Stochastic modeling and analysis of international key compar isons (interlaboratory comparisons) pose several fundamental questions for statistical methodology. A key comparison (KC) is specifically designed to derive the key comparison reference value and to assess conformance of cal ibrations by participating national metrology laboratories at a few, “key”, settings for a particular measurement process. An approach to the statis tical study of key comparisons data is proposed using a model taken from meta-analysis. This model leads to a class of weighted means estimators for the consensus value and to a method of assessing the uncertainty of the resulting estimates.
Bayes estimators for the unknown mean against a reference, non-informative prior distribution for both the mean and independent variances are derived. I entertain the scenario with two groups of observables with the same unknown mean. The unknown variances of the the first group are not supposed to be equal or to be restricted; the second homeogeneous group of observations all have the same unknown variance. Under the normality condition, these procedures turn out to have a very explicit form of the weighted average with data-dependent weights that admit of a very clear interpretation. The approximate formulas for the variance of the considered estimators and their limiting behavior are also examined. The related “self-dual” orthogonal polynomials and their properties are examined. Recursive formulas for estimators on the basis of these polynomials are developed.
Notable discrete probability laws appear as posterior distributions in the estimation of the common mean with heterogeneous variances. These probabilities, which are defined by an arbitrary set of distinct real numbers, also arise in seemingly unrelated areas of polynomial approximation and statistical physics. The corresponding orthogonal polynomials possess an interesting self-duality property, which invites the study of statistical distributions based on data parity. These distributions provide novel, intriguing formulas for the classical hypergeometric function along with several combinatorial identities.