Lindsey Roche

Ms. Lindsey Roche

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

4Years (2023-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
11 November 2024 in The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LRLindsey Roche
Lindsey Roche
ALAndreas Link
Andreas Link
SMSylvia Marinova
Sylvia Marinova
VCVlad Coroama
Vlad Coroama
MFMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner
Purpose: Lithium is critical to the clean energy transition, specifically for lithium-ion batteries in electric vehicles and grid-level energy storage. Chile is a major source of lithium hydroxide and lithium carbonate from brine. The main production facilities are in the Salar de Atacama (SdA), a hyper-arid region home to indigenous communities. A social life cycle assessment (S-LCA) was conducted to better understand the potential impacts of lithium mining on these communities, particularly in relation to water consumption as this is a concern within the region. Methods: A cradle-to-gate S-LCA on lithium was performed from brine extraction to the gate of the chemical plant. A hotspot analysis using the Social Hotspots Database (SHDB), in combination with literature and local discussions, was used to prioritize stakeholder groups and subcategories for data collection. Local community, Worker, and Society were selected as stakeholder groups. Subcategories for the Local community included Access to material resources (with a focus on freshwater), Cultural heritage, Respect of indigenous rights, Community engagement, and Local employment. Data sources included primary data from a mining company and interviews with the local community during a site visit. The reference scale approach was applied using Chilean laws and international best practices. Results and discussion: Two scoring approaches yielded different scores on the reference scale. With an average scoring approach, all subcategories were at compliance level or above for all stakeholders. The mining company has many projects and initiatives ongoing to improve the wellbeing of the local community. Policies and projects lead to higher scores when applying the average scoring approach. However, with a precautionary approach, where the worst performing indicator determines the score, four subcategories were identified as potential issues for the Local community: Access to material resources — freshwater, Access to material resources — agriculture, Delocalization and migration, and Respect of indigenous rights. For Access to material resources — freshwater, local community members had varying perspectives on freshwater scarcity, but some connected it to lithium mining and also described the cultural importance of water. Conclusions: The results of this S-LCA can be used to better understand the potential social impacts from lithium production and how they can be improved. Recommendations are provided to address the potential social impacts of lithium mining in the SdA, including continuing increased communication and projects with the communities, fostering initiatives to improve the understanding of the lithium production process, and considering that community members have equal access to benefit from projects.

30 January 2024 in The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LOLuisa Luna Ostos
Luisa Luna Ostos
LRLindsey Roche
Lindsey Roche
VCVlad Coroama
Vlad Coroama
MFMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner
Purpose: Chocolate is a widely consumed product and consumers are increasingly interested in its sustainability. However, the lack of scientific studies covering the social dimension hinders a holistic assessment of the sustainability. A social life cycle assessment (S-LCA) was conducted in cooperation with a Colombian chocolate manufacturer following the Guidelines for S-LCA of Products and Organizations 2020. This study represents the first application of S-LCA in the chocolate sector covering both cocoa cultivation and chocolate manufacturing. Methods: The study aimed to identify the main social hotspots within the value chain of a dark chocolate product, as well as to identify the potential and actual social performance of this product. The stakeholders assessed in the study were workers (in the cocoa plantation and manufacturing plant), society, and the local community. Primary inventory data was collected through on-site semi-structured interviews as well as through the review of company reports. Secondary data used to build the reference scales for impact assessment were taken from national regulations and best practice standards. In total, 16 subcategories were assessed. Results and discussion: The overall results showed an outcome of at least a compliance level (0), and a performance beyond compliance (+ 1 or + 2) for the local community and society. The latter was attributable to the role of the company as an agent of change in a region heavily impacted by violence and poverty. Furthermore, numerous interviewees stressed the importance of companies in the Colombian post-conflict context to re-integrate former conflict actors back into the labor market. For workers, the results also indicated a performance on the compliance level or above, with child labor and health and safety scoring as + 2 and social benefits/social security scoring as + 1. Areas of improvement were identified in subcategories where the score was on the compliance level (0) such as working hours, fair salary, equal opportunities, and employment relationships. Conclusions: A main challenge encountered was the definition of reference scales for subcategories with no recognized standards applicable to the socio-political context. This suggested a necessity for further S-LCA applications in regions with armed conflicts. The study provided insight into the social sustainability of the chocolate industry across the life cycle, covering the cocoa plantation and the manufacturing plant. At the same time, it provided the company with a tool to measure the positive and negative social impacts of their actions on stakeholders and redirect efforts towards the areas most in need.

