Recycling carbon-fiber-reinforced plastics (CFRPs) is crucial for sustainable material utilization, particularly in aerospace applications, where large quantities of prepreg waste are generated. This study investigated the mechanical properties of highly oriented recycled CFRP (rCFRP) molded using vacuum-assisted resin transfer molding (VaRTM), wet-layup, and traditional RTM methods. Recycled carbon fibers (rCFs) obtained via solvolysis and pyrolysis were processed into nonwoven preforms to ensure fiber alignment through carding. The influence of molding methods, fiber recycling techniques, and fiber orientation on mechanical performance was examined through tensile tests, fiber volume fraction (Vf) analysis, and scanning electron microscopy observations. The results indicated that the solvolysis-recycled rCF exhibited superior interfacial adhesion with the resin, leading to a higher tensile strength and stiffness, particularly in the RTM process, where a high Vf was achieved. Wet-layup molding effectively reduced the void content owing to autoclave curing, maintaining stable properties even with pyrolyzed rCF. VaRTM, while enabling vacuum-assisted resin infusion, exhibited a higher void content, limiting improvements in mechanical performance. This study highlights that tailoring the molding method according to the desired performance, such as increasing stiffness potential by enhancing Vf in RTM or improving tensile strength by improving fiber–matrix adhesion in wet-layup molding, is critical for optimizing rCFRP properties, providing important insights into sustainable CFRP recycling and high-performance material design.