We measured the spatial distribution and composition of ozone-forming hydrocarbons, alcohols, and carbonyls in Utah’s Uinta Basin during the winter months of 2019 and 2020. The Uinta Basin contains about 10,000 producing oil and gas wells. Snow cover and the region’s unique topography (i.e., a large basin entirely surrounded by mountains) promote strong, multi-day temperature inversion episodes that concentrate pollution and lead to wintertime ozone production. Indeed, organic compound concentrations were about eight times higher during inversion episodes than during snow-free springtime conditions. We examined spatial associations between wintertime concentrations of organics and oil and gas sources in the region, and we found that concentrations of highly reactive alkenes were higher in areas with dense oil production than in areas with dense gas production. Total alkene+acetylene concentrations were 267 (42, 1146; lower and upper 95% confidence limits) µg m−3 at locations with 340 or more producing oil wells within 10 km (i.e., 75th percentile) versus 12 (9, 23) µg m−3 at locations with 15 or fewer oil wells (i.e., 25th percentile). Twenty-eight percent of the potential for organic compounds to produce ozone was due to alkenes in areas with dense oil production. Spatial correlations and organic compound ratios indicated that the most likely source of excess alkenes in oil-producing areas was natural gas-fueled engines, especially lean-burning (i.e., high air:fuel ratio) artificial lift engines.
After heavy snowfall in the Uinta Basin, Utah, elevated surface ozone occurs if a cold-air pool persists and traps emissions from oil and gas industry operations. Sunlight and actinic flux from a high-albedo snowpack drive ozone buildup via photolysis. Snow coverage is paramount in initiating the cold pool and driving ozone generation. Its depth is critical for predicting ozone concentrations. The Basin’s location leeward of the Wasatch Mountains provides conditions for a precipitation shadow, where sinking air suppresses snowfall. We analyzed multiple years of ground-based snow depth measurements, surface ozone data, and meteorological observations; we found that ozone levels track with snow coverage, but diagnosing a shadow effect (and any impact on ozone levels) was difficult due to sparse, noisy data. The uncertainty in linking snowfall variation to ozone levels hinders forecast quality in, e.g., machine-learning training. We highlight the importance of a better understanding of regional variation when issuing outlooks to protect the local economy and health. A wider sampling of snow depth across the Basin would benefit operational forecasters and, likely, predictive skill.
7 March 2025 in Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association
We measured organic compound emissions from a produced-water, evaporative disposal facility's oil-water separation vault in May 2022 and March-May 2023. Produced water is water pulled from the subsurface of a well along with the oil and natural gas; some produced water is disposed of by allowing it to evaporate from surface impoundments. The vault measured in this study separated residual oil from produced water before evaporative disposal. Because the vault's surface contained many potential small emission sources, we used a large plastic chamber to cover the entire vault and simultaneously capture all emissions. We also measured organic compounds in ambient air upwind and downwind of the vault and estimated emissions via a backward Lagrangian stochastic model (Windtrax). The total non-methane organic compound (TNMOC) emission rate from the vault ranged from 0.27 to 3.05 kg/h, averaging 1.99 kg/h in 2022 and 0.49 kg/h in 2023. The average TNMOC emission rate determined by the bLS method was 48% higher than the emission rate determined by the chamber method in 2023 (average of 0.73 kg/h). Still, the range of the chamber results fell within the range of TNMOC emissions from the model. Methanol emissions were much higher than the bLS method, averaging 85.3 g/hr, but were highly variable. We surmise that the water condensation on the chamber retained methanol and biased the results low. The extrapolated annual average emissions of methane, TNMOC, and methanol from the vault were 0.1, 15.5, and 1.4 U.S. tons/yr, respectively, within the range of emissions from uncontrolled oil storage tanks. The extrapolation considers bias in the chamber method and differences across the two years of measurements.Implications Statement The findings from our study indicate that emissions of non-methane organic compounds (TNMOC) from the oil-water separation vault at the produced-water evaporative disposal facility exhibit significant variability between years, with a notable decline in average emissiosns from 2022 to 2023. The higher emission rates recorded using the backward Lagrangian stochastic (bLS) model compared to the chamber method suggest that further investigation into measurement techniques is warranted to ensure accurate assessments of emissions. Additionally, the substantial variability in methanol emissions highlights the need for more controlled conditions during sampling to avoid potential biases. Overall, these results imply that while emissions from the vault are within the range of those from uncontrolled oil storage tanks, there is an ongoing necessity for improved monitoring and regulatory practices to mitigate environmental impacts associated with produced water disposal.
After heavy snowfall in the rural Uinta Basin, Utah, elevated surface ozone can occur when a persistent, reinforcing pool of cold air traps emissions from local oil and gas industry operations. Insolation permits photolysis and unhealthy buildup of surface ozone. Wintertime ozone is rare in the U.S. Intermountain West—more so a summertime issue in urban areas—and historically predicted poorly in numerical models. It follows a better understanding of prevailing snow patterns is important for constructing predictive models of ozone concentration. The Basin’s location leeward of the Wasatch Mountains provides conditions for a precipitation shadow, where rain or snow accumulation is suppressed by sinking air close to the lee. Mechanically, in westerly flow during winter, descending air parcels may accelerate, warm, and dry, hence clearing clouds that limit snowfall. Complicating spatial variations, wind-driven forcing may erode snow depth through drifting, melting, sublimation, etc. Sparse in situ observations and poor coverage of low-elevation radar tilts blocked by surrounding terrain compound the difficulty of snow-depth prediction, and due to tight connection with ozone formation, complicating prediction of snow sufficient to initiate the cold pool reinforcing feedback loop. Expectedly, ozone concentration observations track with snow coverage; more challenging was diagnosing a shadow effect and impact on ozone due to data sparsity and noise. The uncertainty but importance in linking snowfall variation to serious impacts of ozone levels on economy and public health motivates efforts to improve the region’s snow-depth measurements for purposes of nowcasting and machine-learning training.