15 February 2025 in Journal of Cleaner Production
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
LRLindsey Roche
Lindsey Roche
PHPeter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
Peter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
MFMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner

2 February 2023 in The Extractive Industries and Society
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
LRLindsey Roche
Lindsey Roche
RARosalie Arendt
Rosalie Arendt
VBVanessa Bach
Vanessa Bach
MFMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner

11 July 2023 in The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LRLindsey Roche
Lindsey Roche
MMMarco Muhl
Marco Muhl
MFMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner
Purpose: Iodine and its compounds have several industrial uses, primarily in nutrition and healthcare. So far, no specific LCA data for industrial iodine production are available. The purpose of this study is to provide the first LCA using primary industry data for iodine production from caliche ore in Chile. Methods: The study is a process-based, attributional LCA and follows the relevant ISO standards 14040/44. Primary data were collected from the world’s main producer representing their production for the years 2019 and 2020. Economic allocation was applied to deal with the by-product sodium nitrate. The impact assessment was performed with a set of CML 2001 indicators. Results and discussion: Cradle-to-gate total LCIA results per 1000 kg of iodine prill product include a GWP 100 of 1.48E+04 kg CO 2 eq., an AP of 2.53E+02 kg SO 2 eq., a POCP of 1.20E+01 kg C 2 H 4 eq., an EP of 9.60E+00 kg PO 4 3− eq., and an ADP fossil of 2.44E+05 MJ. The main contributor across process steps and for most impact categories is electricity consumption. Other hotspots include diesel combustion, hydrogen peroxide, sulfur, sulfuric acid, kerosene, and sodium hydroxide. A scenario analysis with renewable electricity revealed a reduction potential for all impact categories. As an example, the GWP could be reduced by 33–38%. Conclusions: This study is the first LCA for iodine production from caliche ore based on primary industry data. The switch to renewable sources was identified as the main improvement potential for the hotspot electricity consumption, with a potential reduction of at least 25% for all impact categories except ODP.

31 May 2025 in Water
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
ALAndreas Link
Andreas Link
SMSylvia Marinova
Sylvia Marinova
LRLindsey Roche
Lindsey Roche
VCVlad Coroama
Vlad Coroama
LHLily Hinkers
Lily Hinkers
Matthias FinkbeinerMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner
As lithium demand increases, lithium brine from hyper-arid salt flats is becoming increasingly important, although there are concerns about its extraction’s impact on the local water balance. Water footprinting could address these impacts, yet studies lack consensus on whether to classify brine as water or a mineral. This study aims to review perspectives on lithium brine accounting within and beyond the water footprint context, focused on the Salar de Atacama, Chile, and to establish accounting principles for water footprinting, following the relevant ISO standard. Outside water footprinting, four perspectives on brine classification are identified: hydro-social/perceptual, molecular–thermodynamic, precautionary, and legal. Adopting some of these perspectives, e.g., the rationale of brine’s molecular–thermodynamic similarity to freshwater, some water footprint studies argue for accounting brine as equivalent to freshwater. However, they are a minority. According to ISO, brine should not be classified as freshwater, and the type of water and its functionality should be distinguished. We suggest some saline waters below a specific salinity threshold may function as freshwater and could be included in freshwater accounting. Additionally, lithium brine extraction can induce effects on surrounding water compartments. Since conventional water footprints overlook such local effects, we propose testing a set of site-specific accounting principles through case studies.