This paper aims to provide a comprehensive review into academic and industrial research concerning the use of particles as a means of recovering adhesion when low adhesion conditions exist within the wheel/rail contact. The most common particle used is sand, generally possessing a high silica content, usually between 0.85 and 1.4 mm in size. Sand is currently being applied in low adhesion conditions in two ways: firing the sand into the wheel/rail contact by means of a train-borne sanding system, or by suspending it in a gel and applying it to the rail head with either a train-borne system or using a wayside applicator. Sanding has been used for a long time, but little research has been conducted on the sanding system, with research shortfalls surrounding particle properties and models of the mechanical behaviour of the particles’ effect in the wheel/rail contact. This paper includes a gap analysis method whereby previous research has been categorised based on seven criteria, designed to help assess the papers. The research was then graded as either ‘A’, ‘B’ or ‘C’ with ‘A’ grade research representing peer-reviewed work conducted across a range of scales or with an aspect of modelling. Most academic research was of ‘B’ grade due to the lack of multiple scales or modelling, which was also lacking in industrial research, but due to the lack of peer review most industrial research received a ‘C’ grade. The review also found there was evidence to suggest a lack of linkage between academia and industry with regards to taking sanding research findings forward. Additionally, this review helps clarify what future work is needed to optimise the sanding system to best recover adhesion and remove lubricating layers in the wheel/rail contact.
Particle shape analysis is conducted, to compare two types of railway ballast: Calcite and Kieselkalk. Focus lies on the characterisation of particle angularity using 3D scanner data. In the literature, angularity is often characterised using 2D data, as these types of data are easier to collect. 3D scanner data contain a vast amount of information (e.g. curvatures) which can be used for shape analysis and angularity characterisation. Literature approaches that use 3D data are often not thoroughly tested, due to a lack of test cases. In this work, two new curvature-based angularity indices are introduced and compared to one from the literature. Analytical test bodies with shapes ranging from spherical towards cubic are used for a first plausibility test. Then, 3D scans of ballast stones are compared to artificially rounded meshes. Only one out of three evaluated angularity indices seem to be suited to characterise angularity correctly in all of the above tests: the newly introduced scaled Willmore energy. A complete shape analysis of the scanned ballast stones is conducted and no difference between the two types of ballast can be seen regarding form, angularity, roughness, sphericity or convexity index. These findings of shape analysis are set in the context of previous works, where experimental results and DEM simulations of uniaxial compression tests and direct shear tests were presented for the same ballast types.
In railway operation, the sanding process is used to overcome low adhesion conditions in the wheel–rail contact. In the literature, previously conducted research has been experimental, e.g., measuring adhesion coefficients (ACs) under different contact conditions (dry, wet, …) or applying different sands. Under dry conditions, sanding can reduce measured ACs, while under wet conditions different types of rail sand can leave ACs unchanged or increase adhesion. Despite active research, the physical mechanisms causing the change in ACs under sanded conditions are still poorly understood. A possible remedy is the development of advanced models of sanding including local effects. As a basis for such a model, this study presents experimental results concerning single grain crushing behaviour of two types of rail sand under dry and wet contact conditions. Firstly, initial breakage behaviour is investigated with focus on the particle fragments’ size and spread as only fragments within the running band are available to influence the AC during roll-over. Secondly, single grain crushing tests are conducted under realistic wheel–rail load showing the formation of solidified clusters of sand fragments, as well as their size and thickness. This information is important for understanding mechanisms and for future physics-based modelling of the sanding process in wheel–rail contacts.