Peter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel

Mr. Peter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel

Technical University of Berlin, Berlin, Germany
orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

6Years (2021-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
25 April 2023 in The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
PHPeter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
Peter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
VBVanessa Bach
Vanessa Bach
MFMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner
Purpose: In grid electricity consumption models, the location-based method uses regional average emission factors to account for environmental impacts. The market-based method is based on contractual agreements, verifying the exclusive claim on electricity from specific energy sources. An inconsistent application of these methods in life cycle assessment (LCA) and GHG accounting can lead to double counting. Especially, double counting electricity associated with rather low environmental impacts, such as renewable energy, might lead to impact underestimations. The aim of this paper is to identify, describe and propose solutions to double counting challenges. Methods: A four-step procedure is carried out. First, the specifications on grid electricity mix selection in frequently applied standards for LCA and GHG accounting are analysed. Besides the ISO norms for LCA (14040/44) and carbon footprinting (14064/67), the GHG Protocol and the Product and Organizational Environmental Footprint (PEF/OEF) are considered. Based on this analysis, challenges of double counting electricity from specific sources are identified. In the third step, potential solutions for avoiding double counting are proposed. The last research step consists of an illustrative case study to demonstrate the calculation of market-based electricity mixes and identify potential adjustments necessities for LCA application. Results and discussion: A parallel application of the location-based and the market-based method poses the main double-counting challenge. Thus, avoiding double counting demands consistent method application throughout the whole life cycle. Whereas this is relatively straightforward for the location-based method, consistent market-based method application is more challenging. LCAs rely on average life cycle inventory processes, which mostly include location-based electricity mixes. However, for consistent market-based method application throughout the life cycle, electricity-related environmental impacts in the inventory system also need to be market-based. This would demand a partial recalculation of LCI datasets using market-based residual electricity mixes. Besides illustrating the calculation of market-based electricity mixes, the case study is used to identify and propose solutions for two main challenges for residual mix application in LCA: countries without residual mix and electricity under a double marketing ban. Conclusion: Double counting of electricity from specific energy sources is a challenge, since it can lead to under- or overestimations of environmental impacts. Both the location-based and market-based method can avoid double counting. However, parallel or inconsistent applications of both methods lead to double counting. In order to avoid double counting, there is a need to enable and use consistent electricity accounting rules in LCA and GHG accounting.

8 March 2022 in Sustainability
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Elena HuberElena Huber
Elena Huber
Vanessa BachVanessa Bach
Vanessa Bach
PHPeter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
Peter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
Daria BlizniukovaDaria Blizniukova
Daria Blizniukova
Matthias FinkbeinerMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner
Chemicals impact the environment. However, life cycle assessments (LCA) of products containing chemicals are often not possible due to a lack of available datasets. Existing methodologies to address this problem have several shortcomings. Therefore, a new approach to model chemicals is introduced to fill dataset gaps in inventory databases. Further data for 60 chemicals are provided. The approach consists of four steps: (i) general research on the chemical and the synthesis processes, (ii) setting up the reaction equations, (iii) researching the required thermal energy, and (iv) modeling of the dataset (RREM). Depending on the obtained data, calculations are carried out or assumptions are applied. The environmental impact of the chemicals is modeled in the LCA software linking to existing datasets. A case study of the chemical octocrylene illustrates the application of RREM. An overview is given of the environmental profile of 60 chemicals modeled based on RREM. The validity of the assumptions and their influences on the results are examined by a sensitivity analysis. By modeling chemicals with the RREM approach, previously unknown environmental impacts of chemicals and products containing them can be determined.

