This study investigates the value and impacts of utilising cereal residual biomass according to bioeconomy principles within the Italian context. Cereals are relevant in Italy, accounting for over 60 % of total crop residue production. These residues exhibit uniform energy content, enabling different applications. This study uniquely compares three scenarios for converting straw residues into bioenergy via combustion, slow pyrolysis, and anaerobic digestion, considering residues availability and environmental impacts assessed through attributional Life Cycle Assessment (ISO 14040-44) using 1 GJ of energy obtained as a functional unit. Each investigated scenario is based exclusively on using cereal residual biomasses without adding other residual biomasses and includes both the production of bioenergy and the contribution to carbon stocks, considering the residues left in the field and the potential return of biochar. Among the scenarios, slow pyrolysis emerged as the most promising, with biochar offering additional yet unquantified benefits for carbon-smart management, climate change mitigation, and economic sustainability. The potential benefits of pyrolysis and biochar underscore the positive outcomes of the study, which are instrumental in guiding the development of regulatory frameworks supporting policymakers in making sustainable decisions. By providing a detailed comparison of environmental impacts, this research integrates effective cereal residue management practices into policy and regulatory measures, highlighting promising solutions and directing further research toward maximising environmental and climate benefits through optimised and targeted approaches.
The pursuit of alternative ingredients with improved environmental sustainability, nutritive value, and cost efficiency is crucial for modern pork production systems. Replacing soybean meals has the potential to reduce environmental impacts. This study proposes a substitution framework in which alternative ingredients are introduced to replace a growing proportion of soybean meals based on net energy equivalence. Additionally, an optimisation framework has been proposed that simultaneously addresses multiple objectives, including cost, feed weight, environmental impacts, and essential nutritional requirements. Eighteen feed mixes were obtained by introducing alternative ingredients selected from an extensive, if not systematic, literature review. Therefore, black soldier fly meal (BSF), bakery by-product (BP), and pea (P) have been introduced in feed mixes, and feed mixes were evaluated across ten environmental impact categories via a life cycle assessment (LCA) approach (ISO 14040-44), with two different functional units: 1 kg of feed mix and 1 kg of pig meat at the slaughterhouse. To assess the robustness of the optimised feed mixes under uncertainty, a cost and climate change sensitivity analysis was conducted. The results demonstrated that the introduction of BSF increased costs and environmental impacts at the single-score level (by 280% and 118%, respectively), with differences at the single-impact category level. In contrast, BP and P emerged as the most effective solutions in the substitution and optimisation approaches, respectively. BP contributed to a reduction in environmental impacts of up to 9% in optimised diets, while P achieved economic cost savings of up to 28% compared to the original diet. These findings highlighted the need to strike a balance between environmental benefits and financial viability, underscoring the importance of policy support and market incentives to make sustainable practices more accessible.
Circular economy (CE) strategies in the agri-food sector hold strong potential for reducing waste, enhancing resource efficiency, and promoting sustainable value creation. However, early-stage assessment of innovative valorisation pathways remains challenging due to limited data availability and heterogeneous sustainability trade-offs. This study presents a multi-criteria evaluation tool designed to identify sustainability hotspots and support the preliminary screening of CE solutions based on easily obtainable information. The tool combines a structured literature review with expert-based scoring across environmental (ENV), economic (EC), and social (SOC) dimensions. Its applicability was demonstrated through the following three case studies: (i) reconstitution of cheese approaching expiration, (ii) extraction of polyphenols from grape-wine residues via subcritical water extraction, and (iii) biodegradable mulching film production from grape-wine pomace. Results show that the tool successfully differentiates sustainability performance across value chain areas Residue, Final Product, and Process (RES, FP, and PRO) and reveals critical gaps requiring further investigation. Scenario 3 achieved the higher overall score (69.7%) due to fewer regulatory constraints, whereas Scenarios 1 and 2 (61.2% and 54.5%, respectively) are penalised due to the more regulations for human consumption. The proposed tool offers a practical and efficient method to support researchers and industry stakeholders in identifying CE strategies with the highest potential for sustainable development.