The susceptibility to chilling injury and its relationship with changes in the phenolic compounds content and antioxidant capacity were evaluated in five mango cultivars (Ataulfo, Haden, Keitt, Kent, and Tommy Atkins) with export quality. The chilling injury index (CII), postharvest quality (color, firmness, and total soluble solids (TSS)), bioactive compounds (total phenolic, and total flavonoids), and antioxidant capacity (ABTS, DPPH, and ORAC) were determined during storage at chilling (5 ºC) and non-chilling temperature (13 °C) plus 7 days at ripening (21 °C). Ataulfo cultivar showed the lowest CII, and the best color retention and higher TSS content, but the lowest firmness and the highest accumulation of phenolics, flavonoids, and antioxidant capacity during the ripening period, in both storage temperature. In contrast, Keitt cultivar presented the highest CII, especially to 21 °C, showing the highest firmness and the lowest TSS. The bioactive compounds and antioxidant capacity were low. Kent showed the lowest content of bioactive compounds and antioxidant capacity. Tommy Atkins presented the lowest luminosity and Hue angle values but similar behavior to Haden in the rest of parameters. This indicates that the increase in bioactive compounds, especially flavonoids, improves antioxidant capacity and could generate greater tolerance to CI. Therefore, Ataulfo could be stored at low temperatures, extending its commercial life and regular ripening, while Keitt should not be stored at low temperatures due to susceptibility and irregular ripening.