Betül Kara

Ms. Betül Kara


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

4Years (2023-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
11 February 2026 in Sustainable Cities and Society
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BŞBETÜL ŞAŞMAZTÜRK
BETÜL ŞAŞMAZTÜRK
BKBetül Kara
Betül Kara
EAErtugrul Ayyildiz
Ertugrul Ayyildiz
NANezir Aydin
Nezir Aydin

3 October 2025 in Applied Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
BKBetül Kara
Betül Kara
EAErtugrul Ayyildiz
Ertugrul Ayyildiz
BKBahar Yalcin Kavus
Bahar Yalcin Kavus
TKTolga Kudret Karaca
Tolga Kudret Karaca
Smart grid operators face escalating cyber threats and tight resource constraints, demanding the transparent, defensible prioritization of security controls. This paper asks how to select cybersecurity controls for smart grids while retaining picture fuzzy evidence throughout and supporting policy-sensitive “what-if” analyses. We propose a hybrid Picture Fuzzy Stepwise Weight Assessment Ratio Analysis (SWARA) and Combinative Distance-based Assessment (CODAS) framework that carries picture fuzzy evidence end-to-end over a domain-specific cost/benefit criteria system and a relative-assessment matrix, complemented by multi-scenario sensitivity analysis. Applied to ten prominent solutions across twenty-nine sub-criteria in four dimensions, the model highlights Performance as the most influential main criterion; at the sub-criterion level, the decisive factors are updating against new threats, threat-detection capability, and policy-customization flexibility; and Zero Trust Architecture emerges as the best overall alternative, with rankings stable under varied weighting scenarios. A managerial takeaway is that foundation controls (e.g., OT-integrated monitoring and ICS-aware detection) consistently remain near the top, while purely deceptive or access-centric options rank lower in this context. The framework contributes an end-to-end picture fuzzy risk-assessment model for smart grid cybersecurity and suggests future work on larger expert panels, cross-utility datasets, and dynamic, periodically refreshed assessments.

18 April 2026 in Mathematics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MCMelike Cari
Melike Cari
BKBetül Kara
Betül Kara
NANezir Aydin
Nezir Aydin
BKBahar Yalcin Kavus
Bahar Yalcin Kavus
TKTolga Kudret Karaca
Tolga Kudret Karaca
EAErtugrul Ayyildiz
Ertugrul Ayyildiz
Equitable prioritization of public investments is increasingly critical as municipalities face constrained budgets, heterogeneous neighborhood needs, and demands for transparent decisions. This paper proposes a fairness-aware group multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) framework for ranking municipal infrastructure investments when budgets are constrained, and neighborhood needs differ. Six alternatives are assessed in the Istanbul case study: flood risk mitigation, inclusive public realm and cooling, smart and energy-efficient municipal assets, walking and cycling infrastructure, healthcare access improvements, and seismic retrofitting of public buildings. The criteria system combines efficiency, implementability, socio-environmental performance, and equity-oriented priorities through five main dimensions and 23 sub-criteria. In addition to cost, feasibility, and service effectiveness, the framework incorporates fairness-related criteria such as baseline need and deficit severity, vulnerability-targeting effectiveness, minimum service guarantee for the worst-off, and priority for low-accessibility centers. Public acceptance and environmental performance are also included. Stakeholder panels provide expert judgments using intuitionistic fuzzy sets, capturing membership, non-membership, and hesitation to reflect uncertainty. Criteria weights are derived with Intuitionistic Fuzzy Step-wise Weight Assessment Ratio Analysis (IF-SWARA), enabling importance elicitation and group aggregation without forcing crisp consensus. Alternatives are then ranked using Intuitionistic Fuzzy Combined Compromise Solution (IF-CoCoSo), which blends additive and multiplicative compromise solutions to balance overall performance with equity objectives. Robustness is assessed through sensitivity analysis by varying the γ parameter within the IF-CoCoSo procedure. A municipal case study demonstrates that healthcare access improvements achieve the highest compromise performance, followed by flood risk mitigation and seismic retrofitting of public buildings, while smart and energy-efficient municipal assets rank last. The findings confirm that explicitly embedding fairness criteria can shift municipal priorities toward alternatives that more directly reduce deprivation, risk, and spatial inequality. The main contribution of this study is not merely empirical application, but the development of a fairness-aware group MCDM framework that operationalizes distributive justice in municipal investment prioritization through a structured set of criteria.

17 November 2025 in Buildings
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EAErtugrul Ayyildiz
Ertugrul Ayyildiz
TKTolga Kudret Karaca
Tolga Kudret Karaca
BKBetül Kara
Betül Kara
BKBahar Yalcin Kavus
Bahar Yalcin Kavus
NANezir Aydin
Nezir Aydin
Effectively managing Construction and Demolition Waste (CDW) requires prioritizing multi-dimensional risks, a task complicated by the inherent uncertainty and subjectivity of expert judgments. While classical methods like Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) and Fine–Kinney (FK) provide a diagnostic structure, they struggle to capture the vagueness in subjective assessments. This study addresses this gap by developing an integrated framework that couples the classical FMEA/FK criteria (Severity, Exposure, Probability, Detectability, Frequency) with Picture-Fuzzy (PiF) multi-criteria decision making. The methodology first elicits criterion importances from 15 experts using PiF Stepwise Weight Assessment Ratio Analysis (PiF-SWARA), which retains approval, indeterminacy, rejection, and refusal degrees to reduce information loss. Subsequently, it ranks 40 risk factors using the PiF Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (PiF-TOPSIS). Results show severity is the most influential criterion, followed by exposure and probability. The framework identifies the highest-priority risks as cumulative pollution with rising complaints, groundwater leakage, and insufficient investment/operating budgets. A sensitivity analysis confirms that environmental and financial risks remain consistently prominent across various weighting scenarios. This harmonized FMEA/FK–PiF-SWARA–TOPSIS approach yields a transparent and defensible prioritization, offering a practical tool for managers to allocate resources effectively, focusing on critical environmental controls and addressing core financial deficiencies in CDW systems.

27 May 2026 in Information Processing & Management
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
AŞAleyna Şahin
Aleyna Şahin
MCMelike Cari
Melike Cari
BKBetül Kara
Betül Kara
EAErtugrul Ayyildiz
Ertugrul Ayyildiz