The basaltic succession of the Paraná–Etendeka Magmatic Province provides a clear example of how lava emplacement style and post-emplacement processes control volcanic reservoir properties in large igneous provinces. This study integrates petrographic, geochemical, and petrophysical data to evaluate the two lower formations of the Serra Geral Group (SGG) in southern Brazil, focusing on their role as magmatic reservoirs. The Torres Formation (TF), representing the basal unit of the SGG, consists of compound pāhoehoe lava fields composed of small lobes that preserve primary porosity inherited from magmatic vesiculation. These lavas display low permeability, nearly closed-system behavior, limited fluid circulation, and restricted mineral alteration. Accordingly, the Chemical Index of Alteration (CIA; 38–51) and Mafic Index of Alteration (MIA(O); 34–57) values are low, while petrophysical properties indicate porosity around 1.5%, near-zero permeability, and P-wave velocities reaching 5.9 km/s. Alteration in the TF is mainly restricted to vesicle margins and fractures, where secondary minerals have only a minor impact on reservoir quality. In contrast, the Vale do Sol Formation (VSF) is composed of thick rubbly pāhoehoe lava flows characterized by glass-rich, autobrecciated upper crusts and massive lava cores, promoting open-system behavior. Porosity is significantly higher (2.0–21.6%, locally up to ~28%), bulk density is lower (2.08–2.50 g/cm3), and acoustic velocities are more variable (Vp = 2.96–5.37 km/s). Elevated CIA and MIA(O) values indicate more pervasive alteration, reflected by the precipitation of smectite, celadonite, and zeolites within vesicles and interclastic pores. Across both formations, porosity shows an inverse correlation with Vp, demonstrating that elastic properties are controlled by primary emplacement textures and secondary mineralization. These results highlight that contrasting volcanic architectures strongly influence reservoir quality and that rubbly pāhoehoe flows represent the most favorable horizons for subsurface fluid storage within magmatic reservoir systems.