SUMMARY: The World Health Organisation’s 2022 AWaRe Book provides guidance for the use of 39 antibiotics to treat 35 infections in primary healthcare and hospital facilities. We review the evidence underpinning suggested dosing regimens. Few ( n = 18) population pharmacokinetic studies exist for key oral AWaRe antibiotics, largely conducted in homogenous and unrepresentative populations hindering robust estimates of drug exposures. Databases of minimum inhibitory concentration distributions are limited, especially for community pathogen-antibiotic combinations. Minimum inhibitory concentration data sources are not routinely reported and lack regional diversity and community representation. Of studies defining a pharmacodynamic target for ß-lactams ( n = 80), 42 (52.5%) differed from traditionally accepted 30%–50% time above minimum inhibitory concentration targets. Heterogeneity in model systems and pharmacodynamic endpoints is common, and models generally use intravenous ß-lactams. One-size-fits-all pharmacodynamic targets are used for regimen planning despite complexity in drug-pathogen-disease combinations. We present solutions to enable the development of global evidence-based antibiotic dosing guidance that provides adequate treatment in the context of the increasing prevalence of antimicrobial resistance and, moreover, minimizes the emergence of resistance.
Effective policy to address the global threat of antimicrobial resistance requires robust antimicrobial susceptibility data. Traditional methods for measuring minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) are resource intensive, subject to human error, and require considerable infrastructure. AIgarMIC streamlines and standardizes MIC measurement and is especially valuable for large-scale surveillance activities. MICs were measured using agar dilution for n = 10 antibiotics against clinical Enterobacterales isolates ( n = 1,086) obtained from a large tertiary hospital microbiology laboratory. Escherichia coli ( n = 827, 76%) was the most common organism. Photographs of agar plates were divided into smaller images covering one inoculation site. A labeled data set of colony images was created and used to train a convolutional neural network to classify images based on whether a bacterial colony was present (first-step model). If growth was present, a second-step model determined whether colony morphology suggested antimicrobial growth inhibition. The ability of the AI to determine MIC was then compared with standard visual determination. The first-step model classified bacterial growth as present/absent with 94.3% accuracy. The second-step model classified colonies as “inhibited” or “good growth” with 88.6% accuracy. For the determination of MIC, the rate of essential agreement was 98.9% (644/651), with a bias of −7.8%, compared with manual annotation. AIgarMIC uses artificial intelligence to automate endpoint assessments for agar dilution and potentially increases throughput without bespoke equipment. AIgarMIC reduces laboratory barriers to generating high-quality MIC data that can be used for large-scale surveillance programs. IMPORTANCE: This research uses modern artificial intelligence and machine-learning approaches to standardize and automate the interpretation of agar dilution minimum inhibitory concentration testing. Artificial intelligence is currently of significant topical interest to researchers and clinicians. In our manuscript, we demonstrate a use-case in the microbiology laboratory and present validation data for the model’s performance against manual interpretation.
Antimicrobial susceptibility testing is a key weapon against antimicrobial resistance. Diagnostic microbiology laboratories use one-size-fits-all testing approaches that are often imprecise, inefficient, and inequitable. Here, we report a personalised approach that adapts laboratory testing for urinary tract infection to maximise the number of appropriate treatment options for each patient. We develop and assess susceptibility prediction models for 12 antibiotics on real-world healthcare data using an individual-level simulation study. When combined with decision thresholds that prioritise selection of World Health Organisation Access category antibiotics (those least likely to induce antimicrobial resistance), the personalised approach delivers more susceptible results (results that encourage prescription of that antibiotic) per specimen for Access category antibiotics than a standard testing approach, without compromising provision of susceptible results overall. Here, we show that personalised antimicrobial susceptibility testing could help tackle antimicrobial resistance by safely providing more Access category antibiotic treatment options to clinicians managing urinary tract infection.
Although machine learning models can predict antimicrobial susceptibility from bacterial whole genome sequencing (WGS), state-of-the-art approaches are computationally demanding or dependent on knowledge of genetic resistance determinants. Here, we describe an efficient data-driven approach to predicting minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) by progressively extending and refining predictive genome segments, independent of prior knowledge of resistance determinants. Resultant models had high interpretability — known and potentially novel resistance determinants were captured. Using 762 clinical E. coli strains, 71.6% of predictions were within one dilution of the measured MIC. Models trained with this algorithm generalised better onto external data (F1 score = 0.85) compared with alternative models trained on annotated resistance determinants (F1 = 0.82) or k -mer counts (F1 = 0.74). Computational demands were low (RAM usage 23.6GB vs 38.8GB for k -mer model). These advantages represent an important advance in predicting antimicrobial susceptibility from WGS, with potential applications for clinical diagnostics, drug development, and surveillance.
Amoxicillin-clavulanic acid (AMX-CLV) is a widely used oral β-lactam/β-lactamase inhibitor combination against Escherichia coli . Clinical success is largely confined to urinary tract infections. The mechanistic basis for this site-specific efficacy remains unclear. Using a hollow-fibre infection model to replicate human plasma and urinary pharmacokinetics, we show that plasma-like exposures rapidly select for pre-existing resistant subpopulations; whereas, urinary exposures produce sustained bactericidal activity without resistance emergence. Genomic and transcriptomic analyses following plasma drug exposure reveal that treatment selectively enriches pre-existing resistant lineages already harbouring oxidative-stress-associated mutations that activate the SOS response and drive IS-mediated amplification of blaTEM-1 , leading to β-lactamase hyperproduction and treatment failure. In contrast, the high urinary concentrations of clavulanic acid exert direct antibacterial activity, eradicating these subpopulations. Our findings demonstrate that local pharmacokinetic environments fundamentally shape evolutionary trajectories under β-lactam/β-lactamase inhibitor therapy, explaining the restricted efficacy of AMX-CLV and revealing a dynamic interplay between stress responses, genome plasticity, and drug partitioning that governs treatment outcome.