Car ownership is linked to higher car use, which leads to important environmental, social and health consequences. As car ownership keeps increasing in most countries, it remains relevant to examine what factors and policies can help contain this growth. This paper uses an advanced spatial econometric modeling framework to investigate spatial dependences in household car ownership rates measured at fine geographical scales using administrative data of registered vehicles and census data of household counts for the Island of Montreal, Canada. The use of a finer level of spatial resolution allows for the use of more explanatory variables than previous aggregate models of car ownership. Theoretical considerations and formal testing suggested the choice of the Spatial Durbin Error Model (SDEM) as an appropriate modeling option. The final model specification includes sociodemographic and built environment variables supported by theory and achieves a Nagelkerke pseudo-R2 of 0.93. Despite the inclusion of those variables the spatial linear models with and without lagged explanatory variables still exhibit residual spatial dependence. This indicates the presence of unobserved autocorrelated factors influencing car ownership rates. Model results indicate that sociodemographic variables explain much of the variance, but that built environment characteristics, including transit level of service and local commercial accessibility (e.g., to grocery stores) are strongly and negatively associated with neighborhood car ownership rates. Comparison of estimates between the SDEM and a non-spatial model indicates that failing to control for spatial dependence leads to an overestimation of the strength of the direct influence of built environment variables.
6 September 2024 in Case Studies on Transport Policy
The availability of carsharing in cities around the world has allowed more households to take advantage of the service as an alternative or a complement to private car ownership. While most research has looked at the effect of carsharing on car ownership decisions using carsharing users’ surveys, very few have modelled the choice of car ownership and carsharing jointly using independent surveys. This paper investigates the complex relationship between this joint decision, the built environment, and travel-related attitudes. Using data from two surveys in Montreal, latent-cluster analysis is used to identify a typology of residential neighbourhoods and a segmentation of attitude profiles. Cross-analyzing the two segmentations suggests that those with more positive attitudes towards the car are more likely to own cars and less likely to join carsharing across all neighbourhood types compared to less car-oriented profiles. However, people from all attitude profiles own fewer cars in more central neighbourhoods than in more suburban locations. Finally, a MNL model where sociodemographics and residential parking are controlled for confirms that both the built environment and attitudes independently influence the joint decision. Results also suggest that attitudes are associated with residential location choice, hinting at the presence of residential self-selection or environmental determinism. In summary, the analysis indicates that policy measures aimed at expanding carsharing vehicle availability for promoting carsharing as an alternative to car ownership may primarily impact individuals who are less drawn to the symbolic and emotional aspects of traditional cars.
One practical approach to reduce GHG emissions is to shift from driving to modes with lower emissions, such as cycling. One key component of supporting cycling is the quality and quantity of cycling infrastructure. This study analyzes the relationship between the quality (or comfort) and quantity of bicycle infrastructure, the likelihood of cycling, and the emissions. The first objective of this study is to analyze the influence of various variables on cycling choice using an interpretable ensemble learning approach. Second, a scenario-based analysis is applied to examine the influence of various policy scenarios (related to cycling infrastructure) on the transportation life cycle GHG emissions. Using origin–destination survey data from Montreal and Laval, Canada, policy modelling results suggest that without current cycling infrastructure, cycling mode share would be 5.3% less, driving mode share would be 4% higher, and GHG emissions would be 10.2% higher among all trips of a reasonable cycling distance starting from home. Then, policy scenarios modelling for this subset of trips suggests that improving the quality of bikeways, increasing their quantity, and reducing the trip distances by 25% can reduce the GHG emissions by 3.9%, 6.6%, and 29.3%, and increase the number of cycling trips by 8.1%, 14%, and 24.4%, respectively.
Le phénomène de « peak-car », la croissance de l’usage des modes actifs et collectifs et un regain d’intérêt pour des aménagements urbains plus denses, mixtes et à échelle humaine, soulèvent la question du déclin des mobilités automobiles. Un cadre d’analyse en trois perspectives est utilisé pour évaluer d’une part, si ce déclin est réel et d’autre part, si celui-ci s’accompagne d’un changement de paradigme dans la planification des transports et de l’aménagement urbain qui indiquerait la fin de l’ automobilité . La question est appliquée spécifiquement pour la province de Québec et ses deux régions métropolitaines, Montréal et Québec. Comme première perspective, l’analyse des indicateurs de motorisation et d’utilisation de l’automobile indique un accroissement soutenu des mobilités automobiles au cours des deux dernières décennies. Comme seconde perspective, l’analyse des documents officiels de planification et de politiques-cadres de la mobilité révèle des constats justes des enjeux de mobilité, mais une reconnaissance inégale de la dépendance à l’automobile. De plus, aucun des documents municipaux et métropolitains ne présente d’objectifs précis de réduction de l’usage de l’automobile et de la motorisation. Finalement, dans une troisième perspective, les projets d’infrastructures priorisés ne sont pas tous cohérents avec les objectifs et visions des documents de planification. En effet, les bénéfices attendus d’ambitieux projets de transport collectif sont compromis par des projets de développement autoroutiers autant à Montréal qu’à Québec. Les justifications de ces projets routiers sont issues d’un paradigme de planification classique largement démontré comme dépassé et inadéquat. La priorité qui leur est donnée semble relever d’une résistance politique au changement de paradigme. Prises ensemble, ces trois perspectives tendent à démontrer qu’en dépit de certains signes positifs, le déclin des mobilités automobiles qui s’appuie sur un changement réel de paradigme de mobilité ne semble pas être amorcé au Québec.
As cities are looking for ways to reduce car use and ownership, there is evidence that carsharing services can contribute to reach this goal by providing households with an alternative to ownership for access to a car. Because of obvious interdependence in the choice of how many cars to own and the decision to join a carsharing service, there is a need to model both decisions jointly. Previous research also suggests that important heterogeneity due to personal preferences might affect car ownership decisions and to a greater extent, carsharing membership decisions. This paper uses a survey of ~2000 respondents from Montreal, Canada to investigate how taste heterogeneity due to attitude towards the car and travel might influence the effect of built environment and household sociodemographic characteristics on the joint decision. This is done through a Latent-class Multinomial logistic model where attitudes are entered in the class-allocation model. Results indicate the presence of two psychological profiles (“car oriented” and “social-conscious”) in similar proportions (46% and 54%) that differ significantly in how they incorporate carsharing in their portfolio of car accessibility tools. “Car-oriented” households own systematically more cars and are less likely to subscribe to carsharing than “social-conscious” households while “social-conscious” are more sensitive to sociodemographic and built environment characteristics in their decision. For example, availability of carsharing vehicles within walking distance only affects this latter class in selecting carsharing over ownership. In terms of policy implications, this suggests that increasing access to carsharing services might not work for everyone and that other strategies are needed to encourage car-oriented households to reduce car ownership even in the most central neighbourhoods.