The present study assesses the simulated precipitation and cloud properties using three microphysics schemes (Morrison, Thompson and MY) implemented in the Weather Research and Forecasting model. The precipitation, differential reflectivity (ZDR), specific differential phase (KDP) and mass-weighted mean diameter of raindrops (Dm) are compared with measurements from a heavy rainfall event that occurred on 27 June 2020 during the Integrative Monsoon Frontal Rainfall Experiment (IMFRE). The results indicate that all three microphysics schemes generally capture the characteristics of rainfall, ZDR, KDP and Dm, but tend to overestimate their intensity. To enhance the model performance, adjustments are made based on the MY scheme, which exhibited the best performance. Specifically, the overall coalescence and collision parameter (Ec) is reduced, which effectively decreases Dm and makes it more consistent with observations. Generally, reducing Ec leads to an increase in the simulated content (Qr) and number concentration (Nr) of raindrops across most time steps and altitudes. With a smaller Ec, the impact of microphysical processes on Nr and Qr varies with time and altitude. Generally, the autoconversion of droplets to raindrops primarily contributes to Nr, while the accretion of cloud droplets by raindrops plays a more significant role in increasing Qr. In this study, it is emphasized that even if the precipitation characteristics could be adequately reproduced, accurately simulating microphysical characteristics remains challenging and it still needs adjustments in the most physically based parameterizations to achieve more accurate simulation.
This study analyzes the different impacts of autoconversion of cloud droplets to raindrops (ACR) in a Meiyu front rainfall event by comparing two simulations using different parameterizations (KK00 and LD04) in the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model. The Meiyu frontal clouds are further classified into stratiform and deep-convective cloud categories, and the precipitation and microphysical characteristics of the two simulations are compared with a budget analysis of raindrops. The simulated precipitation, radar composite reflectivity distribution, and rain rate evolution are overall consistent with observations while precipitation is overestimated, especially in the rainfall centers. The intensity and vertical structure of the ACR process between the two simulations are significantly different. The ACR rate in LD04 is larger than that in KK00 and there are two peak heights in LD04 but only one in KK00. Accretion of droplets by raindrops (CLcr), melting of ice-phase particles (ML), evaporation of raindrops (VDrv), and accretion of raindrops by ice-phase particles (CLri) are the dominant pathways to raindrop production. Limited distributional differences can be found in both the deep-convective and stratiform clouds between the two simulations during the growth stage of the Meiyu event. Stronger ACR in LD04 results in less cloud droplet content (Lc), more raindrop content (Lr), and larger raindrop number concentration (Nr) and the effect of ACR on Nr is greater than that on Lr. The ACR process also impacts other microphysical processes indirectly, and the influences vary in the two cloud categories. Less CLcr (especially), ML, and VDrv content, caused by stronger ACR, lead to less raindrop production in the LD04 deep-convective clouds, which is different from stratiform clouds, and finally correct the overestimated rainfall center to better match the observations.
This study examines a Mei-Yu rainfall event using rain gauges (RG) and OTT Parsivel disdrometers to observe precipitation characteristics and raindrop size distributions (RSD), with comparisons made against Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model simulations. Results show that Parsivel-derived rain rates (RR) are slightly underestimated relative to RG measurements. Both observations and simulations identify 1–3 mm raindrops as the dominant precipitation contributors, though the model overestimates small and large drop contributions. At low RR, decreased small-drop and increased large-drop concentrations cause corresponding leftward and rightward RSD shifts with decreasing altitude—a pattern well captured by simulations. However, at elevated rainfall rates, the simulated concentration of large raindrops shows no significant increase, resulting in negligible rightward shifting of RSD in the model outputs. Autoconversion from cloud droplets to raindrops (ATcr), collision and breakup between raindrops (AGrr), ice melting (MLir), and evaporation of raindrops (VDrv) contribute more to the number density of raindrops. At 0.1 < RR < 1 mm·h−1, ATcr dominates, while VDrv peaks in this intensity range before decreasing. At higher intensities (RR > 20 mm·h−1), AGrr contributes most, followed by MLir. When the RR is high enough, the breakup of raindrops plays a more important role than collision, leading to a decrease in the number density of raindrops. The overestimation of raindrop breakup from the numerical parameterization may be one of the reasons why the RSD does not shift significantly to the right toward the surface under the heavy RR grade. The RSD near the surface varies with the RR and characterizes surface precipitation well. Toward the surface, ATcr and VDrv, but not AGrr, become similar when precipitation approaches.
Heavy precipitation in Northeast China is frequently modulated by the Northeast China Cold Vortex (NCCV), although the microphysical processes within squall lines under such conditions remain insufficiently understood. This study presents a comprehensive analysis of an NCCV-influenced squall line in Liaoning Province, utilizing coordinated S-band polarimetric radar and surface disdrometer observations. The raindrop size distribution (DSD) characteristics and three-dimensional microphysical structure are systematically examined for both convective and stratiform regimes. A comparative analysis of DSD and warm-rain microphysical mechanisms is also conducted with a Mei-yu event. Results show that convective rain in the NCCV squall line exhibits a continental-type DSD, characterized by fewer but larger raindrops compared to other heavy rainfalls in China. In contrast, the Mei-yu frontal convection under NCCV influence exhibits a transitional DSD pattern between the maritime and continental types, with raindrops smaller and denser than those in the NCCV squall line. Vertical structure of the mature squall line shows prominent differential reflectivity (ZDR) and specific differential phase (KDP) columns above the melting level within the convective region, indicating vigorous riming growth of graupel and hail driven by strong updrafts. Meanwhile, the stratiform region is characterized by ice crystals and aggregates, formed primarily through deposition and aggregation processes. The subsequent melting of ice-phase particles followed by collision–coalescence and evaporation-driven size sorting shapes the large but sparse raindrops in the NCCV squall line. Comparison with Mei-yu convection demonstrates that surface DSD is shaped by environmental conditions and vertical microphysics. The drier, more unstable environment in the NCCV squall line favors deep convection with active ice-phase processes, while the relatively moist and stable environment of the Mei-yu convection supports shallower convection dominated by warm-rain processes. Future multi-case studies with integrated observations are needed to quantify how environmental and aerosol conditions modulate these heavy precipitation processes.