Antibiotic and heavy metal-resistant pathogenic bacteria associated with fish from contaminated water can spread diseases. This study aims to identify antibiotics, lead, and silver nitrate-resistant bacteria in 180 fish samples from Lake Chivero using bacterial identification, disk-diffusion, and agar dilution methodologies. Of the identified 157 bacterial isolates, 46 (29.3%) were Staphylococcus, 35 (22.3%) were Escherichia coli, 26 (16.6%) were Aeromonas spp., 15 (9.6%) were Shigella spp., 13 (8.3%) were Bacillus cereus, 12 (7.6%) were Edwardsiella tarda, 7 (4.5%) were Proteus mirabilis, and 3 (1.9%) were Listeria spp. Gentamicin was the most effective, with 100% of the bacterial species susceptible, followed by neomycin (68.2%), tetracycline (56.7%), cloxacillin (52.2%), streptomycin (51%), erythromycin (32.6%), lincomycin (15.3%), and rifampicin (13.4%). For the eight taxa investigated, the multiple antibiotic resistance (MAR) index ranged from 0.50 to 0.88, with all values greater than 0.2. E. Coli and Proteus spp. had the highest MAR index values (0.88 each), followed by Bacillus, Aeromonas, and Staphylococcus (0.75 each), and Listeria, Edwardsiella, and Shigella (0.63 each). The isolated bacteria were multidrug-resistant, with varying resistance levels to lead and silver nitrate, with silver nitrate resistance rates ranging from 23.1–88.5% and lead resistance rates ranging from 30.8–69.2%. The multidrug resistance (MDR) pathogenic bacteria are found in fish from contaminated Lake Chivero, posing a health risk to humans. As a result, adequate waste disposal is required, as is multi-sectoral monitoring of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) and public education about the health risks associated with fish and fish-derived products.