During the second acceleration stage, some foreshocks occurred closer to or on the mainshock fault, and ionospheric anomalies also appeared near two faults around the epicenter. Furthermore, the correspondence between the ionospheric anomalies and the anomalies in different geolayers can be explained by the lithosphere–atmosphere–ionosphere coupling model.
This paper investigates possible anomalies on the occasion of the ML = 3.3 earthquake, which occurred on 1st January 2023 close to Guidonia Montecelio (Rome, Italy). This earthquake followed another very close event recorded on 23 December 2022 with a magnitude ML = 3.1 (epicentral distance of less than 1 km). Seismological investigations clearly show an acceleration of seismicity in the preceding six months in a circular area of about a 60 km radius. Two conclusions coming from the time-to-failure power law fitting to the cumulative Benioff strain curve are the most probable: the ML3.3 of 1 January 2023 is the mainshock of the seismic sequence, or an incoming earthquake of a magnitude of about 4.1 provides a slightly better fit (higher determination coefficient) of the seismic data. Further investigations are necessary to assess whether the accumulated stress has been totally released. No atmospheric anomalies related to this seismic activity have been identified, even if some SO2 emissions seem to be induced by the tectonic and volcanic sources in the south Tyrrhenian Sea. Swarm satellite magnetic data show about 20 anomalous tracks six months before the Guidonia earthquake. In particular, on 16 December 2022, anomalous oscillations of the east component of the geomagnetic field are temporally compatible with the seismic acceleration, but other sources are also possible. Other anomalous magnetic signals are more likely to be associated with the ongoing seismic activity offshore of the Marche region in Italy (the strongest event up to now is Mw = 5.5 on 9 November 2022 close to Pesaro Urbino).