This study investigates formation homogeneous regions in regional flood frequency analysis (RFFA) and compares two RFFA methods, the quantile regression technique (QRT) and the index flood method (IFM). A total of 201 gauged stations from southeast Australia were adopted in this study. Multivariate statistical techniques were applied to form candidate regions. Also, regions are formed in the L-moments space (such as the L coefficient of variation (LCV) and L coefficient of skewness (LCS) of annual maximum flood data). Hosking and Wallis test statistics were used to find discordant sites and for testing the homogeneity of the assumed regions. No homogeneous regions were found in southeast Australia based on catchment characteristics data; however, homogeneous regions can be formed in the space of L-moments. It was found that regions formed in the L-moments space have little link with the catchment characteristics data space. The QRT provides more accurate flood quantile estimates than the IFM.
This study aimed to compare linear and non-linear regional flood frequency analysis (RFFA) models where streamflow data of 88 catchments of New South Wales (NSW), Australia, were utilized. The Quantile Regression Technique (QRT) was selected as the linear model and an Artificial Neural Network (ANN) as the non-linear model. Six different flood quantiles were considered, which are annual exceedance probabilities of 1 in 2 (Q2), 1 in 5 (Q5), 1 in 10 (Q10), 1 in 20 (Q20), 1 in 50 (Q50), and 1 in 100 (Q100). The selected two RFFA models were compared using a split-sample validation technique (70% data for training and 30% data for testing) and several statistical indices like relative error (RE), absolute median relative error (REr), bias, the median ratio of the predicted and observed flood quantiles (Qr), and the root mean square error (RMSE). The ANN model exhibited smaller bias values for Q2, Q5, Q20, and Q50 and smaller Qr values for Q10, Q20, and Q50. The REr values for the ANN model were found to be lower for smaller return periods (Q2, Q5, and Q10). The overall REr value considering all six AEPs for the ANN model is 35%, which is 37% for the QRT model. The results of this study could assist to select a suitable RFFA technique for design application in the study area.
In regional flood frequency analysis (RFFA), the formation of homogeneous regions is commonly regarded as a necessary condition for reliable regional flood estimation. However, achieving true homogeneity is often challenging in practice. This study investigates the formation of homogeneous regions by applying two region delineation approaches—fixed regions and the region-of-influence (ROI) method—accompanied by the widely used heterogeneity measure (H1) proposed by Hosking and Wallis. The analysis utilizes data from 201 stream gauging stations across southeast Australia, evaluating a total of 1211 candidate regions. The computed H1-statistics range from 13 to 30 for fixed regions and from 6 to 30 for ROI-based regions, indicating a consistently high level of heterogeneity across the study area. This suggests that the assumption of homogeneity may not be realistic for many parts of southeast Australia. Moreover, regression equations developed for regional flood estimation yield absolute median relative errors between 29% and 56%, with a median of 39% across return periods from 2 to 100 years. These findings underscore the limitations of relying solely on homogeneity in regional flood modelling and highlight the need for more flexible and robust approaches in RFFA. The outcomes of this research have significant implications for improving flood estimation practices and are expected to contribute to future enhancements of the Australian Rainfall and Runoff (ARR) national guidelines.