Speech that has been artificially accelerated through time compression produces a notable deficit in recall of the speech content. This is especially so for adults with cochlear implants (CI). At the perceptual level, this deficit may be due to the sharply degraded CI signal, combined with the reduced richness of compressed speech. At the cognitive level, the rapidity of time-compressed speech can deprive the listener of the ordinarily available processing time present when speech is delivered at a normal speech rate. Two experiments are reported. Experiment 1 was conducted with 27 normal-hearing young adults as a proof-of-concept demonstration that restoring lost processing time by inserting silent pauses at linguistically salient points within a time-compressed narrative (“time-restoration”) returns recall accuracy to a level approximating that for a normal speech rate. Noise vocoder conditions with 10 and 6 channels reduced the effectiveness of time-restoration. Pupil dilation indicated that additional effort was expended by participants while attempting to process the time-compressed narratives, with the effortful demand on resources reduced with time restoration. In Experiment 2, 15 adult CI users tested with the same (unvocoded) materials showed a similar pattern of behavioral and pupillary responses, but with the notable exception that meaningful recovery of recall accuracy with time-restoration was limited to a subgroup of CI users identified by better working memory spans, and better word and sentence recognition scores. Results are discussed in terms of sensory-cognitive interactions in data-limited and resource-limited processes among adult users of cochlear implants.
Background/Objectives: We investigated: (1) differences in CI-aided thresholds and speech perception scores among cochlear implant manufacturers and (2) the relationship between CI-aided thresholds and speech perception. Methods: We analyzed exploratory data from NYU and a confirmatory data set of 120 CI-aided audiograms from the ASAN clinic. CI-aided soundfield evaluations were compared between manufacturers (Cochlear, Advanced Bionics, MED-EL) using 5- and 6-pure-tone average thresholds; percentage of patients with average thresholds above 35 dB HL; speech perception scores; and correlations between thresholds and speech perception. Results: Compared to Cochlear users, MED-EL and Advanced Bionics users had significantly higher (poorer) pure-tone averages (26.7 dB HL for Cochlear vs. 30.0 dB HL for AB and 34.6 dB HL for MED-EL at NYU; 29.0 dB HL for Cochlear vs. 36.5 dB HL for MED-EL at ASAN), and higher incidence of 5- or 6-PTAs above 35 dB HL (1.6% vs. 23.4%/47.1% at NYU; 11.2% vs. 60.0% at ASAN). Word and sentence scores were significantly higher for the Cochlear group when compared to the MED-EL group. Speech scores were higher for manufacturers that recommend the use of behaviorally-measured T-levels (Cochlear) rather than estimated T-levels (AB and MED-EL). Significant negative correlations existed between CI-aided thresholds and speech scores. Conclusions: Significant differences in CI-aided thresholds and speech perception were observed between manufacturers, potentially related to brand-specific T-level programming approaches.
12 December 2024 in Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology
Although cochlear implants (CI) successfully replace the sense of hearing, they do not restore natural hearing. Still, CI users adapt to this novel signal, reaching meaningful levels of speech recognition in clinical tests that focus on repetition of words and short sentences. However, many patients who score above average in clinical speech perception tests complain that everyday speech interactions are both difficult and cognitively draining. In part, this difficulty may be due to the naturally rapid pace of everyday discourse. We report a study in which 12 CI users aged 23 to 77, recalled multi-sentence discourse presented without interruption, or in the condition of interest, when passages were paused at major linguistic boundaries, with participants given control of when to initiate the next segment. Comprehension of the discourse structure was based on a formalised representational system that organises discourse elements hierarchically to index the relative importance of different elements to the overall understanding of the discourse. Results showed (a) better recall when CI users were allowed to control the discourse pace; (b) an overall effect of aging, with older CI users recalling discourse less accurately; (c) better recall for passages with higher average inter-word predictability; (d) a “semantic hierarchy effect” reflected by better recall of main ideas versus minor details; (e) an attenuation of the semantic hierarchy effect for low predictability passages. Results underscore the benefits of extra processing time in addressing CI listening challenges and highlight the limited ecological validity of single-word or single-sentence speech recognition tests.
Objectives: This study aims to validate vocoders as acoustic models of cochlear implants by determining whether they capture both perceptual sound quality and speech performance. We hypothesize that valid acoustic models of cochlear implants require listener-specific amounts of frequency mismatch between input filters and output tones or noise bands. Design: Forty-four adult single-sided deaf cochlear implant users were tested 1 to 5 times for a total of 73 sessions at different time points after initial stimulation. Participants had a cochlear implant in one ear and normal or near-normal hearing in the contralateral ear, allowing within-subject comparisons. In Experiment 1, participants used a method-of-adjustment procedure to select acoustic models most similar to their cochlear implant by adjusting three parameters: low- and high-frequency cutoffs of the acoustic output, and channel interaction (overlap among output sound carriers). In Experiment 2, participants rated the perceptual similarity of five acoustic model types using questionnaires assessing overall similarity and four acoustic dimensions (intelligibility, pleasantness, harshness, and loudness). The five model types included the self-selected model, two all-channel frequency-matched vocoders (tone and noise), and two six-channel frequency-matched vocoders (tone and noise). Frequency-matched acoustic models had output noise bands or tones that were frequency-matched to the analysis filters. In Experiment 3, speech perception was evaluated under six conditions: with the cochlear implant alone and with each of the five acoustic model types presented to the normal hearing ear. Results: Nearly all participants (69 of 73 sessions) selected acoustic models with frequency ranges different from their clinical frequency allocation tables. The low-frequency edge of self-selected models was significantly higher than clinical allocations (456 Hz for Cochlear Ltd. and 266 Hz for MED-EL). Over 80% of selections used minimal channel interaction (tones, nonoverlapping noise bands, or adjacent noise bands). Self-selected models received significantly higher similarity ratings (mean of 6.11, where 6 means “somewhat similar” and 7 “very similar”) compared with all frequency-matched models, which were rated around 3 (“not very similar”). Self-selected models were rated most similar to the cochlear implant across multiple acoustic dimensions and were the only models not rated significantly different from the cochlear implant on any dimension. For speech perception, all-channel frequency-matched models significantly overestimated performance compared with the cochlear implant for both words and sentences. Self-selected models provided speech scores closest to cochlear implant performance. Joint analysis of similarity ratings and speech perception scores demonstrated that self-selected models were the only acoustic models achieving both perceptual similarity to the cochlear implant (rating of 6.11 with 7 being “very similar”) and comparable speech perception scores (within five percentage points). Conclusions: Frequency-matched acoustic models fail to replicate the sound of a cochlear implant and all-channel frequency-matched acoustic models also significantly overestimate speech perception. In contrast, self-selected acoustic models incorporating listener-specific perceptual frequency mismatch provide substantially better matches in both subjective sound quality and speech intelligibility. However, variability in similarity ratings across individuals may suggest that additional perceptual components remain unaccounted for in the current parameter set. These findings question the validity of frequency-matched acoustic models of cochlear implants in research applications.