1 May 2024 in The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
PHPeter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
Peter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
JBJonas Bunsen
Jonas Bunsen
ISIvo Schmidt-Sierra
Ivo Schmidt-Sierra
VBVanessa Bach
Vanessa Bach
MFMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner
Purpose: Most life cycle inventory (LCI) datasets include location-based electricity mixes. Using these LCI datasets in combination with market-based electricity accounting in life cycle assessments (LCAs) leads to double counting of electricity from specific sources, such as renewable energy. The goal of this paper is to analyze market-based accounting by replacing location-based electricity consumption with market-based residual mixes in all processes of the ecoinvent database. The python script for this replacement procedure is openly available. Materials and methods: We use the Brightway 2 software package to replace European location-based electricity consumption in all 21,238 processes of the ecoinvent database with residual electricity mixes on the corresponding voltage level. The ecoinvent database provides residual electricity mixes for all countries involved in European trade with market-based energy attribute certificates—Guarantees of Origin. We analyze the induced changes to the database both on an individual process level and on a database-wide level. The analysis focusses on the impact category climate change but is further extended to the impact categories terrestrial acidification, freshwater eutrophication, marine eutrophication, ozone depletion, and particulate matter formation. Results and discussion: For European processes, the implementation of the residual electricity mixes leads to average changes in the life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) results for climate change of 1%, 10%, 20%, and 50% for 2958, 733, 387, and 107 processes, respectively. Changes are especially pronounced for Norwegian and Icelandic processes due to the large differences among their location-based and residual electricity mixes. For the other analyzed impact categories, the changes in LCIA results are particularly high for freshwater eutrophication. With the push towards more primary data in LCA and GHG accounting, the impacts of using residual electricity mixes instead of location-based electricity mixes need further research on basis of quantified figures, which we present in this paper. Conclusion: This paper presents an approach towards enabling more consistent market-based accounting throughout LCAs and thereby contributes to the avoidance of double counting. Since only European residual mixes are considered, the database of this paper leads to distortion of LCA results. Further, research is needed to address double counting beyond the European electricity sector. This includes an expansion of this research to a global level and other industrial sectors. Furthermore, research is needed regarding industry-specific electricity sources in LCI datasets, which may also lead to double counting.

25 August 2024 in Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PHPeter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
Peter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
JBJános Bánk
János Bánk
VBVanessa Bach
Vanessa Bach
MFMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner

8 April 2025 in The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
PHPeter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
Peter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
DBDaria Blizniukova
Daria Blizniukova
VBVanessa Bach
Vanessa Bach
MFMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner
Purpose: Carbon footprinting and life cycle assessment (LCA) are moving from average secondary data towards supply chain specific primary data, which can be modelled via different chain of custody (CoC) models. Contrary to common LCA practice, there is a push towards CoC models that enable a separation of physical and accounted products: the mass balance–credit method and the book and claim model. This article deepens the understanding of CoC modelling options in LCA and identifies corresponding challenges. Methods: A three-step research procedure is defined. First, the five different CoC models, as described in ISO 22095, are illustrated with the example of a hypothetical organization that uses both inputs with specified characteristics, such as biogenic materials, and conventional inputs, such as fossil materials. Second, the fundamental LCA standards—ISO 14040/44—are analyzed for specifications that are relevant for CoC modelling. The five CoC models are then analyzed for their conformity with these specifications. Furthermore, standards, such as ISO 14067 and the GHG Protocol, as well as the carbon footprint guidelines from Catena-X, Pathfinder, and Together for Sustainability (TfS), are analyzed for relevant specifications. Finally, challenges and potential requirements for the use of CoC models in LCA are identified and elaborated. Results and discussion: The mass balance–credit method and the book and claim model can be interpreted as not adhering to the LCA approach of describing physical systems, as specified in ISO 14040. Further, the mass balance–credit method leads to co-products, while not applying the allocation hierarchy of ISO 14044. However, the market-based method for electricity accounting, which resembles the book and claim model, is allowed and even required by some standards, such as the GHG Protocol and the ISO 14067. This may set a precedent for a more general separation of physical and accounted products. Main challenges for CoC modelling in LCA are the avoidance of double counting, the definition of consistent allocation rules, and the definition and enforcement of adequate requirements. The decision on which CoC models are to be allowed in LCA and the corresponding requirements depend on value choices. Thus, stakeholder processes are required for consensus finding. Conclusion: While CoC modelling may gain relevance in LCA, it is important for the LCA community to be aware of potential challenges and work towards adequate solutions and requirements. Further research and specification are necessary to harmonize the standards for CoC modelling and LCA.

15 February 2025 in Journal of Cleaner Production
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
LRLindsey Roche
Lindsey Roche
PHPeter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
Peter Karl Rüdiger Holzapfel
MFMatthias Finkbeiner
Matthias Finkbeiner