Tumor cell heterogeneity is a crucial characteristic of malignant brain tumors and underpins phenomena such as therapy resistance and tumor recurrence. Advances in single‐cell analysis have enabled the delineation of distinct cellular states of brain tumor cells, but the time‐dependent changes in such states remain poorly understood. Here, we construct quantitative models of the time‐dependent transcriptional variation of patient‐derived glioblastoma (GBM) cells. We build the models by sampling and profiling barcoded GBM cells and their progeny over the course of 3 weeks and by fitting a mathematical model to estimate changes in GBM cell states and their growth rates. Our model suggests a hierarchical yet plastic organization of GBM, where the rates and patterns of cell state switching are partly patient‐specific. Therapeutic interventions produce complex dynamic effects, including inhibition of specific states and altered differentiation. Our method provides a general strategy to uncover time‐dependent changes in cancer cells and offers a way to evaluate and predict how therapy affects cell state composition.
Glioblastoma multiforme continues to have a dismal prognosis. Even though detailed information on the genetic aberrations in cell signaling and cell-cycle checkpoint control is available, no effective targeted treatment has been developed. Despite the advanced molecular defects, glioblastoma cells may have remnants of normal growth-inhibitory pathways, such as the bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling pathway. We have evaluated the growth-inhibitory effect of BMP4 across a broad spectrum of patient samples, using a panel of 40 human glioblastoma initiating cell (GIC) cultures. A wide range of responsiveness was observed. BMP4 sensitivity was positively correlated with a proneural mRNA expression profile, high SOX2 activity, and BMP4-dependent upregulation of genes associated with inhibition of the MAPK pathway, as demonstrated by gene set enrichment analysis. BMP4 response in sensitive cells was mediated by the canonical BMP receptor pathway involving SMAD1/5/9 phosphorylation and SMAD4 expression. SOX2 was consistently downregulated in BMP4-treated cells. Forced expression of SOX2 attenuated the BMP4 sensitivity including a reduced upregulation of MAPK-inhibitory genes, implying a functional relationship between SOX2 downregulation and sensitivity. The results show an extensive heterogeneity in BMP4 responsiveness among GICs and identify a BMP4-sensitive subgroup, in which SOX2 is a mediator of the response. Implications: Development of agonists targeting the BMP signaling pathway in glioblastoma is an attractive avenue toward a better treatment. Our study may help find biomarkers that predict the outcome of such treatment and enable stratification of patients.
Glioblastoma (GBM) is a highly malignant brain tumor with extensive cellular heterogeneity and plasticity. Bone morphogenetic protein 4 (BMP4) has shown potential as a therapeutic agent by promoting differentiation, but its effects are complex and context dependent. While BMP4’s role in differentiation is well established, its impact on senescence remains unclear. This study investigates BMP4’s ability to induce senescence in GBM cells. Primary GBM cultures were treated with BMP4 and analyzed for senescence markers, including cell enlargement, p21 expression, senescence-related gene enrichment, and senescence-associated-β-galactosidase activity. A p21 knockout model was used to determine its role in BMP4-induced senescence, and sensitivity to the senolytic agent navitoclax was evaluated. BMP4 induced senescence in the GBM cultures, particularly in mesenchymal (MES)-like GBM cells with high baseline p21 levels. The knockout of p21 nearly abolished BMP4-induced senescence, maintaining cell size and proliferation. Furthermore, navitoclax effectively eliminated BMP4-induced senescent cells through apoptosis, while sparing cells with normal p21 expression. Our findings highlight BMP4 as an inducer of p21-dependent senescence in GBM, particularly in MES-like cells. This study clarifies BMP4’s dual roles in differentiation and senescence, emphasizing their context dependence. Given the strong link between MES-like cells and therapy resistance, their heightened susceptibility to senescence may aid in developing targeted therapies for GBM and potentially other cancers with similar cellular dynamics.
Bone morphogenetic protein 4 (BMP4) has emerged as a potential glioblastoma therapy due to its anti- proliferative effect via SOX2 downregulation and differentiation promotion. However, BMP4 responses vary across and within tumors. Our previous data indicate that BMP4 induces transition to a mesenchymal-like cell state. Mesenchymal transition is associated with therapy-resistance and tumor recurrence, as is senescence in cancer. In this study, we investigated BMP4’s potential to induce senescence in primary glioblastoma cells, including proneural- and mesenchymal-like clones derived from the same tumor. BMP4 treatment induced senescence-associated genes and phenotypic changes such as cell enlargement, senescence- associated-β-gal expression, lamin B1 downregulation, and elevated p21 levels. The most robust senescence induction was observed in the mesenchymal-like clone, compared to its proneural counterpart. Notably, mesenchymal-like cells displayed high basal levels of p21 and other senescence- associated markers, suggesting a convergence of mesenchymal and senescent traits. p21 knockout abolished BMP4-induced senescence, maintaining proliferation and cell size despite SOX2 downregulation. Additionally, senolytic treatment effectively eliminated senescent cells through apoptosis, thereby favoring survival of cells retaining normal p21 levels. Our findings demonstrate BMP4’s ability to induce p21-dependent senescence in glioblastoma, particularly in therapy-resistant mesenchymal-like cells. These insights provide potential therapeutic strategies targeting senescence pathways in this challenging disease.
Table S1. Enriched GO terms for commonly upregulated genes in responsive cell lines and U3017MG harboring the control vector upon BMP4 treatment, according to the Database for Annotation, Visualization and Integrated Discovery (DAVID).
Table S1. Enriched GO terms for commonly upregulated genes in responsive cell lines and U3017MG harboring the control vector upon BMP4 treatment, according to the Database for Annotation, Visualization and Integrated Discovery (DAVID).